Meta's Muse knocks about $81 billion off banks, brokers and insurers; Schwab falls 6.1%, Allstate 5.5%
Investors sold companies that profit when customers stay put, on fears that AI agents will shop around for people. Expedia, which signed up with Muse, finished flat.
Investors sold banks, brokers and insurers on Tuesday on fears that Meta's new Muse AI agent, and the rivals that will follow it, could erode what Bloomberg called "consumer inertia": the habit of staying with the same bank account, card or insurer long after a better deal is available. Bloomberg reported that the S&P 500 financials index lost nearly 2% to its lowest close since July, while the broad index finished roughly flat.
The damage, stock by stock
Closing prices from Nasdaq, with the approximate market value lost on the day, calculated from Nasdaq's market-capitalization data:
| Company | Close | Change | Value lost (approx.) |
|---|---|---|---|
| JPMorgan Chase | $340.07 | -3.40% | $31.8 billion |
| Bank of America | $56.22 | -3.00% | $12.2 billion |
| Charles Schwab | $100.36 | -6.10% | $11.3 billion |
| Wells Fargo | $83.15 | -3.92% | $10.3 billion |
| Morgan Stanley | $200.26 | -2.84% | $9.2 billion |
| Allstate | $229.42 | -5.53% | $3.4 billion |
| Progressive | $206.92 | -2.51% | $3.1 billion |
Those seven alone lost about $81 billion in market value. The Financial Select Sector SPDR fund, XLF, closed down 1.99% at $54.79. Card lenders fell too: American Express lost 2.67% and Capital One 2.04%. Goldman Sachs, which has a much smaller consumer business, fell only 0.98%.
The split that tells you what investors are pricing
The clearest signal came from travel. Booking Holdings fell 2.55% and Airbnb 3.01%. Expedia, which announced on Tuesday that travelers will be able to plan and book trips through Muse, closed down just 0.11%, though Expedia did not say when the service will launch.
That fits how Muse actually works today. According to Skift, Muse books flights through a direct feed from travel-technology firm Duffel covering more than 500 airlines, but for hotels it opens a browser and shops sites such as Expedia and Hotels.com the way a person would. Companies with a formal connection get a commercial relationship with the agent. Companies without one become websites the agent visits on its own terms. Amazon has already blocked Muse from its store, Fortune reported.
What the selloff got ahead of
Tuesday's move priced in a possibility, not a result. We found no report from any of these companies of customers leaving because of AI agents. The banks themselves are pushing back on how fast this goes. Also on Tuesday, a group including Bank of America, Capital One, NatWest and ING published principles for "agentic commerce" and warned that the technology is moving faster than consumer protections, Reuters reported. Their concerns include agents typing card details directly into websites and steering users toward payment methods with weaker protections.
The earnings most exposed are the ones that depend on people not comparing prices: low rates on idle cash balances, auto insurance renewals and card fees.
Who it hits
- Traders in financials: on Tuesday the sector traded as an AI-disruption story rather than a rates story. Meta's Connect event on Wednesday, where Fortune said Mark Zuckerberg is expected to show smart-glasses updates, is the next headline risk.
- Small merchants: if agents start doing the shopping, being readable by an agent (clean product data, a checkout that works for a bot) becomes part of getting found. That is the same choice Expedia made on Tuesday, on a much smaller scale.
Background: Meta jumped 11% on Muse on Monday. More at Stocks.
Sources: Bloomberg; Nasdaq closing quotes and market-cap data; Reuters via Investing.com; Skift; Seeking Alpha; Fortune. Value lost is estimated from closing market value and the day's percentage change. This is market information, not investment advice.
Want your business to be the answer?
Get a full package of articles about your business, built so customers, Google and AI assistants can find you.