New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Sun, Nov 22, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · In-home care

Hire an Independent Caregiver or Use an Agency? Texas and Florida Rules, Risks and Duties

Who is the employer, who is licensed, who pays the taxes and who covers a sick day. A plain comparison of hiring a caregiver yourself, using a licensed agency, or using a Florida nurse registry.

In Texas, a caregiver you hire and pay directly is exempt from agency licensing (Health and Safety Code 142.003(a)(13)), so that person holds no agency license and you do the screening. Under IRS Publication 926, a worker you direct is generally your household employee, which can trigger payroll taxes. If an agency provides the worker and controls the work, the worker is not your employee.

Key facts

  • Texas exempts from HCSSA licensing an individual hired and paid directly by the client or the client's family or guardian to provide home health or personal assistance services (Health and Safety Code 142.003(a)(13)).
  • Texas law requires an HCSSA license to provide home health, hospice, habilitation or personal assistance services for pay as a business (Health and Safety Code 142.002).
  • IRS Publication 926 (2026) says a worker is your household employee if you control not only what work is done but how it is done, even if you found the worker through an agency's list.
  • IRS Publication 926 says that if an agency provides the worker and controls what work is done and how, the worker is not your employee.
  • In 2026 a household employer who pays $3,000 or more in cash wages to one household employee must withhold and pay Social Security and Medicare taxes (IRS Publication 926).
  • Florida law (400.506(6)(d)) deems a nurse-registry-referred caregiver an independent contractor of the registry, but IRS Publication 926 uses a separate control test for federal taxes.
  • Florida requires homemaker and companion providers to register with AHCA, including single individuals with no staff, and the registration does not allow hands-on personal care (Florida Statutes 400.509; AHCA).
  • Florida requires level 2 background screening of employees and contractors of home health agencies, nurse registries and companion or homemaker services (Florida Statutes 400.512).
  • Texas Labor Code 406.002 makes workers' compensation coverage generally elective for employers; Florida Statutes 440.02 excludes domestic servants in private homes from workers' compensation 'employment'.

What is the difference between an independent caregiver and an agency?

There are three common ways to get in-home help in Texas and Florida. The legal duties are different for each, and mixing them up is where most families get hurt.

  • Licensed agency. A business holds a state license, employs the caregivers, sets their schedule, trains and supervises them, and sends the bill. In Texas this is a home and community support services agency (HCSSA) under Health and Safety Code chapter 142. In Florida this is a licensed home health agency under chapter 400, Part III.
  • Independent caregiver (direct hire). You find a person, agree on pay and tasks, and pay that person yourself. This is also called hiring privately. The person works for you.
  • Registry or referral service. A registry matches you with caregivers who work on their own. Florida has licensed nurse registries (chapter 400, Part III). Texas treats a registry that operates solely as a clearinghouse as exempt from licensing, if it does not keep official client records, direct client services or pay the provider (Health and Safety Code 142.003(a)(3)).

Cost is one difference, and it is covered in what drives the cost of home care. This page is about legal and safety duties. We do not claim that agencies are cheaper, safer or better, or the reverse. Each option moves duties to a different person, and you should know who holds each duty before you sign.

Is an independent caregiver licensed?

In Texas, generally no. A person hired and paid directly by the client or the client's family or legal guardian to provide home health or personal assistance services is exempt from HCSSA licensing (Health and Safety Code 142.003(a)(13)). That means a privately hired caregiver does not hold an HCSSA license, and the state is not inspecting that person. Do not call such a caregiver "state licensed." The family must do its own screening.

The same statute lists other exemptions that may apply. These include a person who provides sitter-companion services or chore or household services that do not involve personal care, health or health-related services (142.003(a)(15)); an individual whose permanent residence is in the client's residence (142.003(a)(4)); and an individual who is the employee of a consumer or the consumer's fiscal agent under the consumer-directed option (142.003(a)(21)). Texas law also bars a business from providing home health, hospice, habilitation or personal assistance services for pay without a license (142.002).

A caregiver can hold a separate professional license, such as a nurse license, that has nothing to do with the agency exemption. If a nurse or certified nursing assistant works for you privately, ask to see the license and verify it with the issuing board.

In Florida, the answer depends on what the person does. Companion and homemaker services, with no home health service, are exempt from home health licensure but must be registered with the Agency for Health Care Administration (AHCA) (Florida Statutes 400.509). AHCA says single individuals with no staff who provide homemaker or companion services must also register. A registered companion or homemaker may not provide hands-on personal care, such as bathing, feeding or changing clients. Registration is a limited screening step, not a guarantee of quality. Companion and homemaker is defined in 400.462: a companion spends time with or cares for an older or disabled person, accompanies them on outings, and may prepare and serve meals. A homemaker does household chores such as housekeeping, meal planning and shopping.

Our sources note one open question. Florida registration applies to those offering services to the public. Whether a person hired by one family only must register is something to confirm with AHCA before you hire. Call AHCA's home care unit, and ask in writing if you can.

Who is the employer?

This is the most important question, and the answer depends on who controls the work.

IRS Publication 926 (2026) says that you have a household employee if you hire someone to do household work and "you can control not only what work is done, but how it is done." It does not matter whether the work is full time or part time, or that you hired the worker "through an agency or from a list provided by an agency or association." The IRS lists health aides, caretakers and private nurses among household workers.

The IRS also says: "If an agency provides the worker and controls what work is done and how it is done, the worker isn't your employee." And if only the worker controls how the work is done, the worker is self-employed. The IRS describes a self-employed worker as someone who usually provides their own tools and offers services to the general public in an independent business.

What this means for you:

  • Licensed agency. The agency is the employer. The caregiver is the agency's employee. The agency pays payroll taxes, carries any workers' compensation, and handles scheduling.
  • Direct hire. You are generally the employer. You decide the tasks, the schedule and the way work is done, which is what the IRS control test looks at.
  • Florida nurse registry. Florida law deems a registry-referred caregiver an independent contractor and not an employee of the registry, and the registry must tell the patient that it may not monitor, supervise, manage or train the caregiver (Florida Statutes 400.506(6)(d), (e)). That is a state-law label between the caregiver and the registry. It does not settle your federal tax status. If you direct the work, the IRS test may still make the caregiver your employee. Do not assume that a registry label removes your employer duties. Ask a tax professional.

Some people try to treat a caregiver as an independent contractor to avoid taxes. The label you choose does not decide the matter. The facts of control do. Misclassifying an employee can lead to back taxes, interest and penalties. See household employer taxes and Schedule H. IRS Topic 756 says plumbers, contractors and similar business people who offer services to the public as independent contractors are not household employees (IRS Topic 756). A day-to-day caregiver in your home who follows your instructions is rarely in that group.

Do I owe payroll taxes?

If you are the employer, probably yes, once wages pass certain thresholds. The key 2026 federal facts from IRS Publication 926:

  • If you pay a household employee cash wages of $3,000 or more in 2026, you must withhold and pay Social Security and Medicare taxes. The total is 15.3 percent of cash wages, with 7.65 percent as your share and 7.65 percent as the employee's share. You may choose to pay the employee's share yourself.
  • If you pay total cash wages of $1,000 or more in any calendar quarter of 2025 or 2026 to household employees, you also owe federal unemployment (FUTA) tax, 6 percent of the first $7,000 per employee.
  • You report these taxes on Schedule H (Form 1040) with your tax return. Forms W-2 and W-3 for 2026 are due February 1, 2027.
  • You are not required to withhold federal income tax from a household employee unless the employee asks and you agree.
  • Wages paid to your spouse, your child under 21, or your parent (with an exception) generally do not count toward the Social Security and Medicare threshold.
  • You must confirm the worker may legally work in the United States and complete Form I-9.

Details, dates and examples are on our household employer tax page. State taxes are separate. See Texas and Florida. With an agency, you pay the agency's bill, and the agency handles payroll taxes.

Who covers a sick day?

A licensed agency usually has other caregivers and can send a replacement. Ask each agency how quickly, and put the answer in the service agreement. A registry or a direct hire generally cannot send a replacement, because the person works alone. If your caregiver calls out and your parent cannot be left alone, you need a plan B.

Build the plan before you need it:

  • Name a backup person, such as a family member or neighbor, and agree on the signal.
  • Keep a printed medication list, a list of doctors, and the daily routine near the phone or on the refrigerator.
  • Pick a second caregiver or agency to call for short-notice help.
  • Ask the caregiver to give as much notice as possible, and write the notice rule into the agreement.
  • Decide in advance whether sick days and vacation are paid. Our sources do not show a federal or Texas requirement to pay household employees for sick days, so confirm current state rules before you promise or deny pay.

For respite when a family caregiver needs a break, see respite and family caregiver support.

Who carries workers' compensation?

Workers' compensation pays medical bills and some lost wages when a worker is hurt on the job. The rules differ sharply between the two states, so confirm with the state agency before you decide.

Texas. Texas Labor Code 406.002 says that, except for public employers and as otherwise provided by law, an employer "may elect to obtain" workers' compensation coverage. In other words, coverage is generally elective. A household employer who does not carry it may face different legal risks if the worker sues for an injury. The Texas Department of Insurance, Division of Workers' Compensation can explain those risks. Our research could not load the TDI page, so ask the agency or an attorney. See Texas household employer duties.

Florida. Florida Statutes 440.02 says "employment" for workers' compensation does not include service performed by "domestic servants in private homes." The Division of Workers' Compensation says non-construction employers with four or more employees must carry coverage. A single caregiver in a private home therefore generally falls outside the requirement, but confirm any exception with the Division. See Florida household employer duties.

Agencies. A licensed agency is the employer, and any workers' compensation duty falls on the agency. Ask for proof of coverage. Do not accept "we are insured" without a certificate. You can also ask your own homeowner's insurer, in writing, whether the policy covers a caregiver injured in your home. Policies differ and many exclude or limit this. Get the answer before the first shift.

What screening can I do?

Licensed agencies in both states must screen. Direct hires are your job.

What agencies must do

  • Texas. Under 26 TAC 558.247, an HCSSA must run a criminal history check under Health and Safety Code chapter 250 for unlicensed applicants and employees with face-to-face client contact, and must not employ anyone with a barring conviction. It must also search the Nurse Aide Registry and the Employee Misconduct Registry before hiring an unlicensed person and at least every 12 months, and must discharge anyone listed as unemployable. See Texas caregiver criminal history checks and the Texas registries.
  • Florida. Section 400.512 requires a home health agency, nurse registry or companion or homemaker service to require level 2 background screening of employees or contractors under chapter 435 and section 408.809. Level 2 includes fingerprint checks through FDLE and the FBI, plus local checks, and persons screened must be rescreened every 5 years. See Florida level 2 background screening.

What you can do as a family hiring directly

Texas Health and Safety Code 250.003 applies criminal history and registry rules to individual employers in the consumer-directed service option. It does not by itself make registry checks a legal duty for a family hiring privately outside that option, so treat these steps as good practice, not as the law:

  1. Ask for a government photo ID and confirm work eligibility through Form I-9.
  2. Check references by phone. Ask what the person did, for how long, and whether the family would rehire.
  3. Verify any professional license with the issuing board.
  4. Ask in writing for permission to run a criminal background check, and use a lawful method. Ask a lawyer or the state agency about permitted methods, because background check services have their own legal rules.
  5. For Texas, ask your caregiver about checking the registries. Our sources say HHSC-regulated providers use the TULIP portal for these registry searches; whether a private family can use it was not confirmed, so ask HHSC.
  6. Do a trial shift with someone present, and watch how the person treats your relative.
  7. Ask about a driver's license and car insurance if the person will drive your relative.

See independent caregiver interview questions for a full list, and red flags and scams for warning signs.

What can the caregiver legally do?

The scope of what a caregiver may do depends on their license or registration, not on what you wish. See the full guide: what caregivers can legally do in Texas and Florida. Key points for this decision:

  • Texas direct hire. Because the direct hire is exempt from HCSSA licensing, the exemption does not by itself define a list of allowed tasks. Nursing tasks need a nurse license. Do not ask an unlicensed person to perform tasks reserved for nurses.
  • Florida registered companion or homemaker. No hands-on personal care.
  • Florida nurse registry aides. A registry may refer a certified nursing assistant or home health aide to a private residence only if the patient is under a physician's care. The aide is limited to bathing, dressing, toileting, grooming, eating, physical transfer and routine daily activities the patient could do if physically capable, and may not provide medical services reserved for licensed professionals (400.506(6)(b)). A referred person who is not a nurse may perform only services they are certified or trained to perform. Going beyond that can be unauthorized practice of medicine or a Nurse Practice Act violation (400.506(7)).
  • Medications. Florida allows an unlicensed person employed by or under contract to a home health agency to help a medically stable patient with self-administration of routine, regularly scheduled medicines after training (400.488). That help does not include mixing or calculating doses, preparing syringes or any injection. See Florida medication assistance.

When in doubt, ask the doctor and the licensing agency before assigning a task.

Side-by-side comparison: who holds each duty

QuestionLicensed agencyDirect hire (independent caregiver)Florida nurse registry referral
Is there a state license?Agency holds a license (Texas HCSSA, Florida home health agency)Texas: exempt from HCSSA license. Florida: companion or homemaker registration may apply; check with AHCARegistry holds a nurse registry license; the caregivers are referred
Who is the employer?The agencyGenerally you, under the IRS control testState law calls the caregiver an independent contractor of the registry; federal tax status turns on control
Who pays payroll taxes?The agencyYou, if thresholds are met (2026: $3,000 for Social Security and Medicare)Unclear: ask a tax professional; do not assume none are owed
Who screens the caregiver?The agency, under state rules (Texas 26 TAC 558.247; Florida 400.512)YouThe registry screens under 400.512; you can add your own checks
Who covers a sick day?Usually the agency sends a replacement; confirm in writingYouUsually you or the registry finds another referral; confirm in writing
Workers' compensationAgency's duty; ask for proofTexas: elective. Florida: domestic servants excluded. Check with the stateDepends on status; ask the registry and your insurer
Who supervises the work?The agency, under its licenseYouThe registry may not monitor, supervise, manage or train the caregiver
Who handles complaints?Agency first, then HHSC (Texas) or AHCA (Florida)You and law enforcement or APS; no agency license to complain aboutRegistry first, then AHCA
Who reports suspected abuse?Agency staff must report; so can youAnyone who suspects it should reportAnyone who suspects it should report

The table is a summary of the laws cited on this page and is not legal advice. It does not say that any option is better. A direct hire can work well for families that want control and are willing to take on employer duties, and an agency can work well for families that want a business to share the duties. Choose based on your family's needs and your tolerance for administrative work.

Common mistakes families make

These patterns come up again and again when families choose between an agency and a private hire. Each one ties back to a rule above.

  • Treating a registry label as a tax answer. In Florida, the registry statute calls a referred caregiver an independent contractor of the registry. The IRS uses its own control test. If you direct the daily work, assume you may be an employer until a tax professional tells you otherwise.
  • Calling a private caregiver "licensed." In Texas, a directly hired caregiver is exempt from agency licensing. If someone tells you they are state licensed, ask which license, and look it up.
  • Paying cash with no records. Without pay records you cannot show wages, file Schedule H or defend a dispute later. Pay by check or electronic transfer.
  • Assigning nursing tasks to an unlicensed helper. Medication injections, wound care and similar tasks belong to licensed professionals. Ask the doctor who may do what.
  • Skipping the backup plan. Most crises happen on the first sick day. Write the plan when things are calm.
  • Not asking the insurer. Your homeowner's policy may not cover a caregiver hurt in your home. Ask in writing before the first shift.
  • Forgetting your relative's voice. Ask your parent whom they trust, and let them take part in the choice whenever possible.

Where to complain or report, by option

Agency. For a Texas agency, see Texas complaints and client rights. For a Florida agency or registry, see check a Florida home care provider, because AHCA may inspect and fine agencies for violations of chapter 400, Part III (400.484).

Direct hire. There is no agency license for a state agency to enforce. If you suspect abuse, neglect or exploitation, report it. In Texas, call Adult Protective Services at 1-800-252-5400, or 9-1-1 in an emergency. Texas Human Resources Code 48.051 requires a person who has cause to believe an older adult or an adult with a disability is being abused, neglected or exploited to report immediately. In Florida, call the Abuse Hotline at 1-800-962-2873 (24 hours a day), or 911 if the person is in immediate danger. Florida Statutes 415.1034 requires anyone who knows or has reasonable cause to suspect abuse to report. Theft is a crime. Call local police. See Texas reporting and Florida reporting.

What is the safest way to start?

  1. Start with a written list of needs. Hours, tasks, medicines, mobility, memory issues, language, pets, and the home itself.
  2. Decide how much administration you can handle. If you do not want to run payroll, handle a sick day or supervise, an agency removes most of that work. If you want control and can manage payroll and backup care, a direct hire may fit.
  3. Verify the license or registration. Use check a Texas home care agency or check a Florida home care provider.
  4. Put it in writing. Use the service agreement checklist. For a direct hire, write the tasks, schedule, pay rate, pay date, notice rules, house rules and what the caregiver may not do.
  5. Start with a short trial of a few weeks, and review how it is going.
  6. If you hire directly, set up payroll from day one. Get an employer identification number, keep pay records, and calendar the tax dates.
  7. Keep a log of hours and tasks, and keep copies of every pay record.
  8. Stay involved. Visit at different times, check on supplies and medicines, and talk to your relative alone.
  9. Use cameras lawfully. Rules about recording are legal questions. Ask a lawyer before using hidden recording, and tell the caregiver about any visible cameras.

If you are comparing prices, remember to include employer taxes, backup care and insurance in the direct-hire cost, as explained in cost drivers.

How to choose a provider

  • Write down the hours and tasks needed before you call anyone.
  • Decide whether you want a business to share the employer duties.
  • Verify any agency license or registration before signing.
  • For a direct hire, ask a tax professional whether you will be a household employer.
  • Confirm work eligibility and complete Form I-9 for any employee you hire.
  • Check references and verify any professional license.
  • Ask each agency for proof of workers' compensation coverage.
  • Ask your homeowner's insurer in writing about caregiver injuries.
  • Name a backup caregiver and write a sick-day plan.
  • Write the tasks, pay, schedule and notice rules into an agreement.
  • Keep pay records and a log of hours.
  • Report suspected abuse, neglect or theft to the proper hotline right away.

Related in-home care guides

In-home care by state and city

Questions people ask

Is an independent caregiver licensed?

In Texas, a person hired and paid directly by the client or family is exempt from agency licensing under Health and Safety Code 142.003(a)(13), so that person has no agency license. The caregiver may hold a separate professional license, such as nursing. In Florida, companion and homemaker providers must register with AHCA, and the registration does not allow hands-on personal care.

Who is the employer?

Under IRS Publication 926, you are the employer if you control not only what work is done but how it is done, even when you found the worker through an agency's list. If an agency provides the worker and controls the work, the worker is not your employee. A Florida nurse registry label of independent contractor does not settle federal tax status.

Do I owe payroll taxes?

If the caregiver is your household employee and you pay $3,000 or more in cash wages in 2026, you owe Social Security and Medicare taxes, 7.65 percent employer share and 7.65 percent employee share. If you pay $1,000 or more in any calendar quarter, you also owe federal unemployment tax. Report on Schedule H. Ask a tax professional about your facts.

Who covers a sick day?

A licensed agency usually can send a replacement. With a direct hire or a registry referral, you or the registry must find one. Ask each option how fast it can replace a caregiver, and write the answer in the agreement. Prepare a backup person and a printed routine in case a shift is missed.

Who carries workers' compensation?

Agencies are responsible for their own employees. In Texas, employers may elect to carry workers' compensation (Labor Code 406.002). In Florida, the statute excludes domestic servants in private homes from workers' compensation employment (440.02). Confirm with the state agency, and ask your homeowner's insurer in writing before hiring.

What screening can I do?

Agencies must screen under state rules. A family hiring directly can ask for ID, check references, verify any professional license, use a lawful criminal background check and run a trial shift. In Texas, registry checks for private families were not confirmed, so ask HHSC. Treat these steps as good practice, not as a legal duty.

What can the caregiver legally do?

It depends on their license or registration. Florida registered companions and homemakers cannot give hands-on personal care. A Florida nurse registry aide is limited to bathing, dressing, toileting, grooming, eating, transfers and routine daily activities. Nursing tasks require a nurse. Do not assign medical tasks to an unlicensed person.

What is a nurse registry?

In Florida, a nurse registry is a licensed business that matches nurses, certified nursing assistants, home health aides, companions and homemakers, who work as independent contractors, with patients. It is exempt from home health agency licensing but needs its own AHCA license (400.506). It may not monitor, supervise, manage or train the caregiver.

What is the safest way to start?

Write down needs, decide how much administration you can handle, verify the license or registration, put the plan in writing, run a short trial, set up payroll if you hire directly, keep a log, and stay involved. Report suspected abuse or theft immediately.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal or medical advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration