Western Digital rebounds 7% to $442.44 and Seagate 5% to $891.76 as three brokers call the Toshiba selloff overdone
Bernstein says Toshiba would rise from 11.2% to 16.8% of hard-drive capacity even if it doubles output. The arithmetic holds, but it rests on the two leaders growing 25%.
Western Digital rose 7% to $442.44 and Seagate gained 5% to $891.76 on Monday, recovering part of Friday's drop after Toshiba said it would double hard-drive capacity for AI data centers, 24/7 Wall St. reported. Three brokers argued the reaction went too far. We covered the original selloff; this is the reply.
What the three brokers said
Per the same report, Bernstein called the move "a storm in a teacup," Citi said the industry is shipping well below demand, and Morgan Stanley called Friday a "knee-jerk reaction," adding that Toshiba lacks leading-edge capacity and the heat-assisted magnetic recording technology the two leaders already have. Goldman Sachs named Seagate a top tactical pick while rating Western Digital Neutral, yet Western Digital rose more. Flash maker SanDisk rose only 0.6%, so the move was confined to drive makers.
Checking Bernstein's math
Bernstein's case is that if Toshiba doubles exabyte output while Western Digital and Seagate each ship 25% more, Toshiba's share of capacity goes from 11.2% to 16.8%. Working it through: take 100 units of capacity, Toshiba at 11.2 and the other two at 88.8. Toshiba doubles to 22.4; the others grow to 111.0. Toshiba's share is 22.4 divided by 133.4, or 16.8%. The figure is right, but it depends on the 25% growth assumption. If demand does not carry the leaders that far, Toshiba's share lands higher. Our own earlier illustration, with the leaders standing still, put it near 18%.
What this does and does not settle
A one-day rebound does not answer the question the market asked on Friday: whether a third supplier at a larger scale changes pricing for drives sold years ahead. It says analysts at three firms think supply stays short. Toshiba's plan targets fiscal 2027, so there is time for either view to be tested by shipment and pricing data.
For the readers who actually buy the drives, such as data-center operators and the integrators that supply small businesses with storage, the practical point is that a third supplier is more likely to matter for availability than for next quarter's price.
Sources: 24/7 Wall St.; Bernstein, Citi, Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs comments as reported there. Prices as reported for Monday, October 5, 2026. Some data may be delayed. This is market information, not investment advice.
Want your business to be the answer?
Get a full package of articles about your business, built so customers, Google and AI assistants can find you.
New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

