Local Guide · Home alarm and security systems
Outdoor Lighting, Landscaping and Home Hardening: What Police and Researchers Recommend
What the research on lighting and crime really shows, what police and sheriff guides say about shrubs, fences and timers, and the Texas and Florida rules that affect your yard.
A New York City experiment found extra street lighting cut outdoor nighttime crime in public housing, but it did not test home porch lights. Police guides advise lighting entrances and walkways, shrubs under 3 feet, tree canopies above 7 feet, clear sightlines, and signs of occupancy. Check HOA, city and Florida coastal lighting rules first.
Key facts
- A randomized experiment in New York City public housing (NBER Working Paper 25798, May 2019) found street lighting reduced outdoor nighttime index crimes by at least 36 percent, accounting conservatively for spillovers.
- The same paper says about 11 percent of index crimes on those campuses occur outdoors at night, so the overall effect on index crime was about 4 percent, and the lights were temporary towers placed at 40 of 80 selected developments.
- A Santa Barbara County Sheriff's CPTED guide advises keeping shrubs no higher than 36 inches and tree canopies no lower than 7 feet, and lighting yards so a person can be seen at 25 feet.
- Houston Police advise lighting around doors, walkways and driveways, mounting lights high and out of reach, using timers or photo cells, and choosing non-glare soft lighting with downward shielding.
- The Florida Sheriffs Association advises motion-sensing outdoor lights near entrances and dark areas, using timers or smart systems for indoor lights when away, and keeping sightlines clear from the street to the front door.
- Texas Health and Safety Code ch. 425 sets lighting rules for fixtures paid for with state funds; the text we loaded does not address private residential lighting.
- Florida Stat. 161.163 directs the state to adopt guidelines for local beachfront lighting rules to protect nesting sea turtles; the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission lists local lighting ordinances for 27 counties.
- Tex. Prop. Code 202.023(b) bars a Texas property owners' association from enforcing a covenant that prevents an owner from installing security measures including a security camera, motion detector or perimeter fence, with exceptions.
- The Florida Sheriffs Association says a USPS hold mail request is effective for up to 30 days.
Does outdoor lighting deter burglars?
The honest answer is: better lighting probably helps, but the strongest evidence is about street lighting and public places, not the porch light on a single house. Here is what the research does and does not show.
The New York City lighting experiment
Economists and criminologists Aaron Chalfin, Benjamin Hansen, Jason Lerner and Lucie Parker ran a randomized experiment in New York City. Their paper is NBER Working Paper 25798, dated May 2019, titled Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City. We read the paper. These are the facts we can report from it:
- Design. The New York City Police Department provided a list of 80 high-priority public housing developments from among 340. The researchers randomly placed 40 into a treatment group that received new lighting and 40 into a control group. Temporary light towers were installed from March through August 2016.
- Result. After accounting for possible spatial spillovers, the authors found lighting led to at least a 36 percent reduction in outdoor nighttime index crimes. Index crimes are the serious offenses the police count, such as robbery and assault.
- Overall effect. The paper says about 11 percent of index crimes on those campuses occur outdoors at night. So a 36 percent cut in those crimes means about a 4 percent cut in all index crimes on the campuses.
- Daytime and spillovers. The authors say they did not detect clear spillover effects, but their tests were underpowered. Daytime estimates were negative but too imprecise to be confident.
Limits you should know
- The setting was public housing campuses in a large city with high crime rates, not single-family homes in suburbs.
- The lights were very bright temporary towers, not a normal porch fixture.
- The paper measures outdoor nighttime street-type crimes in the police data, not residential burglary of a house.
- It was a working paper. NBER notes working papers are circulated for discussion and have not been peer-reviewed by the NBER. We cite the version we loaded.
- The authors say the effect on crime would be cost-beneficial "should the impact of lighting persist over time," which they did not test.
Takeaway: lighting can reduce crime in public spaces, which supports lit streets, entries and shared areas. It does not prove that a light on your garage will prevent a burglary. Police guides recommend it as one part of a layered approach, alongside locks, sightlines and alarms. See our guide on door and window sensors for the burglary entry data we could confirm.
Which lighting is recommended: motion, dusk-to-dawn or timers?
Police and sheriff guides give a mix of advice. They are not studies, but they reflect what crime prevention officers see.
| Option | What guides say | Trade-offs |
|---|---|---|
| Dusk-to-dawn lighting (photocell or timer) | The Santa Barbara County Sheriff's CPTED guide says to consider "dusk to dawn" lighting as an alternative to motion detection lighting. Houston Police advise using inexpensive timers or photo electric cells to turn lights on and off at dusk and dawn. | Always on, so it lights paths for you and visitors. Uses more electricity than motion-only lights. Glare can cause problems for neighbors and cameras. |
| Motion-sensing lights | The Florida Sheriffs Association advises installing outdoor lights, especially motion-sensing ones, near entrances and dark areas. | Surprises people who approach, and shows you when something moves. Can trigger from animals, wind and passing traffic. May not help people see the area in the dark when the light is off. |
| Timers and smart plugs | Houston Police and the Florida Sheriffs Association advise timed or smart lighting to make the home look lived in. | Easy and cheap, but a fixed pattern can look fake. Smart plugs connect to your Wi-Fi, so secure them. See below. |
How to place and choose fixtures
- Light the doors first. Houston Police advise lights in areas around doors, walkways and driveways.
- Mount high. Houston Police advise locating outside lights high and out of reach.
- Avoid glare and shadows. Houston Police say non-glare soft lighting and downward shielding is optimal. The Santa Barbara guide says lighting should highlight entryways without creating harsh effects or shadowy hiding places.
- Light so you can see a person. The Santa Barbara guide says sidewalks and all areas of the yard should be well lit during darkness with the ability to see someone at 25 feet.
- Keep branches from blocking light. The Santa Barbara guide says to trim trees to avoid blocked light.
- Check bulbs. The Florida Sheriffs Association advises replacing burnt-out bulbs and fixing broken fixtures during routine checks.
- Light the numbers. The Santa Barbara guide says the property address should be visible from the street and ideally backlit, with numbers at least 5 inches high. Houston Police advise large reflective numbers at least 3 inches high on your house and mailbox so police and emergency personnel can find your home quickly.
Lights and cameras
Bright lights near a camera lens can wash out the picture, and a very dark yard can leave a camera with a grainy image. We did not find a named test, so follow the camera maker's instructions on aiming and placement, and test at night. The Santa Barbara guide recommends at least one camera angled and zoomed to record a clear picture of each person's face at entry doors or hallways. See indoor and outdoor security cameras. Check the recording laws in Texas and Florida before you add audio.
What is CPTED?
CPTED stands for Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design. It is the idea that how a place is designed and kept up can make crime more difficult and less likely. The Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office guide says CPTED principles have been helping people create safer environments since the 1970s and that its guidelines are most useful to consider when building or remodeling, and are complemented by Neighborhood Watch. The same guide lists these primary concepts:
- Natural surveillance. Using the location of physical features, lighting, activity and people to maximize visibility, creating a risk of detection for intruders.
- Access control. Using people, devices and natural measures to create a perception of risk to offenders and deny them access to targets, and to guide wanted visitors safely through the environment.
- Territoriality (territorial reinforcement). Using physical features and activities to express ownership and control, and delineating private and semi-private spaces.
- Target hardening and maintenance. Using locks and barriers, and keeping the other measures working over time.
A caution: CPTED guides are made by police and planners, and the evidence behind each recommendation varies. The New York lighting study is one of the few randomized tests we found, and it concerns streetlights. We did not load the National Crime Prevention Council's own CPTED materials, so we cite the sheriff's guide, the Houston Police Department and the Florida Sheriffs Association instead.
CPTED in plain words for a house
| Idea | Simple home example |
|---|---|
| Natural surveillance | Windows facing the street, a clear view of the front door from the street and driveway, low shrubs, good lighting |
| Access control | One clear front walk to the door, locked gates, thorny plants under windows, no trees giving access to a roof |
| Territoriality | Hedges, low fences or gates marking the property line, a tidy yard that shows someone cares |
| Target hardening and maintenance | Strong locks, lights that work, trimmed plants, repaired fences |
How should I trim shrubs and trees for security?
Two numbers appear in the police guides we loaded:
- Shrubs: no higher than 36 inches (3 feet) and tree canopies: no lower than 7 feet, to give maximum viewing to and from the house and to leave no hiding places (Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office CPTED guide).
Houston Police advise trimming shrubbery and trees so doors and windows are visible from the street, and pruning trees on a second floor so a thief cannot use them to reach a window. The Florida Sheriffs Association says to trim trees and shrubs near doors and windows to remove hiding spots and keep sightlines clear from the street to your front door. We did not find a single Texas or Florida statewide height rule, so use these as guidelines and check your local code and HOA rules.
Plants that help and plants that hurt
- Help: Low plants and thorny or "hostile" plants under windows and along fences. Houston Police advise planting thorny, hostile plants along fences and near windows. The Santa Barbara guide says to place thorny defensible plants under windows and other vulnerable spots. The Florida Sheriffs Association also advises thorny bushes under windows.
- Hurt: Tall hedges near doors, dense evergreens against windows, climbing plants on trellises that lead to a second floor, and large trees whose limbs reach a roof or balcony. The Santa Barbara guide says to keep trees or exterior buildings from roof and second-story balcony or window access.
Florida and Texas climate notes
In both states, trimming also reduces storm damage. Before hurricane season, which the National Weather Service says runs June 1 to November 30, ask a licensed arborist about trimming. We did not load Texas or Florida arborist rules or city tree ordinances, which can limit what you may cut, especially for protected or heritage trees. Call your city before removing a large tree.
Other yard items
- Do not leave ladders or tools outside, since they can help a person get in (Houston Police and the Florida Sheriffs Association).
- Lock down air conditioning units (Santa Barbara guide).
- Designate a delivery spot that is visible from inside but not from the street (Florida Sheriffs Association). See package theft and porch pirates.
- Mow lawns and remove clutter, since neglected yards can signal that a home is vacant (Florida Sheriffs Association).
Do fences and gates help?
Fences define your space, which is the "territoriality" part of CPTED, and a locked gate is a barrier. But a tall solid fence can also hide a person working on a door or window from the street. The guides we loaded lean toward fences you can see through:
- Houston Police: "A good fence should not block visibility," and gates on fenced yards should be locked with good quality padlocks.
- Santa Barbara County Sheriff's guide: use metal tubular gates and fences or fences made of materials where visibility is heightened, and mark property boundaries, where possible, with hedges, low fences or gates.
- Florida Sheriffs Association: use fencing that defines your property but still allows visibility, and use hedges, flower beds or low fences to mark boundaries.
Rules that can affect fences
Texas HOAs. Tex. Prop. Code 202.023(b) says a property owners' association may not adopt or enforce a restrictive covenant that prevents an owner from building or installing security measures, including a security camera, motion detector or perimeter fence. But 202.023(c) lets an association regulate the type of fencing and prohibit fencing that blocks a license area, sidewalk or drainage easement, and it may prohibit a security camera in a place other than the owner's private property. The section was amended by S.B. 711 effective September 1, 2025, does not apply to condominiums or master mixed-use property owners' associations, and lets owners keep perimeter or front fencing installed before certain dates. Read the current text before you build. See HOA security camera rules in Texas.
Florida HOAs and condos. The Florida homeowners' association and condominium statutes we loaded do not have specific provisions on fences or lights for security, apart from Fla. Stat. 720.304(6), which lets an HOA parcel owner display a sign of reasonable size provided by a contractor for security services within 10 feet of any entrance to the home. Fence and lighting rules come from your recorded declaration, rules and the board. See HOA security camera rules in Florida.
City and county rules. Fence height, setbacks, materials and permits are set by local zoning and building codes. We did not load the codes for Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, Miami, Tampa, Orlando or Jacksonville, so we do not state their rules. Call the city's planning or code office and ask about fence permits for your address.
Should I leave lights on when I am away? Are timers and smart plugs worth it?
Making a home look lived in is a common recommendation. The Houston Police brochure says when traveling, keep your home looking lived-in by having grass cut, mail and newspapers picked up, and lights turned on and off. The Florida Sheriffs Association advises using timers or smart systems to turn indoor lights on and off when you are away, and notes that mail should not pile up.
What to do
- Use timers or smart plugs for a few lamps, in rooms visible from outside, set to turn on at dusk and off at a normal bedtime. Vary the times if your device lets you.
- Use a photocell for outdoor lights so they come on without help.
- Keep the yard maintained. Arrange for someone to cut the grass. The Florida Sheriffs Association says neglected yards signal vacancy.
- Stop mail and deliveries. The Florida Sheriffs Association says a USPS hold mail request is effective for up to 30 days, or ask a neighbor to collect mail, newspapers and flyers.
- Do not announce your trip. The Florida Sheriffs Association advises not posting vacation schedules or "out of town" updates on social media, and Houston Police advise never leaving notes on your door that reveal that your home is not occupied.
- Ask neighbors to watch your home. The Florida Sheriffs Association also suggests asking whether your local sheriff has a residential check program.
- Do not leave ladders or tools outside.
Are smart plugs worth it?
They are an easy way to run lamps on a schedule from your phone. Their weak point is security. CISA's home network guidance says to change default passwords, use the strongest Wi-Fi encryption available, turn off remote router management and keep firmware updated. NIST's IR 8425 report lists baseline cybersecurity capabilities for consumer internet-connected devices. We did not find a named, dated cost-benefit study of smart plugs versus plain timers, so we do not make a claim. A plain mechanical timer has no network risk.
For longer absences, snowbirds and vacation homes, see security for vacation homes and snowbirds. A monitored alarm and cameras do more than timers. See do I need a home security system?
How should I secure sliding doors, garages and windows from the outside?
Lighting and landscaping support hardware, they do not replace it. These points come from the police guides above.
- Sliding glass doors. Houston Police advise an anti-lifting device and a secondary locking device. The Florida Sheriffs Association says to use track locks or a solid rod or dowel in the track.
- Garage. The Santa Barbara guide says garage door openers are not locks and to make sure the door cannot be manually opened even with the opener attached. The Florida Sheriffs Association says to lock the garage and secure the door between the garage and the house.
- Windows. Houston Police note that windows have latches, not locks, and advise secondary locking devices. The Santa Barbara guide says all windows should have locks and advises thorny plants under them.
- Doors. Solid core or metal doors, a deadbolt with a one-inch throw, a strike plate with 3-inch screws and pinned hinges. See smart locks, deadbolts and door hardware.
- Hurricane openings. In hurricane areas, FLASH says to protect every unprotected opening, including windows, entry and garage doors, skylights, sliding doors and gable vents. Design lighting and landscaping so that loose items can be stored and branches cannot hit openings.
Our guide to door and window sensors covers what to place on those openings for an alarm.
What do dark-sky and local lighting ordinances say in Texas and Florida?
You may have heard that lights must be shielded or turned off. The answer depends on where you live.
Texas
Texas Health and Safety Code chapter 425, "Regulation of Certain Outdoor Lighting," sets conditions for outdoor lighting fixtures installed, replaced, maintained or operated with state funds. Section 425.002(a) requires new or replacement fixtures with a rated output above 1,800 lumens to be cutoff luminaires, with other conditions, and 425.002(c) lists exemptions such as temporary emergency lighting and a compelling safety interest. The text we loaded does not address private residential lighting and does not show county or local provisions. So this chapter does not tell you what to do with your own porch light. Texas cities and counties that adopt dark-sky or lighting ordinances do so under their own rules, which we did not load for Houston, Dallas, San Antonio or Austin. Call the city before installing large or high-output fixtures, and ask whether a lighting ordinance applies.
Florida
Fla. Stat. 161.163 directs the state Department of Environmental Protection to designate coastal areas used for sea turtle nesting and to adopt rules with guidelines for local regulations that control beachfront lighting. The Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission lists local sea turtle lighting ordinances for 27 counties, along with their municipalities, with adoption or update years. It lists, for example, Atlantic Beach, Jacksonville Beach and Neptune Beach in Duval County, and several beach cities in Miami-Dade County. It lists Hillsborough and Pinellas counties with no county lighting ordinance (some municipalities in Pinellas are listed). The FWC page does not describe homeowner requirements such as shielding or turn-off times. For specifics, read your local ordinance or ask code enforcement. If you live near a nesting beach, outdoor lights that shine on the beach may be regulated, and violations can lead to citations. Orlando and inland areas are not coastal nesting areas, but check local rules.
HOAs
Some associations regulate light color, brightness or fixtures in their rules. Check your declaration and architectural guidelines before you install floodlights or change fixtures. In Texas, 202.023 protects owners' security cameras, motion detectors and perimeter fences with exceptions, but it does not address floodlights by name.
Good-neighbor practice
Aim lights down and away from neighbors' windows. Houston Police recommend downward shielding. A bright light shining into a neighbor's bedroom can lead to complaints even where no rule exists.
How do I get a professional home security survey?
Many police and sheriff offices offer help. The Houston Police brochure lists the Office of Community Affairs at 713-308-3200 for general information, and the Santa Barbara County Sheriff's guide says it provides CPTED reviews as a community service at no cost (that is California). We did not confirm which Texas and Florida departments offer a home survey, or what it includes, in the sources we loaded. Call the non-emergency number of your police department or sheriff's office and ask whether they do home security surveys or have a crime prevention specialist.
When you get a survey, ask the reviewer to look at:
- Lighting at doors, walkways, driveways and the back yard.
- Sightlines from the street to the front door.
- Shrub and tree heights and branch access to roofs.
- Locks, strike plates and hinges.
- Sliding doors, windows and the garage.
- Address numbers that can be read from the street at night.
- Where cameras and sensors would help.
Then make a priority list, starting with the cheapest, strongest steps: trimming, light bulbs, locks and screws. Our home security checklist before you buy covers alarm and camera buying.
How to choose a provider
- Light every entry door, walkway and driveway with shielded, non-glare fixtures mounted high.
- Use a photocell or timer for dusk-to-dawn lights, and motion lights for dark side areas.
- Trim shrubs to 36 inches and raise tree canopies to 7 feet or more where practical.
- Keep sightlines clear from the street to your front door.
- Plant thorny or hostile plants under windows and along fences.
- Trim trees so they cannot be used to reach a roof, balcony or second-floor window.
- Put large reflective address numbers on the house and mailbox.
- Lock gates and the garage, and put away ladders and tools.
- Use timers or smart plugs for lamps when away, and stop or hold mail for up to 30 days.
- Check your HOA, city and, in Florida coastal areas, sea turtle lighting rules before changing fixtures.
Related home alarm and security systems guides
- Smart Locks, Deadbolts and Door Hardware: What Actually Improves Security
- Door and Window Sensors, Motion Detectors and Glass-Break Sensors: What to Install and Where
- Can a Texas HOA Restrict Security Cameras, Doorbells and Alarm Signs?
- Florida HOA and Condo Rules on Security Cameras, Doorbells and Alarms
- Indoor and Outdoor Security Cameras: Types, Placement, Storage Math and Legal Limits in Texas and Florida
- Securing a Second Home or Snowbird Property in Florida and Texas
- Package Theft and Porch Pirates: Laws, Penalties, Prevention and How to Report in Texas and Florida
- Home Security Buyer's Checklist: 25 Questions to Ask Before You Sign (Texas and Florida)
Home alarm and security systems by state and city
Questions people ask
Does outdoor lighting deter burglars?
The strongest evidence is a New York City experiment in public housing where added street lighting cut outdoor nighttime index crimes by at least 36 percent. It did not test home porch lights or burglary. Police guides recommend lighting doors, walkways and driveways as part of a layered plan with locks and sightlines.
Which lighting type is recommended: motion or dusk-to-dawn?
Guides differ. One sheriff's guide suggests dusk-to-dawn lighting as an alternative to motion lights. The Florida Sheriffs Association suggests motion-sensing lights near entrances and dark areas. Houston Police advise timers or photocells. Many homes use dusk-to-dawn on entrances and motion lights on side areas.
How should I trim shrubs and trees for security?
A sheriff's CPTED guide advises shrubs no higher than 36 inches and tree canopies no lower than 7 feet, so people can see to and from the house and nobody can hide. Houston Police advise trimming so doors and windows are visible and pruning trees that give access to second-floor windows.
What is CPTED?
CPTED means Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design. It uses natural surveillance, access control, territorial reinforcement and target hardening with maintenance to make crime harder. It covers lighting, plant heights, fences and entrances, and works together with locks and neighbors who watch out for each other.
Do fences and gates help?
They define your space and a locked gate is a barrier. Police guides prefer fences you can see through, since a solid tall fence can hide someone at a door. In Texas an HOA cannot bar an owner's perimeter fence under 202.023, with exceptions. Check local fence rules and permits.
Should I leave lights on when away?
Make the home look lived in with timers or smart plugs on a few lamps, a photocell on outdoor lights, a mowed yard and held or collected mail. A USPS hold can last up to 30 days. Do not post travel plans online or leave notes on the door.
How should I secure sliding doors, garages and windows?
Use an anti-lift device and a secondary lock or a rod in the track for sliding doors, lock the garage and the door into the house, and use secondary locks on windows. Remember a garage door opener is not a lock. See our door hardware guide for details.
Are timers and smart plugs worth it?
A plain timer is cheap and has no network risk. A smart plug adds phone control and schedules but connects to your Wi-Fi, so change default passwords, update firmware and use strong encryption, as CISA advises. We found no named cost-benefit study, so choose based on how often you travel.
Sources
- NBER Working Paper 25798, Reducing Crime Through Environmental Design: Evidence from a Randomized Experiment of Street Lighting in New York City (May 2019)
- Santa Barbara County Sheriff's Office, CPTED Residential Guidelines
- Houston Police Department, Burglary Prevention for Your Home brochure
- Florida Sheriffs Association, How to Prevent a Home Burglary
- U.S. Bureau of Justice Statistics, Victimization During Household Burglary (September 2010)
- Texas Health and Safety Code ch. 425 (Regulation of Certain Outdoor Lighting)
- Florida Statutes 161.163 (sea turtle protection; local beachfront lighting guidelines)
- Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, Local Sea Turtle Lighting Ordinances
- Texas Property Code ch. 202 (HOA security measures)
- Florida Statutes 720.304 (HOA owners' rights)
- CISA, Home Network Security
- NIST IR 8425, Profile of the IoT Core Baseline for Consumer IoT Products
- FLASH, Protect Your Windows
- National Weather Service, Hurricane Safety Tips and Resources
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


