New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Thu, Nov 19, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · Roofing

Roofing Contingency Agreements and Insurance Authorizations: Sign or Don't?

What the one-page 'inspection' or 'claim authorization' a roofer hands you actually does, how it differs from a full contract, an AOB and a direction to pay, and what Texas and Florida law say about it.

A roofing contingency agreement is a contract that says if your insurer approves your claim, you will hire that roofer, usually at the insurance price. It can be binding, and many include cancellation fees. You do not need to sign one to get an inspection or to file a claim. The safer path is to call your insurer first, get written itemized bids, and sign a full contract only after you know what the claim covers.

Key facts

  • Florida contractors may not give an insured an agreement authorizing repairs without a good-faith itemized estimate of services and materials (Fla. Stat. 489.147(2)(e)).
  • Florida contractors may not interpret policy provisions, advise on coverage, or adjust a claim unless licensed as public adjusters (Fla. Stat. 489.147(2)(d)).
  • Texas contractors may not act as public adjusters or advertise to adjust claims on property they may repair, even with a power of attorney (Tex. Ins. Code 4102.163).
  • For Florida policies issued on or after Jan. 1, 2023, any attempted assignment of post-loss insurance benefits is void (Fla. Stat. 627.7152).
  • Florida's consumer advocate says you are not required to sign a direction to pay to have work done, and warns it may let the insurer pay the contractor before work is complete (Florida DFS).
  • After a Governor-declared emergency, Florida owners can cancel a roof contract within 10 days or by the official start date without penalty (Fla. Stat. 489.147(6)).
  • Door-to-door sales over $25 can be cancelled until midnight of the 3rd business day under federal, Texas and Florida law (FTC; Tex. Bus. & Com. Code 601; Fla. Stat. 501.025).
  • Texas public adjusters' fees are capped at 10% of the settlement; Florida's cap is 10% after declared emergencies (for a year) and 20% otherwise (Tex. Ins. Code 4102.104; Fla. Stat. 626.854).

What is a roofing contingency agreement?

A contingency agreement is a contract with a condition. The condition is your insurance claim. The typical deal reads like this: 'If your insurance company approves the claim for roof replacement, you agree that we will do the work for the amount the insurer approves, plus your deductible.'

It is usually short. It might be titled 'Inspection Agreement,' 'Claim Authorization,' 'Customer Agreement,' 'Work Authorization,' or 'Insurance Agreement.' It is often signed on a tablet in your driveway, minutes after a free inspection.

Common clauses include:

  • Exclusive right to do the work if the claim is approved.
  • Price set by the insurer's estimate (sometimes called 'insurance price' or 'price per insurance scope') rather than a fixed price.
  • Cancellation fee if you cancel after approval, either a flat amount or a percentage of the claim value. Terms vary widely.
  • Authorization to communicate with your insurer, receive copies of estimates, or 'meet the adjuster.'
  • Direction to pay or payment authorization telling the insurer to include the contractor on checks or pay the contractor directly.
  • Supplements: permission to ask the insurer for more money as the job goes.

Not every contingency agreement includes every clause. That is the point: you have to read the one in front of you.

Is a contingency agreement a binding contract?

Often, yes. A signed document with an offer, acceptance and something of value exchanged (the roofer's inspection and services for your promise to hire them) can be an enforceable contract, even if the work depends on a future event. Whether a specific agreement holds up depends on its wording, whether the roofer complied with state notice rules, and whether any cancellation right applies.

Three things can make a contingency agreement weaker or cancellable:

  1. You signed at home and are still inside a cooling-off period. The FTC rule and Texas and Florida home-solicitation laws give you until midnight of the 3rd business day to cancel most door-to-door sales over $25.
  2. In Florida, required roof-contract notices are missing. Florida roof contracts must include a notice about banned inducements (gifts, deductible waivers). If it is missing, you may void the contract within 10 days. Contracts signed during a declared emergency must also contain the 14-point bold cancellation notice, and every residential roof contract must contain the 14-point bold statement advising you to contact your insurer before signing.
  3. In Florida, the contractor is unlicensed. A contract entered by an unlicensed contractor is unenforceable by that contractor.

Even when you have a strong argument, a contractor may still try to collect a fee or file a lien. If that happens, talk to a lawyer. This page is general information, not legal advice.

Contingency agreement vs full contract vs AOB vs direction to pay

These four documents get mixed up at the kitchen table. They do very different things.

DocumentWhat it doesWho controls the claim moneyStatus in FloridaStatus in Texas
Contingency agreementPromises the job to the roofer if the claim is approved, usually at the insurer's priceYou, unless it includes a direction to payAllowed, but the roof contract must contain required notices, and post-emergency cancellation rights applyAllowed; deductible notice required for insurance-paid contracts of $1,000 or more
Full construction contractFixed scope, materials, price, schedule and warrantyYou pay the roofer per the payment scheduleMust include lien notice (over $2,500), Recovery Fund notice (over $2,500), and roof notices under s. 489.147Deductible notice; homestead and residential lien disclosures (see our contract checklist)
Assignment of benefits (AOB)Transfers your post-loss insurance rights to the contractor, who then deals with the insurer and can sue itThe contractorVoid for policies issued on or after Jan. 1, 2023No AOB ban in our sources, but a contractor may not act as your public adjuster
Direction to pay (DTP)Tells the insurer to pay the contractor directly or name it on checks; you keep the claimShared or shifted toward the contractorDFS says you are not required to sign one to get work doneNot required; check your mortgage and policy terms

A DTP can look harmless. Florida's consumer advocate warns that it 'may require the insurance company to pay the contractor directly (sometimes before work is complete)' and to watch for language letting a contractor submit claims or ask for payment from your insurer without consulting you first. Whether a particular DTP or 'authorization' is treated as an illegal assignment under Florida's AOB ban depends on its wording; if a document gives the contractor your rights under the policy, ask an attorney before you sign.

For the Florida AOB rules in detail, see Florida's AOB ban and roofing contracts.

Is a contingency agreement legal in Florida after the AOB ban?

The 2022 AOB ban did not outlaw contingency agreements. It voids assignments of post-loss benefits under residential and commercial property policies issued on or after January 1, 2023. A contingency agreement that only promises the work to a contractor, and does not transfer your rights under the policy, is a different thing.

But Florida added roof-specific rules that apply to these agreements:

  • No inducements. Contractors may not offer a rebate, gift, gift card, cash, coupon, deductible waiver or anything of value for letting them inspect your roof or for making a roof claim.
  • No claim advice or adjusting. Contractors may not interpret your policy, advise you on coverage, or adjust the claim for you unless licensed as a public adjuster.
  • Itemized estimate first. A contractor may not give you an agreement authorizing repairs without a good-faith itemized estimate of services and materials for repairs under a property insurance claim.
  • Required notices. Roof contracts must include the inducement-ban notice (missing it gives you a 10-day right to void), the 14-point bold 'contact your insurance company' statement on the signature page, and, after a declared emergency, the 14-point bold cancellation notice.
  • Penalties. Violations can bring fines up to $10,000 each, and acts of paid door knockers count as the contractor's acts.

So a Florida one-page 'authorization' with no itemized estimate, signed during a free inspection, may already conflict with s. 489.147. Florida's DFS has a blunt message for storm victims: 'Following storm damage, DON'T SIGN ANYTHING. Call our helpline first!' The number is 1-877-693-5236.

What do Texas rules say?

Texas has no roof-specific contingency statute in the sources we reviewed, but several laws shape these agreements:

  • No contractor adjusting. Texas Insurance Code 4102.163 says a contractor may not act as a public adjuster, or advertise to adjust claims, for any property where it provides or may provide contracting services. That applies even if the contractor holds an adjuster license or a power of attorney. A contingency agreement that lets the roofer 'handle your claim' is a warning sign.
  • Deductible notice. A contract for goods or services reasonably expected to be paid from a property insurance claim, with a price of $1,000 or more, must include a 12-point bold notice that Texas law requires the insured to pay the deductible.
  • No deductible games. Waiving, absorbing or rebating the deductible without the insurer's consent is a Class B misdemeanor. Insurers with replacement cost coverage may hold back the depreciation payment until you prove you paid the deductible.
  • Home solicitation. Door-to-door sales over $25 can be cancelled until midnight of the 3rd business day, and a merchant is not entitled to compensation for services performed under a canceled transaction.
  • Homestead formalities. To have a lien on a homestead, a roofer needs a written contract signed before work begins, signed by both spouses if you are married, and filed with the county clerk. A tablet signature by one spouse during an inspection may not meet that standard. See roofing liens.

More on Texas rules: Texas roofing laws on deductibles and contracts.

What happens if I sign and the claim is denied?

Read your agreement, but in most contingency agreements, a denial means the condition never happened, so you owe nothing for the roof. Problems arise when:

  • The agreement charges an inspection fee or 'claim services' fee whatever the outcome.
  • The roofer pushes you to dispute the denial, reopen the claim, or hire a public adjuster or lawyer they recommend.
  • The roofer offers to replace the roof anyway at a cash price you never negotiated.
  • The agreement treats a partial approval (a repair, not a replacement) as 'approval' that triggers the contract.

If a claim is denied and you think it is wrong, your options are your own: ask the insurer for the written reason, request appraisal if your dispute is about the amount, file a complaint with TDI or DFS, or hire a licensed public adjuster or attorney. See roof claim denied: what to do.

Can I use a different roofer after signing?

Possibly, but it can cost you. Your options depend on timing and what you signed:

  1. Inside 3 business days of a door-to-door signing: cancel in writing under the FTC rule and your state's home-solicitation law. You don't need a reason.
  2. Florida, after a declared emergency: if you signed within 180 days of the event, cancel within 10 days or by the official start date (when final materials start going on, a permit issues, or a code-compliant temporary repair is made), whichever comes first. Send it by certified mail or another method with proof.
  3. Florida, missing notice: if the inducement-ban notice is missing, you can void within 10 days.
  4. Outside those windows: check the cancellation clause. Some agreements allow cancellation before the claim is approved. Others charge a fee after approval.

If the roofer demands a cancellation fee, ask for it in writing with the basis for the amount. A fee that bears no relation to work actually done (for example, a percentage of a claim the roofer never worked on) may be challengeable as an unenforceable penalty, depending on state law and the facts. That is a question for a consumer attorney, not a door knocker. Don't pay a fee just because a salesperson says you must.

What is a cancellation fee in a roofing contingency agreement?

It is a clause that says if you back out after the claim is approved, you pay the roofer something. You will see:

  • A percentage of the claim. For example, if an agreement set a 20% fee and the insurer approved $20,000, the fee would be $4,000 for a roof that was never installed.
  • A flat fee for 'inspection, claim assistance and administrative services.'
  • Hourly or itemized charges for time spent meeting the adjuster or preparing supplements.

Why it matters in each state:

  • In Florida, a contractor who charges for 'claim assistance' may be close to the line on unlicensed adjusting, since contractors may not adjust a claim on your behalf. In Texas, the same concern applies under Insurance Code 4102.163.
  • Florida's post-emergency cancellation right is 'without penalty or obligation.' A fee clause does not override it.
  • Under the Texas home-solicitation law, a merchant is not entitled to compensation for services performed under a transaction canceled within the 3-day window.

Is 'sign here so we can meet your adjuster' a contract?

It can be. You do not need to sign anything for a roofer to attend your adjuster's inspection. You can simply invite the roofer you chose to be there, or decline. TWIA, for example, encourages policyholders to get line-item contractor estimates that break out labor and materials and will compare them with its adjuster's estimate. That process does not require you to give any contractor rights in your claim.

If the paper says anything about the contractor doing the work, a price, the insurance scope, a percentage, a fee, or payment authorization, treat it as a contract and read it as one. Florida's consumer advocate advises letting the insurer inspect before you sign any paperwork and before a contractor starts work.

Should I sign anything during a free inspection?

No. A good inspection ends with photos and a written report, not a signature. Ask the inspector to email the photos and findings. If you want that company's bid, ask for an itemized written estimate you can compare with others.

The one exception is a written authorization for an emergency temporary repair, like a tarp, when water is coming in. Even then, make sure the paper covers only the tarp, has a price, and says nothing about the full roof or your claim. Note that in Florida, a code-compliant temporary repair can count as the 'official start date' that ends your post-emergency cancellation window, so don't sign a combined tarp-and-roof contract.

Safer alternatives to a contingency agreement

  1. Call your insurer or agent first. Report the claim yourself. IBHS and NICB say your first call after suspected storm damage should be to your insurance agent.
  2. Get your own inspection. Hire an inspector or a roofer you chose and verified. Ask for photos and a written report.
  3. Ask for itemized written bids from three licensed (Florida) or registered (Texas city) roofers. Use our quote comparison guide.
  4. Let the adjuster inspect. Invite your chosen roofer if you like.
  5. Compare the adjuster's estimate with the bids line by line. Ask the insurer in writing about any missing items.
  6. If you need claim help, hire a licensed public adjuster or attorney, not a contractor. Public adjuster fees are capped: 10% of the settlement in Texas; in Florida, 10% for claims from a declared emergency during the year after the declaration and 20% otherwise. Florida lets you cancel a public adjuster contract within 10 days.
  7. Sign a full contract with a fixed scope and price once you know what the claim covers. Use our contract checklist.

If you already signed: a quick decision tree

  • Signed in the last 3 business days at home? Cancel in writing now (certified mail, return receipt). Email a copy too.
  • Florida, signed within 180 days of a declared storm, no work started? Cancel within 10 days of signing, before any permit, temporary repair or material installation.
  • Florida, inducement-ban notice missing? Void within 10 days.
  • Outside all windows? Read the cancellation clause. Ask the roofer for its position in writing. Talk to a consumer attorney before paying any fee.
  • Either way: tell your insurer in writing that the contractor is not authorized to act for you or receive payment unless you say so, and ask to be copied on all communications.

For other recovery steps and where to report problems, see storm chaser scams.

How to choose a provider

  • Do not sign anything during a free inspection.
  • Call your insurer or agent to report the claim yourself.
  • Get itemized written bids from verified roofers.
  • Read any 'authorization' for claim percentages, fees, and payment directions.
  • Refuse any document that transfers your insurance rights to the contractor.
  • Do not sign a direction to pay unless you understand when the contractor gets paid.
  • Florida: check that roof contracts include the 489.147 notices.
  • Texas: check for the 12-point bold deductible notice on insurance jobs of $1,000 or more.
  • If you signed at home, cancel in writing within 3 business days if you want out.
  • Florida after a declared emergency: cancel within 10 days or before the official start date.
  • Tell your insurer in writing who is and is not authorized on your claim.
  • Use a licensed public adjuster or attorney, not a contractor, for claim help.

Related roofing guides

Roofing by state and city

Questions people ask

What is a roofing contingency agreement?

It is a contract that promises the roofing job to a contractor if your insurance claim is approved, usually at the price the insurer approves. It may also let the roofer talk to your insurer, add itself to payments, and charge a cancellation fee if you later choose someone else. Because it can be binding, read it as carefully as you would a full contract.

Do I have to sign a contingency agreement to file a claim?

No. You file a claim with your insurer yourself. You do not need any contractor's paperwork to report damage, schedule an adjuster, or receive an estimate. Florida's consumer advocate advises letting the insurer inspect before signing anything with a contractor. You can invite your chosen roofer to the inspection without signing an agreement.

Can a contractor negotiate my claim for me?

Not in either state, unless properly licensed. Florida bars contractors from interpreting policy provisions, advising on coverage or adjusting a claim for an insured unless they hold a public adjuster license. Texas goes further: a contractor may not act as a public adjuster on property it may repair, even if it holds an adjuster license or a power of attorney.

What is a direction to pay?

A direction to pay tells your insurer to pay the contractor directly or put the contractor's name on claim checks. You still own the claim, but money control shifts toward the contractor. Florida's consumer advocate warns it can lead to the contractor being paid before work is complete and says you are not required to sign one to have work done.

Is it legal to charge a percentage of my claim as a cancellation fee?

It depends on the contract, state law and timing. Florida's post-emergency cancellation right is without penalty, and Texas's home-solicitation law says a merchant gets no compensation for services under a transaction canceled within 3 business days. Outside those windows, a fee unrelated to actual work may be challengeable. Have a consumer attorney review it before you pay.

Is an AOB the same as a contingency agreement?

No. An assignment of benefits transfers your insurance rights to the contractor, who can then deal with and even sue your insurer. A contingency agreement only promises the job to the contractor. In Florida, attempted assignments of post-loss benefits are void for policies issued on or after January 1, 2023, so be wary of any document that hands over your rights.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration