Local Guide · General and residential contractors
How Do You Check a Contractor's References, Reviews and Past Work?
Reviews and references are easy to fake. Public records are not. Here is how Texas and Florida homeowners can verify a contractor through reference calls, permit portals, county court and lien records, business filings and complaint data, and how to read online ratings with a skeptical eye.
Call at least three references from the last year, including one with a problem, and ask about cost, schedule and how issues were fixed. Then confirm the work exists in city permit records, search county court and clerk records for lawsuits and liens, check business filings on Sunbiz (Florida) or the Texas Secretary of State and Comptroller, and check the Florida DBPR license for discipline. Treat star ratings and paid badges as leads to investigate, not proof.
Key facts
- The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465) took effect October 21, 2024 and lets courts impose civil penalties for knowing violations (FTC).
- The rule bars businesses from writing or buying fake reviews, paying for reviews that express a particular sentiment, and posting undisclosed reviews by officers or managers (16 CFR 465.2, 465.4, 465.5).
- The rule also bans company-controlled 'independent' review sites that are not disclosed, suppressing negative reviews, and buying fake followers or likes (16 CFR 465.6-465.8).
- BBB letter grades run from A+ to F, are built from seven elements such as complaint history and licensing, and do not use customer reviews; BBB says a rating is not a guarantee (BBB).
- Houston's Sold Permits Search shows basic permit history for permits sold in a rolling three-year period (Houston Permitting Center).
- Texas mechanic's lien affidavits are filed with the county clerk where the property is located (Tex. Prop. Code ch. 53).
- Florida claims of lien must be recorded within 90 days after the lienor's final furnishing, and Notices of Commencement are recorded with the clerk (ss. 713.08, 713.13, F.S.).
- The Texas Attorney General states that under Texas law consumer complaints filed with it are open to the public (Texas OAG).
- Florida law directs DBPR to make contractor licensure and disciplinary information available through its online system (s. 489.117, F.S.).
Why references and reviews are not enough on their own
Every contractor can find three happy customers, and online ratings can be bought, filtered or written by friends. That does not make references and reviews useless. It means you should use them to generate questions, then confirm the answers in records the contractor does not control: permits, court files, lien filings, business registrations and license discipline.
A good vetting process has four layers:
- Credentials: license (Florida) or city registration and trade licenses (Texas), plus insurance. See Florida license lookup and Texas license requirements.
- People: reference calls and a job-site visit.
- Records: permits, court cases, liens, business filings, complaints.
- Reputation: reviews and ratings, read critically.
This page covers layers two to four. Budget two to three hours per finalist. It is cheap insurance on a project that may cost more than a car.
How to check references the right way
How many references are enough?
Ask for at least three from projects finished in the last 12 months that are similar to yours in type and size, plus one older project so you can see how the work held up. Ask specifically for one job where something went wrong. Every contractor has one. How they handled it is the most useful thing you will learn.
Make sure the references are real
- Get the property address, not just a phone number.
- Check that a permit for that type of work appears in the city's permit records for that address around the date given (see below).
- Ask the reference a detail only a real client would know: the project manager's name, the start month, the color of the tile.
- Be cautious if every reference has the same last name as the contractor, or if all calls go to cell numbers that answer with first names only.
What to ask
- What was the project, and when did it finish?
- How close was the final cost to the contract? What changed?
- Did it start and finish on time?
- Who supervised daily, and how quickly did they respond?
- Were change orders written and priced before the work?
- What went wrong, and how was it handled?
- Did permits and inspections go smoothly?
- Did any subcontractor or supplier send you a notice or file a lien?
- Have you needed warranty service?
- Would you hire them again?
A longer script is on our questions to ask a contractor page. Question 8 matters in both states. In Florida, subs and suppliers serve a Notice to Owner, and in Texas they send notices of claim, when they are worried about payment. A reference who received those notices has seen the contractor's cash-flow habits up close.
Check past work in city and county permit records
Permit records are one of the best ways to confirm that a contractor really builds what it shows you, and that it pulls permits at all.
| Where | What you can find | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Houston | Sold Permits Search: basic permit history for permits sold in a rolling three-year period, by search or council district | For complete history, the city directs requests to its Open Records section |
| Austin | Austin Build + Connect portal, where contractors register and permits are managed | Austin requires contractors and homeowners acting as contractors to register before permitted work |
| Dallas | DallasNow, the city's online portal for permitting services | Search by address or permit |
| San Antonio | BuildSA, including a contractor search | Check the contractor's registration category |
| Florida cities and counties | Online permit status systems; Florida requires local building departments to accept applications electronically and post application status online until the permit is issued | Search by address or contractor license number |
How to use permit records:
- Search the reference addresses. A kitchen or addition with no permit is a warning sign.
- Search the contractor's name or Florida license number to see how many permits it pulls and of what type.
- Look at inspection results. Many failed inspections, or permits that expired without a final, deserve questions.
- In Florida, a recorded Notice of Commencement at the clerk's office names the contractor on many jobs. Searching the clerk's official records for the company name shows where it has worked.
City-by-city details are on our Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, Miami, Tampa, Orlando and Jacksonville pages.
Search court records for lawsuits
Contract disputes with homeowners, subcontractors and suppliers usually land in county or district court. Search both the company name and the owner's name, with spelling variations.
Texas
- Harris County (Houston): the Harris County District Clerk's 'Search Our Records' service, and today's new civil filings.
- Travis County (Austin): the District Clerk's Case Information and Records Search.
- Dallas County: the county's Online Record Search.
- Bexar County (San Antonio) and Tarrant County (Fort Worth): check each district clerk's website for online case records, or call the clerk.
- Check justice courts too for smaller claims, and county courts at law.
Florida
- Miami-Dade: the Clerk of the Court and Comptroller's Online Civil, Family and Probate Case Search.
- Hillsborough (Tampa): the Clerk of Courts online case and official records searches.
- Orange (Orlando): the Clerk of Courts Court Record Search.
- Duval (Jacksonville): the Clerk of Court's court records and official records services.
How to read what you find
- One or two disputes over many years is normal for an active builder. Look for patterns: repeated suits by suppliers (unpaid bills), by homeowners (abandonment or defects), or by the state.
- Read the complaint and the outcome. A dismissed case or a settled dispute means something different from a default judgment the contractor never answered.
- Look for judgments that were never paid.
- Search for bankruptcy filings under the owner's name in federal court if anything looks off.
Search lien records
A lien filed against a past customer's property by the contractor's own subcontractor or supplier tells you the contractor did not pay someone. That is a direct risk to you, because in both states unpaid subs and suppliers can pursue the owner's property.
- Texas: mechanic's lien affidavits are filed with the county clerk in the county where the property is located (Prop. Code ch. 53). In Harris County, that is the Harris County Clerk's real property records, separate from the District Clerk's court records. Search the contractor's name as the 'original contractor' named in affidavits.
- Florida: claims of lien, Notices of Commencement, notices of contest and lien releases are recorded in the county clerk's official records. A claim of lien must be recorded within 90 days after the lienor last furnished labor or materials (s. 713.08).
A contractor filing liens against its own customers is not automatically a bad sign. It may reflect owners who did not pay. Read a few and look at the amounts and the pattern. See our Texas lien guide and Florida lien guide.
Verify the business itself
| Check | Florida | Texas |
|---|---|---|
| Entity record | Sunbiz (Division of Corporations): search by name, officer or registered agent, FEI/EIN, document number, ZIP or street address; fictitious names searchable separately | Texas Secretary of State filings through its SOSDirect online service (fee-based; check the current fee on the SOS site) |
| Tax standing | Not applicable in the same way | Comptroller's Franchise Tax Account Status search, by entity name, taxpayer number, EIN or SOS file number |
| License | DBPR license search: status, class, qualifier and discipline | No state GC license; TDLR license search for electricians and A/C contractors; Texas State Board of Plumbing Examiners search for plumbers |
| Workers' comp | DFS Division of Workers' Compensation coverage and exemption searches | Ask the insurance agent for a certificate showing whether the contractor carries workers' compensation |
| Lead-safe certification | EPA's RRP program page links to a search for certified renovation firms | Same EPA search; certification is needed for paid work disturbing paint in pre-1978 homes |
What to compare across records: the exact legal name, the address, the owners or officers, and the date the company was formed. A company formed this year that claims 20 years of projects may be a rebrand. That can be innocent, or a way to leave old judgments behind. Ask.
Check complaints and discipline
- Florida DBPR: look at the license record for disciplinary actions and final orders. Florida law directs the board to make licensure and disciplinary information available online, including discipline that local jurisdictions report for locally licensed registrants (s. 489.117). CILB can fine contractors up to $10,000 per violation and suspend or revoke licenses (s. 489.129).
- Texas Attorney General: the Consumer Protection Division states that complaints filed with it are open to the public under Texas law. There is no public search page for them, but you can request complaint records about a named business with a written Public Information Act request delivered by mail, email, hand delivery or another method the agency approves.
- Florida consumer agencies: the Florida Attorney General and the Florida Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services take consumer complaints. Contact them and ask whether complaints about the business are on file.
- Better Business Bureau: read the complaint details, not just the grade (see below).
To file your own complaint, see how to file a complaint against a contractor.
Are online reviews of contractors reliable?
Partly. Reviews are most useful in bulk and in detail. A contractor with dozens of specific reviews over several years, including a few mixed ones with professional replies, is more credible than one with a burst of perfect five-star reviews in a single month.
What federal law now says about fake reviews
The FTC's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (16 CFR Part 465) took effect October 21, 2024, and the FTC says courts can impose civil penalties for knowing violations. In plain terms, the rule makes it illegal for a business to:
- write, create or sell reviews that misrepresent who the reviewer is or their experience, or buy such reviews (465.2);
- pay or give incentives for reviews that express a particular sentiment, positive or negative (465.4);
- post reviews by its own officers or managers, or push employees and relatives to review, without clear disclosure of the relationship (465.5);
- run a review website it controls while claiming it is independent (465.6);
- use groundless legal threats or intimidation to get reviews removed, or hide negative reviews while implying you see all of them (465.7);
- buy or sell fake followers, likes or views (465.8).
Asking all customers for reviews in general is allowed. Offering a discount only for five-star reviews is not.
How to spot fake contractor reviews
- Many reviews posted in a short window, especially soon after the business appeared.
- Vague praise with no project details, no names, no city.
- Reviewer profiles with one review, or reviews across unrelated cities on the same day.
- Repeated phrases across different 'customers.'
- Perfect ratings everywhere except where the business cannot remove reviews.
- Photos that also appear on other contractors' sites (see reverse image search below).
Read the one- and two-star reviews first. Look at what went wrong and whether the contractor responded professionally. Problems with payment, abandonment and unpaid subs matter more than a missed appointment.
Is the BBB rating meaningful?
It is one data point. The BBB describes its rating as its opinion of how a business is likely to interact with customers. Key facts from the BBB's own explanation:
- Grades run from A+ to F. 'NR' means no rating, used when there is not enough information or the file is under review; BBB says NR is not negative.
- Ratings are built from seven elements: complaint history, type of business, time in business, transparent business practices, failure to honor commitments to BBB, licensing, and advertising issues.
- Complaint handling carries much of the weight: on BBB's 100-point scale, unanswered complaints account for up to 40 points and unresolved complaints up to 30.
- Customer reviews are not used in the letter grade.
- BBB says a rating is not a guarantee of reliability or performance.
BBB accreditation is a separate program that businesses apply for. Read the actual complaint text and the business's responses. A high grade with several recent complaints about abandoned jobs is worth a question.
Lead-generation platforms and badges
Many homeowners find contractors through directories and lead-generation apps. These platforms differ widely in what they check. Some run background or license checks; others mostly verify that a business exists and pays for leads. A 'top pro' or 'screened' badge can reflect paid placement, response time or volume of reviews rather than licensing or quality.
Before you rely on a badge:
- Find the platform's own written description of what the badge checks, and when.
- Assume the platform did not verify a Florida license class or a Texas city registration unless it says so. Check those yourself.
- Remember that sponsored or 'featured' listings are advertising.
- Be wary of 'independent' comparison sites that only feature one company's services. Under 16 CFR 465.6, a business may not misrepresent that a site it controls provides independent reviews.
Verify portfolio photos
Contractor websites sometimes use stock images or photos lifted from other builders. Three quick checks:
- Reverse image search. Upload or paste the photo into a reverse image search tool. If the same photo appears on a stock site or another contractor's page, ask about it.
- Ask for the address and the permit. For a major project, match the photo to a permitted job.
- Ask for in-progress photos. Framing, waterproofing and rough-in photos are hard to fake and show how the hidden work is done.
Visiting a current job site beats any photo. Our job-site visit checklist lists what to look for.
Putting it together: a one-page vetting record
Keep one page per finalist. Record:
- License or registration numbers and status, with the date checked.
- Insurance certificate details and the agent you called.
- Reference names, project addresses and what they said.
- Permit records found for those addresses.
- Court cases and liens found, with outcomes.
- Business filing status and formation date.
- Complaints and BBB file notes.
- Your overall impression.
This record helps you choose, and it helps if something goes wrong later. If a dispute arises, see contractor dispute resolution.
How to choose a provider
- Ask for three references from the last 12 months plus one older job and one with a problem.
- Confirm each reference address in the city's permit records.
- Call references with the script and ask about notices or liens from subs.
- Search county court records for the company and owner names.
- Search county clerk real property or official records for liens and Notices of Commencement.
- Check Sunbiz (Florida) or the Texas Secretary of State and Comptroller records (Texas).
- Florida: read the DBPR license record for discipline and final orders.
- Texas: consider a Public Information Act request to the Attorney General for complaint records.
- Read low-star reviews first and look for patterns of fake reviews.
- Reverse-image-search portfolio photos and ask for in-progress photos.
- Visit a current job site.
- Keep a one-page vetting record for each finalist.
Related general and residential contractors guides
- What Questions Should You Ask a Contractor Before Hiring? (75 Questions and the Answers You Want)
- How Do You Hire a General Contractor in Texas or Florida, Step by Step?
- Licensed, Bonded and Insured: What It Actually Means in Texas and Florida
- How Do You Look Up a Florida Contractor License and Read What It Says?
- Does Texas Require a General Contractor License? (No, But Here Is What It Does Require)
- What Are the Most Common Contractor Scams in Texas and Florida, and How Do You Spot Them?
- How Do I File a Complaint Against a Contractor in Texas or Florida?
General and residential contractors by state and city
Questions people ask
How do I check a contractor's references?
Ask for at least three references from similar projects finished in the last 12 months, plus one with a problem. Get the property address and confirm a permit exists for that work in the city's records. Then call and ask about cost versus contract, schedule, supervision, change orders, what went wrong, inspections, any lien notices from subcontractors, and whether they would hire the contractor again.
How do I spot fake contractor reviews?
Watch for bursts of five-star reviews in a short period, vague praise with no project details, reviewer profiles with only one review, repeated phrases across different reviewers, and portfolio photos that also appear elsewhere online. Since October 21, 2024, the FTC's consumer review rule has made writing, buying or soliciting fake reviews, and paying for reviews of a particular sentiment, a violation that can carry civil penalties.
How do I search court records for a contractor in Texas?
Search the district clerk's online records in the county where the contractor works, such as the Harris County District Clerk's Search Our Records service or the Travis County District Clerk's case search, and Dallas County's Online Record Search. Search the company and owner names with spelling variations. Check county courts at law and justice courts for smaller claims too.
How do I check if a contractor has liens or lawsuits in Florida?
Search the county clerk's court records for lawsuits and the clerk's official records for claims of lien, Notices of Commencement and lien releases. Miami-Dade's Clerk offers an online civil case search and official records; Hillsborough, Orange and Duval clerks offer similar searches. Look for patterns, such as repeated supplier liens on the contractor's jobs, which suggest unpaid bills.
How do I find past permits a contractor pulled?
Use the city's online permit system. Houston's Sold Permits Search covers a rolling three years; Dallas uses DallasNow; Austin uses Austin Build + Connect; San Antonio uses BuildSA, which includes a contractor search. Florida local building departments must post application status online. Search by the reference's address, or by the contractor's name or Florida license number.
Can I check complaints filed against a contractor?
Yes, in several places. In Florida, the DBPR license record shows discipline, and law directs DBPR to post licensure and disciplinary information online. In Texas, the Attorney General says complaints filed with it are public, and you can request them in writing under the Public Information Act. BBB business profiles show complaint details and responses.
Should I trust lead-generation platform badges?
Only after reading what the badge actually checks. Some platforms run background or license checks; others mainly reflect paid membership, response speed or review volume. Never assume a badge confirmed a Florida license class, Texas city registration or insurance. Verify those yourself with the state, the city and the insurance agent.
What does licensed, bonded and insured really mean?
Licensed means the state or city authorized the contractor for the work; in Texas there is no state general contractor license. Bonded usually refers to a surety bond that protects a government or a specific party, often not the homeowner. Insured means the contractor carries liability and, ideally, workers' compensation coverage. Our licensed, bonded and insured guide explains each and how to verify them.
Sources
- 16 CFR Part 465, Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials (eCFR)
- FTC, Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule: Questions and Answers
- BBB, Overview of BBB Ratings
- Houston Permitting Center, Sold Permits Search
- City of Austin, Contractor Registration
- City of Dallas, Residential Permits
- City of San Antonio Development Services (BuildSA)
- Harris County District Clerk, Search Our Records
- Harris County Clerk
- Travis County District Clerk
- Dallas County District Clerk
- Miami-Dade Clerk of the Court and Comptroller
- Hillsborough County Clerk of Courts
- Orange County Clerk of Courts
- Duval County Clerk of Courts
- Texas Property Code ch. 53
- Florida Statutes s. 713.08 (2026)
- Florida Statutes s. 713.13 (2026)
- Florida Statutes s. 713.06 (2026)
- Florida Statutes s. 553.79 (2026)
- Florida Statutes s. 489.117 (2026)
- Florida Statutes s. 489.129 (2026)
- Florida Division of Corporations (Sunbiz): Search Records
- Texas Comptroller, Franchise Tax Account Status Search
- TDLR License Data Search
- Texas State Board of Plumbing Examiners
- Florida DFS, Workers' Compensation Exemption Search
- Texas Attorney General, File a Consumer Complaint
- Texas Attorney General, How to Request Public Information
- EPA, Lead Renovation, Repair and Painting Program
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


