New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Fri, Nov 20, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · General and residential contractors

Contractor Dispute: Should You Negotiate, Mediate, Arbitrate or Go to Court?

Most contractor disputes can be settled before a lawsuit, but Texas and Florida each add required notices, mediation rules and fee-shifting statutes that change the strategy. This neutral guide walks through the escalation ladder, arbitration clauses, attorney's fees, withholding payment, evidence and experts.

Resolve a contractor dispute by escalating in steps: talk, then put the complaint in writing, then send a formal demand and any required pre-suit notice (Texas RCLA or DTPA, Florida chapter 558), then mediate, and only then arbitrate or sue. Check your contract first for mediation or arbitration clauses. In Texas, a homeowner who wins a contract claim may recover attorney's fees under Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code s. 38.001. In Florida, the prevailing party in a lien action recovers fees under s. 713.29.

Key facts

  • Texas's Residential Construction Liability Act requires certified-mail notice of construction defects at least 60 days before suing or starting arbitration, and its definition of action includes arbitration (Prop. Code ss. 27.001, 27.004).
  • In a Texas RCLA suit seeking more than $7,500, either side may move to compel mediation within 90 days after filing, and parties split the mediator's cost equally unless they agree otherwise (Prop. Code s. 27.0041).
  • The Texas DTPA requires 60 days' written notice before suit and allows a motion to compel mediation within 90 days after a DTPA pleading is served (Bus. & Com. Code ss. 17.505, 17.5051).
  • Texas allows recovery of reasonable attorney's fees on a claim for an oral or written contract, rendered services, performed labor or furnished material, if the claimant has a lawyer, presents the claim and is not paid within 30 days (Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code ss. 38.001, 38.002).
  • Florida awards the prevailing party reasonable attorney's fees in any action to enforce a construction lien or a claim against a lien bond (s. 713.29).
  • Florida's chapter 558 controls over a conflicting arbitration clause in a contract for the sale, design, construction or remodeling of real property (s. 558.004(14)).
  • Since September 1, 2023, submitting a Texas RCLA claim to arbitration affects limitations the same as filing in court, and contractual waivers of the RCLA are void (Prop. Code ss. 27.008, 27.009).
  • The American Arbitration Association publishes separate Home Construction Arbitration Rules and a Home Construction fee schedule alongside its Construction Industry rules; fees are tied to the claim amount and other factors.

How do I resolve a dispute with my contractor? The escalation ladder

Think of dispute resolution as a ladder. Each rung costs more time and money than the one before, and most disputes should settle on the first three. Climb only as far as you need to.

RungWhat it isTypical costWhen to move up
1. Direct conversationMeet on site, walk the problem, agree on a fix and dateYour timeNo agreement, or agreement not kept
2. Written complaintEmail or letter listing issues, photos, contract sections and a requested fixYour timeNo written response in about a week, or a refusal
3. Formal demand and statutory noticeCertified letter with a deadline; RCLA, DTPA or ch. 558 notice when they applyPostage; optional attorney letterStatutory waiting period runs without a fair offer
4. MediationNeutral mediator helps both sides reach a voluntary settlementMediator's fee, often splitImpasse
5. Arbitration or courtA decision-maker issues a binding award or judgmentFiling fees, attorney's fees, expert feesJudgment or award entered; then collection

Running alongside the ladder are three parallel tools: licensing complaints (Florida DBPR, Texas city registration offices and trade licensing agencies), lien remedies (contesting or removing an improper lien), and, where money was misused, criminal referrals. Those are covered in how to file a complaint against a contractor and contractor abandoned the job.

Step one: read your contract's dispute clause

Before you send anything, find the parts of your contract that control disputes:

  • Notice clause: how and where formal notices must be sent.
  • Notice and cure: whether the other side gets a set time to fix a default before termination.
  • Mediation clause: whether mediation is required before arbitration or suit.
  • Arbitration clause: whether disputes go to private arbitration instead of court, which rules apply, who administers it, and where hearings happen.
  • Attorney's fees clause: whether the winner recovers fees.
  • Claims period: whether you must make claims within a shortened time.
  • Statutory notices: Texas contracts subject to the RCLA must contain a 10-point bold Chapter 27 notice (a missing notice can support a $500 civil penalty), and Florida contracts after October 1, 2009 must state that defect claims are subject to the notice and cure provisions of chapter 558, unless the parties opted out.

Is arbitration required in my contract?

Only if your contract (or a later written agreement) says so. Look for words like "binding arbitration," "shall be resolved by arbitration," or a named provider such as the American Arbitration Association. If there is no clause, you can still agree to arbitrate after the dispute arises.

Two state rules interact with arbitration clauses:

  • Texas: the RCLA defines "action" to include arbitration, so its 60-day notice, inspection and offer process applies before you file an arbitration demand over residential defects (Prop. Code ss. 27.001(1), 27.004). Since September 1, 2023, filing in arbitration affects limitations the same way as filing in court (s. 27.008), and a contract cannot waive the RCLA (s. 27.009).
  • Florida: to the extent an arbitration clause conflicts with s. 558.004, the statute controls (s. 558.004(14)). The parties may agree in writing to pre-action mediation or to change the ch. 558 procedure (s. 558.005(4)).

What is a demand letter, and what should it include?

A demand letter is a formal written request that tells the contractor what is wrong, what you want, and by when, and what you will do if it does not respond. It often doubles as the notice a statute requires.

Include:

  • Your name, the property address, the contract date and the permit number.
  • A short, factual timeline.
  • Each problem, numbered, with the contract section, photo references and any inspector or engineer findings.
  • The amount you claim and how you calculated it (repair estimates, overpayment, completion cost).
  • Exactly what you want: repair by a date, a refund of a stated amount, or both.
  • A response deadline that matches any statute (60 days for RCLA and DTPA notices in Texas and ch. 558 in Florida; 30 days for a Florida s. 489.126 refund demand).
  • The statutes the letter is served under, when applicable.

Which statutory notice applies?

SituationTexasFlorida
Construction defect in a residenceRCLA notice, certified mail, return receipt, at least 60 days before suit or arbitration (Prop. Code s. 27.004)Ch. 558 notice of claim, at least 60 days before suit (120 for associations over 20 parcels) (s. 558.004)
Deceptive practice or warranty breach (consumer)DTPA notice at least 60 days before suit, stating the complaint and damages and fees claimed (s. 17.505)Not covered on this page; consult counsel
Deposit taken, work not started or stoppedWritten demand; RCLA does not apply to wrongful abandonmentCertified-mail demand to perform or refund; 30 days (s. 489.126)
Contract claim with attorney's feesPresent the claim; fees available if not paid within 30 days (CPRC s. 38.002)Depends on the contract's fee clause and statutes like s. 713.29

Lawyers often combine notices in a single certified letter. Keep the return receipt or USPS tracking printout with your file.

Should I mediate a contractor dispute?

Often, yes. Mediation is a meeting (in person or by video) where a neutral mediator helps both sides negotiate. The mediator does not decide anything. If you settle, you sign a written agreement; if not, you keep all your rights.

Why it often works in construction cases:

  • Repair disputes usually turn on scope and price, which are negotiable.
  • Both sides avoid expert and attorney costs that can exceed the repair amount.
  • A settlement can include things a court cannot easily order, like a specific repair schedule or a mutual release.

When mediation can be required

  • Texas RCLA suits over $7,500: either party may move to compel mediation within 90 days after the suit is filed; the court must order it within 30 days of the motion, mediation must start within 30 days of the order (up to 60 if needed), and each party pays an equal share unless agreed otherwise (Prop. Code s. 27.0041).
  • Texas DTPA suits: a party may move to compel mediation within 90 days after service of a DTPA pleading (Bus. & Com. Code s. 17.5051).
  • Florida small claims: mediation may take place at the pretrial conference, and settlements reached there are written as a stipulation (Florida Small Claims Rules, rule 7.090).
  • Your contract may require mediation before arbitration or suit.

Preparing for mediation

  • Know your number: the lowest settlement you will take, backed by estimates.
  • Bring a one-page summary, the contract, key photos, the expert report and repair bids.
  • Think about non-money terms: who does the repair, warranty on the repair, lien releases, permit closeout, mutual release.
  • Make sure whoever attends has authority to settle.

Arbitration vs court

FactorArbitrationCourt
Who decidesPrivate arbitrator, often with construction experienceJudge or jury
Required?Only by agreementDefault if no arbitration agreement
Cost to fileAdministrative fees set by the provider's fee schedule, plus arbitrator compensationCourt filing fees set by statute or county
SpeedOften faster, but depends on the provider and arbitratorDepends on court docket; small claims is fastest
PrivacyGenerally privatePublic record
AppealVery limited groundsFull appeal rights
DiscoveryLimited, set by rules and arbitratorBroader under court rules

How much does construction arbitration cost?

The American Arbitration Association (AAA) administers many construction arbitrations. It publishes Construction Industry Arbitration Rules and Mediation Procedures, separate Home Construction Arbitration Rules and Mediation Procedures, and corresponding administrative fee schedules, including a Home Construction Industry Administrative Fee Schedule. The AAA says its costs are tied to the claim amount and other factors, and it offers a fee waiver affidavit for individuals who qualify. Arbitrator compensation is in addition to administrative fees. Check the current schedule on the AAA's construction rules page, or the schedule of whichever provider your contract names, before you file; we have not listed dollar amounts because they change.

In Texas, if you win an RCLA claim, reasonable and necessary arbitration filing fees and your share of arbitrator compensation are recoverable damages (Prop. Code s. 27.004(g)(7)).

Can I get attorney's fees?

In the United States, each side usually pays its own lawyer unless a contract or statute shifts fees. Construction disputes in Texas and Florida have several fee-shifting rules.

Texas

  • Contract claims, CPRC s. 38.001. A person may recover reasonable attorney's fees, in addition to the claim and costs, from an individual or organization for a claim for rendered services, performed labor, furnished material, a sworn account, or an oral or written contract. To recover, you must be represented by an attorney, present the claim to the other side, and not have been paid the just amount within 30 days after presenting it (s. 38.002). Since 2021, fees may also be recovered as compensatory damages for breach of a construction contract (s. 38.0015). This works in both directions: a contractor that wins can seek fees from you.
  • DTPA. Each consumer who prevails is awarded court costs and reasonable and necessary attorney's fees (Bus. & Com. Code s. 17.50(d)). A groundless, bad-faith or harassing DTPA suit can make the consumer pay the defendant's fees (s. 17.50(c)).
  • RCLA. Reasonable and necessary attorney's fees are a listed category of recoverable damages (Prop. Code s. 27.004(g)(6)), but if you reject a reasonable offer you can recover only fees incurred before rejection (s. 27.004(e)). A groundless suit filed in bad faith or to harass makes the filer liable for fees (s. 27.0031).
  • Lien suits. In proceedings to foreclose a lien or declare one invalid, the court awards costs and reasonable fees as are equitable and just, but on a residential construction contract the court is not required to order the property owner to pay them (Prop. Code s. 53.156).

Florida

  • Lien actions, s. 713.29. In any action to enforce a construction lien, including one transferred to security, or a claim against a lien bond, the prevailing party recovers a reasonable attorney's fee for trial, appeal or arbitration. Because this cuts both ways, a homeowner who defeats a bad lien can recover fees, and one who loses can owe them.
  • Fraudulent liens, s. 713.31. A fraudulent lien is a complete defense, and the owner may sue for damages, with the prevailing party recovering fees and costs.
  • Contract clauses. Many Florida construction contracts include a prevailing-party fee clause. Read yours.

Can I withhold payment during a dispute?

Sometimes, but carefully. Withholding without a contract basis can make you the party in breach.

  • Tie it to the contract. Withhold only for documented defaults, incomplete work or defective work, and say in writing which items and amounts you are holding.
  • Keep it proportional. Hold roughly what it would cost to fix or finish, not the whole balance.
  • Texas retainage is required. Owners must reserve 10% of the contract price, or of the value of the work, during the job and for 30 days after completion (Prop. Code s. 53.101). If a subcontractor or supplier sends a notice of claim, the statutory warning tells you your property may be liened if you do not withhold enough from future payments to the contractor to cover it.
  • Florida payment rules. Paying a contractor does not protect you from subs who served a Notice to Owner. Pay only against releases, and get the Contractor's Final Payment Affidavit before final payment (s. 713.06). In Florida, a good-faith dispute over the amount due is recognized: the misapplication statute does not prevent withholding "pursuant to a bona fide dispute regarding the amount due" (s. 713.345(1)(a)).
  • Pay undisputed amounts. Paying what you agree you owe, and holding only the disputed part, shows good faith and limits your fee exposure in Texas under ch. 38.

What evidence do I need? A checklist

  • Contract documents: signed contract, plans, specifications, scope, allowances, every change order, and any warranty.
  • Money trail: invoices, draw requests, receipts, canceled checks, bank and card statements; in Texas, the contractor's disbursement statements and subcontractor list.
  • Communications: emails, texts (with phone numbers visible), letters and call notes, in date order.
  • Site record: dated photos and video from start to finish; daily or weekly notes if you kept them.
  • Public records: permit, plan approvals, inspection results, and the contractor's license or registration status.
  • Lien paperwork: Florida Notices to Owner, Notice of Commencement, claims of lien; Texas notices of claim and lien affidavits.
  • Professional opinions: inspector, engineer or architect reports on what is wrong, why, and how to fix it.
  • Repair bids: at least one, preferably two, detailed written estimates from independent contractors.
  • Damages proof: temporary housing receipts, damaged belongings, extra completion costs.
  • Proof of notices: certified-mail receipts and tracking printouts for every statutory notice.

Organize it in a single binder or folder with a one-page summary on top: the contract price, what you paid, what was done, what it costs to fix or finish, and the number you are asking for.

What is an expert witness in a construction defect case?

An expert witness is a qualified professional who gives opinions the judge, jury or arbitrator could not form alone: what caused a crack, whether work met code or trade standards, and what a proper repair costs. Common construction experts are licensed structural or geotechnical engineers, architects, building envelope or roofing consultants, licensed trade professionals and cost estimators.

  • Texas: the RCLA requires you to provide expert reports and other evidence with your notice if they would be discoverable (Prop. Code s. 27.004(a)), and reasonable and necessary engineering and consulting fees are recoverable damages (s. 27.004(g)(3)).
  • Florida: during the ch. 558 process either side may request expert reports describing defects; reports exchanged then may not be used later unless the expert testifies or a testifying expert relies on them (s. 558.004(15)). Code violation claims under s. 553.84 often need an expert to show the violation was material.

For a small claim, a written report from an inspector or a detailed repair estimate may be enough. For foundation, structural, water intrusion or large-dollar claims, an engineer's report is usually essential.

When should I hire a construction lawyer?

You can handle many small disputes yourself, especially in small claims court. Consider a construction attorney when:

  • The amount at stake is above the small claims limit ($20,000 in Texas justice court; $8,000 in Florida small claims).
  • A lien has been recorded against your property, or a contractor is threatening one.
  • The contract has an arbitration clause, a fee clause, or a claim deadline you are close to.
  • The dispute involves structural defects, water intrusion, mold or safety hazards.
  • A limitations or repose deadline is near: Texas residential repose is generally 10 years after substantial completion (6 with a qualifying warranty); Florida's is 7 years, and Florida's limitations period is 4 years.
  • The contractor has a lawyer.
  • You are a business or association with a commercial contract, where the DTPA may not apply (for example, deals over $500,000, or written contracts over $100,000 where you had a lawyer, unless your residence is involved).

The State Bar of Texas and The Florida Bar both operate lawyer referral services. Many construction lawyers will review a contract and documents for a flat fee. This guide is general information, not legal advice.

How long does a construction dispute take?

It varies widely by forum, complexity and how hard each side fights. Some fixed time frames help you plan:

  • Statutory pre-suit periods: at least 60 days in Texas (RCLA and DTPA) and Florida (ch. 558), or 120 days for large Florida associations, plus offer and response windows.
  • Florida small claims: the pretrial conference is set within 50 days of filing, and trial within 60 days after the pretrial conference (rule 7.090).
  • Texas justice court: the defendant's answer is due by the end of the 14th day after service; either side may appeal within 21 days after judgment for a new trial in county court (Texas Rules of Civil Procedure 502.5, 506.1, 506.3).
  • Larger cases in county, district or circuit court, or in arbitration, involve discovery, experts and hearings and commonly take much longer. Ask your attorney for a realistic schedule for your court.

Small claims details are in suing a contractor in small claims. Local guides: Houston, Dallas, San Antonio, Austin, Miami, Tampa, Orlando, Jacksonville.

How to choose a provider

  • Read the contract's notice, cure, mediation, arbitration and fee clauses.
  • Put every complaint in writing with photos and contract references.
  • Get an independent inspection report and at least one repair bid.
  • Calculate your number: repair or completion cost, overpayment and other damages.
  • Send the statutory notice that applies (RCLA, DTPA, ch. 558 or s. 489.126) by the required method.
  • Pay undisputed amounts; document what you are withholding and why.
  • Track and respond to inspection requests and offers within the statutory windows.
  • Propose mediation before filing, or use the statutory mediation motion.
  • Check the arbitration provider's current rules and fee schedule if your contract names one.
  • Calendar limitations and repose deadlines.
  • Choose the forum: small claims, regular court or arbitration.
  • Consult a construction attorney for liens, large claims or close deadlines.

Related general and residential contractors guides

General and residential contractors by state and city

Questions people ask

How do I resolve a dispute with my contractor?

Start with a direct conversation, then a written complaint, then a formal demand that includes any required notice: the RCLA or DTPA notice in Texas, or a chapter 558 notice of claim in Florida. If that fails, try mediation. Only then move to arbitration, if your contract requires it, or court. Small claims court handles many disputes: up to $20,000 in Texas justice court and $8,000 in Florida.

Is arbitration required in my contract?

Only if the contract or a later written agreement requires it. Look for phrases like binding arbitration or a named provider. In Texas, the RCLA's notice process still applies before arbitration of residential defect claims, and contract waivers of the RCLA are void. In Florida, chapter 558 controls over a conflicting arbitration clause. Have a lawyer read any clause you are unsure about.

How much does construction arbitration cost?

It depends on the provider, the claim amount and the arbitrator's rates. The American Arbitration Association publishes separate fee schedules for construction and home construction cases and says costs are tied to the claim amount and other factors; arbitrator compensation is extra. Check the current schedule before filing. In Texas, a winning RCLA claimant can recover arbitration fees and its share of arbitrator compensation.

Can I get attorney's fees from my contractor?

Possibly. In Texas, Civil Practice and Remedies Code s. 38.001 allows fees on contract and services claims if you have a lawyer, present the claim and are not paid within 30 days; the DTPA awards fees to a prevailing consumer; and the RCLA lists fees as recoverable damages. In Florida, the prevailing party in a lien action recovers fees under s. 713.29, and many contracts have fee clauses.

Can I withhold payment during a dispute?

You can withhold amounts tied to documented defaults or defective work if your contract allows, but withholding too much can make you the party in breach. Pay undisputed amounts. In Texas, you must keep the 10% statutory retainage until 30 days after completion and withhold enough to cover noticed sub claims. In Florida, pay only against lien releases and the final payment affidavit.

Should I mediate a contractor dispute?

Usually it is worth trying. Mediation is confidential, cheaper than litigation, and lets you agree on a repair schedule or release terms a court might not order. In Texas, RCLA suits over $7,500 and DTPA suits can be sent to mediation on a motion within 90 days. Bring your contract, photos, expert report and repair bids, and know your bottom line.

When should I hire a construction lawyer?

When the claim exceeds the small claims limit, a lien has been recorded or threatened, the contract has an arbitration or fee clause, the problem is structural or involves water intrusion, the contractor has a lawyer, or a deadline is close. Texas residential repose is generally 10 years from substantial completion; Florida's is 7. Both state bars run lawyer referral services.

What is an expert witness for construction defects?

A qualified professional, such as a licensed engineer, architect, roofing or building envelope consultant, or cost estimator, who explains what caused a defect, whether the work met code or trade standards, and what a proper repair costs. In Texas, expert reports must be shared with your RCLA notice if discoverable, and engineering and consulting fees are recoverable damages under the Act.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration