New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Thu, Nov 19, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · Plumbing

Selling a House With Plumbing Problems in Texas or Florida: What Must You Disclose?

What Texas and Florida sellers must disclose about leaks, slab repairs, pipes and unpermitted work, when to fix or sell as-is, and how repair negotiations work under the standard contracts.

Texas sellers must give the Seller's Disclosure Notice under Property Code 5.008, which asks about plumbing, sewer and slab defects, non-flood water damage, flooding and unpermitted repairs; a buyer who gets it late can terminate within 7 days. Florida sellers must disclose known, material defects that are not readily observable under Johnson v. Davis, even in an as-is sale, plus a flood disclosure under 689.302. Disclose past leaks with repair receipts.

Key facts

  • Texas Property Code 5.008 requires a Seller's Disclosure Notice for most single-dwelling resales; TREC's current form is 55-1.
  • The Texas notice asks about defects in Plumbing/Sewers/Septics and Foundation/Slab, and about Water Damage Not Due to a Flood Event.
  • It also asks about repairs made without necessary permits or not in compliance with building codes.
  • A Texas buyer who signs without the notice may terminate for any reason within 7 days after receiving it.
  • Johnson v. Davis (Fla. 1985): Florida home sellers must disclose known facts materially affecting value that are not readily observable.
  • Florida courts hold an as-is clause does not remove the Johnson disclosure duty in residential sales (Florida Bar Journal review).
  • Fla. Stat. 689.302 requires a residential flood disclosure at or before contract signing.
  • TREC contract: agreed repairs must be done by licensed persons with required permits, with documentation and transferable warranties delivered.

What Texas sellers must disclose about plumbing

Texas Property Code 5.008 requires a seller of residential property with not more than one dwelling unit to give the buyer a written Seller's Disclosure Notice, on the statutory form or one substantially similar to it. The Texas Real Estate Commission (TREC) publishes the standard version as form 55-1. The notice is a statement of what the seller knows as of the date signed. It is not a warranty and it does not replace the buyer's inspections.

Plumbing-related items on the Texas notice

Section of the noticeWhat it asks
Item 1: property featuresWhether the property has a plumbing system, septic system, public sewer, disposal, pool and pool equipment, spa, hot tub, automatic lawn sprinkler system, natural gas lines and fuel gas piping type, water heater (gas or electric) and water supply (city, well, MUD or co-op); then whether any of those items are not working, have known defects or need repair
Item 3: known defectsFoundation/slab, floors, walls and ceilings, and "Plumbing/Sewers/Septics"
Item 4: known conditions"Water Damage Not Due to a Flood Event," improper drainage, previous structural repair, and a single blockable main drain in a pool, hot tub or spa
Item 5Any item, equipment or system in need of repair
Items 6 to 8: floodingPresent flood insurance, previous water penetration from a natural flood, reservoir flooding, floodplain location, flood insurance claims (including NFIP) and FEMA or SBA flood assistance
Item 9: otherRoom additions, structural modifications, "or other alterations or repairs made without necessary permits or not in compliance with building codes in effect at that time," and any condition that materially affects health or safety

If a seller does not know an answer, the statute says marking it unknown complies. But "unknown" is not a safe answer for something you actually know about.

Timing and the buyer's walk-away right

The notice must be delivered on or before the effective date of the contract. If the contract is signed without it, the buyer may terminate for any reason within 7 days after receiving the notice. The TREC resale contract (form 20-19) adds that if the buyer never receives it, the buyer may terminate any time before closing and get the earnest money back. Deliver it before you accept an offer.

Who is exempt

Section 5.008(e) lists exemptions, including transfers under a court order or foreclosure, by a trustee in bankruptcy, by a fiduciary administering an estate, guardianship or trust, between co-owners, to a spouse or relatives in the direct line, to or from a government entity, and of a new home never occupied. An estate executor may therefore be exempt from the form, but misstatements or concealment can still lead to fraud or DTPA claims. Ask the estate's attorney.

What Florida sellers must disclose about plumbing

Florida does not have a single statutory disclosure form like Texas. Instead, the rule comes from the Florida Supreme Court. In Johnson v. Davis, 480 So. 2d 625 (Fla. 1985), the court held that "where the seller of a home knows of facts materially affecting the value of the property which are not readily observable and are not known to the buyer, the seller is under a duty to disclose them to the buyer." The case itself involved a roof the sellers said had no problems; after a heavy rain, water was found "gushing" in multiple places.

A Florida Bar Journal review of the case law explains how this works today:

  • Four elements. The seller knew of a defect, it materially affected value, it was not readily observable and not known to the buyer, and the seller failed to disclose it.
  • Silence is enough. A buyer can bring a claim based on mere silence, and the seller's intent does not matter.
  • "As is" does not erase it. Florida appeals courts have held that sellers in residential contracts must still disclose known material defects even with "as-is" language. An as-is clause means the seller does not have to make repairs; it is "not a license to fail to disclose, or worse yet, actively conceal known defects."
  • Residential only. The duty applies to residential sales; commercial sales follow traditional fraud rules.

Florida's statutory flood disclosure

Florida Statutes 689.302 requires a seller of residential real property to give a flood disclosure at or before the time the contract is signed. It states whether the seller knows of flooding that damaged the property during the seller's ownership, has filed a flood insurance claim (including with the National Flood Insurance Program), and has received flood-damage assistance, including from FEMA. Plumbing leaks are not flooding under that statute's definition, but sewage backups and water intrusion during storms often overlap, so be careful and accurate.

The AS IS contract's own statements

In the Florida Realtors/Florida Bar AS IS contract (Rev. 8/24), the seller states it knows of no facts materially affecting value that are not readily observable and have not been disclosed, and that, except as disclosed in writing, it has received no notice of uncorrected building or safety code violations. The permits paragraph says the seller knows of no improvements made without required permits or under permits that were not properly closed.

Do I have to disclose a past slab leak or a repaired leak?

This is the question sellers ask most, and the honest answer is that a known history of water problems is the kind of fact disclosure rules are built for. It is general information, not legal advice, but here is how the two states' rules apply.

Texas

The notice asks whether you are aware of defects or malfunctions in the foundation/slab and in plumbing, whether you are aware of "Water Damage Not Due to a Flood Event," and about previous structural repair. A slab leak that was repaired is not necessarily a current defect, but water damage from it and any foundation work are things the form asks about directly. The safest practice is to disclose the history with a short explanation and attach proof of repair. Concealing a known problem can lead to claims under the Deceptive Trade Practices Act, where knowing conduct can bring up to three times economic damages (Bus. and Com. Code 17.50).

Florida

If the leak was fully repaired and left no hidden damage, it may not "materially affect value" today. But a recurring leak, an unresolved under-slab issue, hidden water damage or mold behind finished walls likely would. Because silence alone can support a Johnson claim, the safest practice is to disclose known past leaks, describe the repair, and provide the invoice and any leak detection or re-test reports.

What a good disclosure looks like

"In March 2025 a hot water line leaked under the slab in the kitchen. A licensed plumber rerouted the line through the attic (invoice attached). The plumber's pressure test after repair passed (report attached). Flooring in the kitchen was replaced. No leaks since." Clear, dated and documented disclosures tend to reassure buyers more than they scare them.

Should I fix plumbing before listing or sell as-is?

There is no one answer. Use these questions:

SituationUsually fix firstUsually sell as-is with price adjustment
Active leak, water heater failing, sewage backupYes; these show up on inspection and scare buyers and insurersOnly if the buyer pool is investors
Missing water heater relief valve or discharge pipeYes; cheap, and Texas inspectors must flag it
Polybutylene supply pipeConsider a repipe or a quote in hand, because many insurers balkInvestor or cash buyer, priced to reflect a repipe
Old cast iron drains (Florida)Get a camera report; spot repair what is failingDisclose report and price it in
Dated but working fixturesRarely worth itYes
Unpermitted plumbing workPermit and inspect it, or close open permitsDisclose and expect a discount

Price context from Fixr and Bob Vila data: water heater replacement typically $874 to $1,765 (Bob Vila citing Angi and HomeAdvisor), repiping $1,500 to $15,000 with a national average of $7,500 (Bob Vila), and slab leak repair $1,000 to $4,000 (Fixr, May 2025). See our plumbing cost guide for more.

Can I sell a house with polybutylene or cast iron as-is?

Yes. Nothing in Texas or Florida law requires you to replace either material before selling. Disclosure still applies to known defects, and the buyer's insurer will likely learn the pipe type anyway, because the Citizens four-point inspection form asks for supply and drain pipe types, including polybutylene and cast iron. If insurance becomes the obstacle, your buyer may cancel during the inspection or option period, so pricing the house with that in mind avoids a failed contract. Our polybutylene guide and cast iron guide have the details.

Do I need to disclose polybutylene in Texas?

The Texas form does not name polybutylene. It asks about known defects in plumbing and whether the plumbing system needs repair. If you know the house has polybutylene and it has leaked, or a plumber told you it should be replaced, that is a known defect or need for repair. Even if it has not leaked, disclosing a known pipe material that affects insurability avoids later disputes.

Should I get a pre-listing plumbing inspection?

Pros: you find problems on your schedule, get competitive bids instead of a rushed repair during escrow, and can price the house correctly. A clean sewer camera report can also be a selling point on an older home.

Cons: once you know about a defect, you must disclose it. You also pay for inspections the buyer will likely repeat.

A middle path many sellers choose: a sewer camera inspection on an older house (Fixr's January 2025 data puts specialty sewer inspections at $200 to $1,000), a meter leak test, and photos and age of the water heater. Those three cover the most common plumbing deal killers.

Do I have to disclose unpermitted plumbing?

In Texas, yes, if you know about it. Item 9 of the notice asks directly about "alterations or repairs made without necessary permits or not in compliance with building codes in effect at that time." Texas cities over 5,000 people must require permits for plumbing work, except for leak repairs and replacing faucets, ballcocks, disposals or toilets (Occupations Code 1301.551).

In Florida, the AS IS contract's permits disclosure has the seller state it knows of no unpermitted improvements or open permits, and if the seller identifies any, it must deliver the plans and documents it has. Florida Statutes 553.79 lets a property owner close a permit by hiring the original or another licensed contractor, or by acting as an owner-builder. An expired permit whose work is substantially complete can sometimes be closed without a new permit, and a local agency may close a permit 6 years after issuance if no safety hazard exists. Clean up open permits before listing, because a title company may find them anyway.

Repair negotiations, receipts and warranties

Texas contract rules

Under the TREC resale contract (form 20-19):

  • The buyer may accept the property as-is, or as-is with specific listed repairs; the form warns against vague phrases like "subject to inspections."
  • Agreed repairs must be done by persons licensed to do them, with required permits, before closing unless agreed otherwise. The seller must give the buyer documentation showing the scope of work and payment, and transfer any transferable warranties at closing.
  • Neither party must pay for lender-required repairs unless agreed. If they cannot agree, the contract terminates; if lender-required repairs exceed 5 percent of the sales price, the buyer may terminate.
  • During the option period, the buyer can terminate for any reason, so a buyer can walk away over a sewer scope result.

Florida contract rules

Under the AS IS contract, the seller is not required to make repairs. The buyer can cancel during the inspection period (15 days if left blank). Plumbing findings usually lead to a price reduction, a credit if the lender allows it, or a cancellation. The seller must keep the property in the condition it was in on the effective date, except for ordinary wear and tear, so a new leak during the contract is the seller's to handle.

Keep every receipt

Invoices, permits, leak detection reports and warranties are your best evidence that problems were handled. Keep a single folder for the buyer and the closing agent. Repairs by licensed plumbers are easier to verify: Texas buyers can check a plumber at the Texas State Board of Plumbing Examiners' license search, and Florida buyers at myfloridalicense.com.

Should I offer a home warranty to buyers?

A home warranty, called a residential service contract in Texas, can reassure a buyer about older fixtures, water heaters and appliances. The TREC resale contract lets the seller agree to reimburse the buyer at closing for a residential service contract up to a stated dollar amount, and notes those contracts are offered by providers licensed by the Texas Department of Licensing and Regulation. Buyers should review the coverage, exclusions and limits; most contracts exclude known pre-existing conditions and many under-slab or underground repairs. A warranty is not a substitute for disclosing a known defect. See our home warranty plumbing guide.

Can buyers back out over a sewer scope or plumbing report?

Usually, yes, if they act within their contract's window. In Texas, a buyer who paid the option fee has an unrestricted right to terminate during the option period. In Florida, a buyer under the AS IS contract can cancel during the inspection period if the property is "not acceptable to Buyer" in the buyer's sole discretion. After those windows close, the buyer generally loses that easy exit. That is why serious problems tend to surface, and get negotiated, in the first week or two of a contract.

If a buyer's sewer scope shows a belly, roots or a crack, ask for the video and the plumber's written recommendation, then get your own quote. A spot repair is often far cheaper than the full replacement a report may suggest, and Bob Vila's data puts typical full sewer line replacement at $1,253 to $4,701. See our sewer camera inspection guide.

Does a repaired slab leak lower home value?

We did not find a reliable, dated study measuring how much a repaired slab leak changes sale prices in Texas or Florida, so be skeptical of any specific percentage you hear. What matters to buyers, appraisers and insurers is usually whether the repair is documented and whether there is lasting damage. A repair with an invoice, a passing re-test and no foundation movement is a solved problem. An undocumented repair, repeated leaks, or a foundation repair without engineering paperwork raises more concern. For detail on repair methods, see our slab leak guide.

Landlords and estates selling a property

If the house is rented, your repair duties to the tenant continue until the sale closes. In Texas, landlords must make a diligent effort to repair conditions that materially affect health or safety after proper notice (Property Code 92.052), and in Florida landlords must keep plumbing in reasonable working condition where no local code applies (Fla. Stat. 83.51). Do not let a known leak sit because a sale is pending. Our Texas landlord and Florida landlord guides cover the rules.

For inherited homes, the executor may not know the plumbing history. In Texas, a transfer by a fiduciary administering an estate is exempt from the 5.008 form, but anything the estate does know and say must be accurate. A pre-listing sewer scope and leak test can fill in what the family does not know.

How to choose a provider

  • Gather invoices, permits, leak detection and sewer reports for all past plumbing work.
  • Note the water heater age and photograph its label.
  • Run a meter leak test before listing.
  • Consider a sewer camera inspection on an older home.
  • Close or resolve open permits.
  • Fill out the Texas Seller's Disclosure Notice (or Florida disclosures) accurately; attach repair documents.
  • Deliver disclosures before accepting an offer.
  • Decide in advance which repairs you will offer and which you will price in.
  • Use licensed plumbers for any agreed repairs and keep the paperwork.
  • Keep repairing tenant-reported problems until closing if the house is rented.

Related plumbing guides

Plumbing by state and city

Questions people ask

Do I have to disclose a plumbing leak that was fixed years ago?

In Texas, the notice asks about known water damage not due to a flood event, foundation problems and plumbing defects; a past leak with lasting damage or foundation work fits those questions. In Florida, sellers must disclose known facts that materially affect value and are not readily observable. A fully repaired leak with no lingering damage may not qualify, but disclosing it with the invoice is the safest course.

What happens if I don't disclose a known plumbing problem?

In Texas, a buyer who did not get the disclosure can terminate within 7 days of receiving it, and concealment after closing can lead to DTPA or fraud claims, including up to three times economic damages for knowing conduct. In Florida, buyers can sue under Johnson v. Davis based on silence alone, and an as-is clause does not protect a seller who hid a known defect. Talk to an attorney.

Can I mark 'unknown' on the Texas disclosure?

Yes, if you truly do not know. The statute says a seller who indicates that information is unknown complies with the section. It is not a shield for things you do know about. If you have invoices, reports or memories of a leak, disclose them accurately.

Do I have to fix problems found on the buyer's inspection?

No, in either state you are not required to make repairs unless you agree to in the contract. In Texas, the buyer may terminate during the option period or ask for repairs or a price change. In Florida's AS IS contract, the seller has no repair obligation, and the buyer may cancel during the inspection period.

Who has to do agreed plumbing repairs in a Texas sale?

Under the TREC resale contract, agreed repairs must be performed by persons licensed to do them, with any required permits, and the seller must give the buyer documentation of the scope of work and payment, plus transfer any transferable warranties at closing. For plumbing, that means a TSBPE-licensed plumber working under a Responsible Master Plumber.

Does an as-is sale in Florida mean I don't have to disclose?

No. The Florida Bar Journal review of the case law says the answer is emphatically no: an as-is clause in a residential contract means the seller does not have to repair, not that the seller may stay silent about known material defects that are not readily observable.

Should I disclose a past sewer backup?

Yes, if it caused damage or reveals a continuing problem such as roots or a broken line. In Texas, the notice asks about known defects in plumbing and sewers and about water damage; in Florida, the Johnson duty applies to known material problems. Disclose the date, cause and repair, and attach the camera report or invoice if you have them.

Do I need a permit to repair plumbing before selling?

It depends on the work and city. Texas exempts leak repairs and replacing faucets, ballcocks, disposals and toilets from permits, while water heater replacements generally need permits, for example in Houston and Jacksonville. Miami-Dade exempts licensed-contractor repairs under $500. Using a licensed plumber who pulls required permits makes your repair receipts more convincing to buyers.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration