New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Fri, Nov 20, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · Roofing

When a 'Free Roof' Becomes Insurance Fraud: Legal Risks for Homeowners

Deductible waivers, padded estimates and 'free roof' pitches put homeowners, not just roofers, at legal risk. Here is what Texas and Florida law actually says, what can happen to you, how insurers claw back money, and how to report a scheme.

A roof is never legally free if insurance pays for it: you must pay your deductible in both Texas and Florida. A roofer who waives or rebates it breaks the law (a Class B misdemeanor in Texas, a third-degree felony for contractors in Florida). Homeowners who knowingly sign or submit false or inflated claim information can face insurance fraud charges, restitution and repayment demands. Refuse the offer, keep proof you paid your deductible, and report the contractor.

Key facts

  • Texas Insurance Code Ch. 707 requires the insured to pay any applicable deductible on a property claim.
  • In Texas, a seller who waives, absorbs or rebates an insured's deductible without the insurer's consent commits a Class B misdemeanor (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code 27.02).
  • In Florida, a contractor who knowingly waives, pays or rebates an insurance deductible with intent to defraud commits a third-degree felony (Fla. Stat. 817.234(7)(d)).
  • Florida contractors may not offer cash, gift cards, coupons, rebates or deductible waivers in exchange for a roof inspection or a roof claim (Fla. Stat. 489.147).
  • Texas insurance fraud ranges from a Class C misdemeanor for claims under $100 to a first-degree felony at $300,000 or more; $2,500 to under $30,000 is a state jail felony (Tex. Penal Code 35.02).
  • Florida insurance fraud is a third-degree felony under $20,000, second-degree from $20,000 to under $100,000, and first-degree at $100,000 or more (Fla. Stat. 817.234(11)).
  • Texas courts must order a person convicted of insurance fraud to pay restitution, including court costs and attorney fees, to the insurer (Tex. Penal Code 35.02(e)).
  • TDI says an insurer may cancel a Texas home policy at any time if you file a fraudulent claim.
  • Florida roof solicitations urging a claim must state, in large type, that the consumer pays the deductible and that deductible waivers and false claims are third-degree felony insurance fraud (Fla. Stat. 489.147).

Why 'free roof' offers are a legal trap

After big hail in Dallas or a hurricane in Tampa, door-knockers often say some version of: "Your insurance will buy you a new roof and it won't cost you a dime." The pitch sounds harmless because the insurer is a big company and you are a homeowner with a real storm. But the promise of no cost can only come true one of three ways, and all three are illegal:

  1. The roofer waives or rebates your deductible, or hides it with a fake discount.
  2. The roofer inflates the claim to cover the deductible: extra squares, an extra layer, damage that isn't there, or upgrades billed as repairs.
  3. The roofer adds damage, sometimes literally, by bruising shingles with tools to fake hail hits.

Texas and Florida both made the homeowner's deductible part of the law, not just the policy. Texas Insurance Code Chapter 707 requires the insured to pay any applicable deductible. Florida requires roof solicitations to warn in bold type that you pay the deductible and that waivers and false claims are felony insurance fraud. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) puts it simply: it is illegal for contractors or roofers to offer to waive a deductible or promise a deductible rebate, and insurers may ask for proof that you paid it.

Is it insurance fraud if a roofer waives my deductible?

Texas

Texas Business and Commerce Code Section 27.02 makes it a Class B misdemeanor for a person who sells goods or services paid by an insurance claim to waive, absorb, rebate, or otherwise help you avoid the deductible without the insurer's consent. Contracts expected to be paid by insurance and priced at $1,000 or more must include a 12-point bold notice that Texas law requires you to pay the deductible. Under Chapter 707, an insurer with replacement cost coverage may hold back the depreciation payment until you show reasonable proof you paid the deductible: a canceled check, money order receipt, card statement, or installment contract.

Florida

Florida Statute 817.234(7)(d) says a contractor may not knowingly or willfully, with intent to defraud, pay, waive or rebate all or part of an insurance deductible for repairs covered by a property policy. Doing so is a third-degree felony. Separately, Statute 489.147 bars contractors from offering anything of value, including a deductible waiver, a gift card, or cash, in exchange for a roof inspection or making a roof claim. Fines run up to $10,000 per violation, and the acts of paid canvassers are attributed to the contractor.

What about the homeowner?

The deductible statutes are aimed at the seller. But a homeowner who knowingly helps hide a deductible from the insurer can be caught by the general fraud statutes below. For example, if you sign an invoice listing a price you know is inflated so the insurer covers your deductible, that invoice is a false statement in support of a claim. Texas Penal Code 35.02(b) also makes it an offense to solicit, offer, pay or receive a benefit in connection with goods or services billed to insurance, with intent to defraud the insurer.

Can I go to jail for letting a roofer inflate my claim?

Yes, if you knew. Both states' fraud laws turn on intent and knowledge. Honest mistakes, honest disagreements over cost, and a contractor's secret padding that you didn't know about are not crimes by you. Knowingly signing or submitting false information is.

Texas Penal Code 35.02

A person commits insurance fraud if, with intent to defraud or deceive an insurer, the person prepares or presents a statement supporting a claim that the person knows contains false or misleading material information. The grade depends on the value of the claim:

Value of the claimOffense (Texas)
Under $100Class C misdemeanor
$100 to under $750Class B misdemeanor
$750 to under $2,500Class A misdemeanor
$2,500 to under $30,000State jail felony
$30,000 to under $150,000Third-degree felony
$150,000 to under $300,000Second-degree felony
$300,000 or moreFirst-degree felony

The court must order restitution to the insurer, including court costs and attorney fees. If part of the claim was a valid covered loss, the value of the claim for grading is the difference between the total and the valid part (Sec. 35.02(g)). That rule matters for roofs: a real hail claim padded by $8,000 is graded on the $8,000.

Florida Statute 817.234

A person commits insurance fraud if, with intent to injure, defraud or deceive an insurer, the person presents, prepares or makes a statement supporting a claim knowing it contains false, incomplete or misleading material information. Penalties by value of the property involved:

ValueOffense (Florida)
Under $20,000Third-degree felony
$20,000 to under $100,000Second-degree felony
$100,000 or moreFirst-degree felony

Florida also gives an insurer harmed by a violation, after a criminal conviction, a civil cause of action to recover compensatory damages plus investigation and litigation expenses (817.234(5)).

Plain example: A Houston roofer tells you, "Sign here. I wrote the job at $26,000 instead of $22,000 so the insurance covers your deductible." If you sign knowing that, you have helped present false material information. At that value, it would fall in Texas's state jail felony range.

What if a roofer adds damage that didn't happen to my estimate?

This can happen without your knowledge: a roofer adds a second layer that doesn't exist, bills for decking that wasn't replaced, or photographs another house's roof. Some contractors have been accused of creating hail marks with tools. If you find out:

  1. Don't sign or submit anything you know is false. That includes a certificate of completion listing work not done.
  2. Tell your insurer in writing what you found and correct the record. This protects you and shows you weren't part of it.
  3. Keep the evidence: the estimate, texts, emails, photos, and the name of the salesperson.
  4. Report it to the state fraud unit (see below).
  5. Don't pay for work not done. In Texas, TDI advises not paying in full up front and not making the final payment until work is done.

Note on contractors running your claim: in Texas, a contractor may not act as a public adjuster on property it repairs or may repair (Tex. Ins. Code 4102.163). In Florida, a contractor may not interpret your policy or adjust your claim unless licensed as a public adjuster (Fla. Stat. 489.147). A roofer who wants to "handle everything with your insurance" is a warning sign.

Can my insurer demand money back after paying a roof claim?

Yes, in several situations. These are general patterns; your policy's fraud and concealment clause controls.

  • Overpayment or mistake: if the insurer paid for work that wasn't done (for example, depreciation released on a fake invoice), it may demand repayment and sue to recover it.
  • Fraud or concealment: most policies say coverage is void if you intentionally conceal or misrepresent a material fact about a claim. The insurer may deny the whole claim, not just the padded part, and seek repayment.
  • Criminal restitution: Texas courts must order restitution to the insurer on a fraud conviction (Penal Code 35.02(e)). Florida gives insurers a civil action after a conviction (817.234(5)).
  • Cancellation: TDI says a Texas insurer may cancel a policy at any time if you file a fraudulent claim. That can also make future coverage harder to find.
  • Depreciation and deductible proof: Texas insurers can withhold depreciation until you prove you paid the deductible. If you later can't prove it, the holdback may never be paid.

If you get a repayment demand or a recorded-statement request involving possible fraud, talk to a licensed attorney before responding in detail.

Is a 'free roof' ever legit?

A roof is never free if insurance pays for it, because you owe the deductible. But there are legitimate ways a roof can cost you little or nothing beyond that:

  • A real covered loss on a replacement cost policy: you pay the deductible and the insurer pays the rest of a fair estimate. That is not "free," but it is normal.
  • A legitimate discount that is real and disclosed: a roofer can lower its price, but the insurer must be told the real contract price. A discount that only exists to cancel your deductible is the problem.
  • Florida's My Safe Florida Home program: state grants for hurricane mitigation, including some roof work, with a homeowner match for most applicants and no match for low-income homeowners up to $10,000. Funding depends on yearly appropriations. See My Safe Florida Home roof grants.
  • Warranty claims: a manufacturer or workmanship warranty may cover a defective roof. See roof warranties explained.

Any offer that says you'll pay nothing, or that dangles a gift card, cash, or "we'll cover your deductible," should end the conversation.

Red flags that a roof deal crosses the line

What you hearWhy it's a problem
"We'll take care of your deductible."Deductible waivers are illegal in both states.
"We'll give you a $500 gift card for a free inspection."Florida bans inducements for roof inspections or claims (489.147).
"Just sign this so we can talk to your insurance."May be a contingency agreement, an assignment, or a power of attorney. Florida voids post-loss assignments for policies issued on or after Jan. 1, 2023 (627.7152); Texas bars contractors acting as public adjusters.
"We'll write it as a full replacement; nobody checks."Inflation of the claim is the core of insurance fraud.
"Sign the completion certificate now so we can get the depreciation."Certifying unfinished work supports a false claim.
"Endorse the check over to us."The FTC advises never signing an insurance check over to a contractor.
"We're from out of state, here for the storm."Not illegal itself, but in Florida unlicensed contracting during a declared emergency is a third-degree felony (489.127).

Your protections when signing a roof contract

  • Florida 10-day cancel after emergencies: if you sign a residential roof contract within 180 days of an event under a Governor's state of emergency for your area, you can cancel without penalty within 10 days or by the official start date, whichever comes first, by certified mail or other proof of mailing (489.147). DFS publishes a Notice of Roofing Contract Cancellation form.
  • Florida missing notice: if a roof contract omits the required notice of the inducement ban, you may void it within 10 days after signing (489.147).
  • Texas door-to-door cancel: home-solicitation sales over $25 can generally be canceled until midnight of the third business day after signing (Bus. & Com. Code Ch. 601).
  • Texas deductible notice: contracts of $1,000 or more expected to be paid by insurance must carry the bold deductible notice (27.02).
  • Licensing: Florida roofers must hold a DBPR roofing license (number beginning with CCC for certified or RC for registered); Texas has no state roofing license. See Florida license lookup and vetting a Texas roofer.

How to report roof insurance fraud

What happenedTexasFlorida
Padded or false claim, deductible waiverTDI Fraud Unit (online fraud report; FraudUnit@tdi.texas.gov). TDI's Help Line, 800-252-3439, can help you choose between a complaint and a fraud report.DFS Criminal Investigations Division, Bureau of Insurance Fraud (report online or through DFS's helpline, 1-877-693-5236)
TWIA claim fraudTWIA fraud hotline (Veracity Research Company), 800-625-0425Not applicable
Unlicensed or scam contractorTexas Attorney General consumer complaint (complaints are public under Texas law)DBPR complaint portal or Unlicensed Activity program, 850-487-1395
Any disaster scamFTC, ReportFraud.ftc.govFTC, ReportFraud.ftc.gov
Your insurer's own conductTDI complaint (for denials or amounts)DFS consumer services request for help

TDI's rule of thumb: file a complaint if you disagree with a claim denial or amount; file a fraud report if you suspect a criminal act such as a false or padded claim. Tell your own insurer as well, in writing, if a claim on your home is involved.

Honest mistakes vs. fraud: where the line is

Fear of fraud should not stop anyone from filing a real claim or arguing for a fair price. Both states' fraud laws require that you knew the information was false or misleading and acted with intent to deceive the insurer. These are normal parts of a claim, not fraud:

  • Disagreeing with the adjuster's estimate and submitting your roofer's higher line-item estimate.
  • Asking for a supplement when rotted decking or a hidden layer turns up during tear-off, with photos.
  • Getting the date of loss slightly wrong and correcting it once you check storm records.
  • Not noticing damage until later and reporting it when you find it, within the deadline.
  • Choosing a better shingle and paying the upgrade yourself, as long as the invoice shows the upgrade honestly.

The line is crossed when someone knowingly misstates facts that matter to the payment: work that wasn't done, damage that didn't happen, a price that isn't the real price, or a deductible that was secretly forgiven. A good habit: before you sign any invoice or certificate, read the numbers and ask, "Is every line true?" If the answer is no, don't sign, and ask the contractor to fix it in writing.

What contractors face: in Florida, violating 489.147 brings fines up to $10,000 per violation, and contracting without a license during a declared state of emergency is a third-degree felony (489.127). In Texas, deductible waivers are a Class B misdemeanor and false claims fall under Penal Code 35.02. Knowing the contractor carries this risk helps you push back when a salesperson insists "everyone does it."

If you already signed something you regret

  1. Stop and read it. Is it an inspection authorization, a contingency agreement, a full contract, an assignment, or a power of attorney?
  2. Check the cancellation window. Florida's 10-day post-emergency right and Texas's 3-business-day home-solicitation right run from signing.
  3. Cancel in writing with proof of mailing, and keep a copy.
  4. Call your insurer to confirm you control the claim and that no one else is authorized to speak for you.
  5. Don't sign a completion certificate or invoice you know is wrong.
  6. Get advice: TDI or DFS helplines, legal aid, or a licensed attorney. See storm chaser scams and contingency agreements.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. If you are contacted by a fraud investigator or receive a repayment demand, speak with a licensed attorney.

How to choose a provider

  • Plan to pay your deductible and keep proof (canceled check, card statement or receipt).
  • Refuse any deductible waiver, rebate, gift card or cash for an inspection or claim.
  • Never sign an invoice, estimate or completion certificate you know is inaccurate.
  • Read every document before signing; ask whether it is a contract, contingency agreement or assignment.
  • Keep control of your claim; don't let a roofer act as your adjuster.
  • Never endorse the insurance check over to the contractor.
  • Use your cancellation rights in writing if you signed under pressure.
  • Tell your insurer in writing if you discover padded or false items.
  • Report suspected fraud to TDI's Fraud Unit or Florida DFS's Bureau of Insurance Fraud.
  • Report unlicensed contractors to DBPR in Florida or the Attorney General in Texas.

Related roofing guides

Roofing by state and city

Questions people ask

Is it insurance fraud if a roofer waives my deductible?

It is illegal for the roofer in both states. In Texas, waiving or rebating a deductible without the insurer's consent is a Class B misdemeanor under Business and Commerce Code 27.02. In Florida, a contractor who knowingly waives or rebates a deductible with intent to defraud commits a third-degree felony under Statute 817.234. A homeowner who knowingly signs inflated paperwork to hide the waiver risks fraud charges too.

Can I go to jail for letting a roofer inflate my claim?

If you knowingly signed or submitted false information to get paid, yes. Texas grades insurance fraud from a Class C misdemeanor up to a first-degree felony depending on the claim value, and $2,500 to under $30,000 is a state jail felony. Florida makes it a felony at every level, starting at third degree under $20,000. Honest mistakes and secret padding you didn't know about are not your crimes.

Is a free roof ever legit?

Not if insurance pays for it, because you must pay your deductible in both states. What is legitimate: a covered storm claim where you pay the deductible and the insurer pays the rest; a disclosed price discount reported honestly to the insurer; a manufacturer warranty claim; or a Florida My Safe Florida Home grant, which most applicants must match.

What if a roofer adds damage that didn't happen to my estimate?

Don't sign or submit it. Tell your insurer in writing what you found, keep the paperwork and messages, and report the contractor to TDI's Fraud Unit in Texas or Florida DFS's Bureau of Insurance Fraud. Correcting the record quickly shows you weren't part of the scheme. Don't pay for work that wasn't done.

Can my insurer demand money back after paying a roof claim?

Yes. If the payment was based on false information, a mistake, or work that wasn't done, the insurer can demand repayment and sue. Many policies void coverage for intentional concealment. After a fraud conviction, Texas courts must order restitution to the insurer, and Florida law gives insurers a civil action for damages and investigation costs.

Does a roofer's gift card for an inspection break the law?

In Florida, yes. Statute 489.147 bars contractors from offering residential owners a rebate, gift, gift card, cash, coupon, deductible waiver or anything of value for a roof inspection or for making a roof claim, with fines up to $10,000 per violation. Texas law targets deductible waivers and rebates; a gift tied to a claim is risky there too.

Where do I report a roofing insurance scam?

In Texas, file a fraud report with TDI's Fraud Unit, call TWIA's fraud hotline at 800-625-0425 for TWIA claims, and file a consumer complaint with the Attorney General. In Florida, report to DFS's Bureau of Insurance Fraud and report unlicensed contractors to DBPR at 850-487-1395. Anywhere, you can report to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration