New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Thu, Nov 19, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · Roofing

Bad Roof Job or Roofer Won't Finish: Your Options in Texas and Florida

A neutral, step-by-step path for homeowners with leaks, shoddy work or an abandoned job: document it, send the right pre-suit notice (Texas Chapter 27 or Florida Chapter 558), use agency complaints, small claims, and Florida's Recovery Fund, without creating a lien problem.

If your roofer did bad work or won't finish, document everything, get an independent inspection, and send a written demand. Before suing over a defect, Texas requires a Chapter 27 notice by certified mail at least 60 days before filing, and Florida requires a Chapter 558 notice of claim at least 60 days before filing. Florida homeowners can also file a DBPR complaint and may qualify for the Recovery Fund. Small claims limits are $20,000 in Texas justice court and $8,000 in Florida.

Key facts

  • Texas Property Code Chapter 27 requires written notice of construction defects by certified mail, return receipt requested, at least 60 days before suing a residential contractor (Tex. Prop. Code 27.004).
  • Under Texas Chapter 27, the contractor may inspect during the 35 days after notice and may make a written settlement offer within 60 days; rejecting a reasonable offer can limit what you recover (Tex. Prop. Code 27.004).
  • Texas Chapter 27 does not apply to claims for a contractor's wrongful abandonment of a project before completion (Tex. Prop. Code 27.002).
  • Florida Chapter 558 requires a written notice of claim at least 60 days before filing a construction defect suit (120 days for associations over 20 parcels); the contractor must respond within 45 days (Fla. Stat. 558.004).
  • Texas justice courts hear civil cases up to $20,000, excluding interest (Tex. Gov't Code 27.031).
  • Florida's Small Claims Rules apply to county court cases up to $8,000, excluding costs, interest and attorney's fees (Fla. Sm. Cl. R. 7.010).
  • Florida generally gives 4 years to sue over construction of an improvement, with a 7-year outer limit for latent defects (Fla. Stat. 95.11(3)(b)).
  • A Florida contractor who has been paid more than the value of work done may not stop work for any 90-day period, and the board may presume abandonment after 90 days without just cause (Fla. Stat. 489.126; 489.129).
  • Florida's Recovery Fund can pay up to $100,000 per roofing claim on contracts signed on or after July 1, 2024, after a judgment or board order and collection efforts (Fla. Stat. 489.141; 489.143).

Start here: the 8-step path

Most roofing disputes end without a lawsuit when the homeowner follows a clear sequence and keeps records. Here is the order that protects your rights in both states.

  1. Stop further damage. If water is coming in, make emergency temporary repairs (a tarp) and keep receipts. Both states' pre-suit laws allow necessary emergency repairs.
  2. Document. Photos and video of the roof, attic and ceilings with dates; every contract, change order, invoice, payment record, text and email.
  3. Get an independent inspection from someone with no stake in the dispute (a roofing consultant, engineer, or licensed inspector). Ask for a written report with photos that ties each problem to the code, the manufacturer's instructions, or the contract.
  4. Send a written demand to the roofer listing the problems and a reasonable deadline to fix them. Keep a copy.
  5. Check warranties. Read the workmanship warranty and the manufacturer warranty. A manufacturer claim may cover defective materials even if the roofer won't respond.
  6. Send the statutory pre-suit notice if you may sue: Texas Chapter 27 or Florida Chapter 558 (details below).
  7. File agency complaints: DBPR in Florida; the Texas Attorney General for deceptive practices; your city building department for code issues.
  8. Choose a forum: negotiate or mediate, small claims, regular court, or arbitration if your contract requires it. In Florida, a judgment against a licensed contractor may open the Recovery Fund.

This page is general information, not legal advice. For disputes over a few thousand dollars, a consultation with a construction or consumer attorney is often worth it, especially before you withhold money or reject an offer.

What can I do if my roofer did a bad job?

Figure out what 'bad' means

Problems fall into three groups, and each points to a different fix:

Type of problemExamplesMain path
Workmanship defectLeaks at flashing, high nails, missing drip edge, crooked courses, wrong nailing patternWorkmanship warranty; Chapter 27 (TX) or 558 (FL) notice; claim against the contractor
Material defectShingles blistering, cracking or losing granules early when installed correctlyManufacturer warranty claim
Code violationMissing Florida secondary water barrier, deck nailing, failed or skipped inspectionBuilding department; Florida also allows a civil action for material code violations (s. 553.84)
Contract breachWrong shingle line or color, items in the contract not installed, no cleanupWritten demand; contract claim
AbandonmentDeposit paid, little or no work, contractor stops answeringAgency complaint; contract and fraud claims; in Florida, Recovery Fund

Check the permit

Call your building department and ask whether the permit was finaled (passed final inspection). If the job failed inspection, the inspector's notes are strong evidence. If no permit was pulled where one was required, report it.

My roofer won't come back to fix leaks. What now?

  1. Send a written warranty demand. Quote the workmanship warranty, list each leak with dates and photos, and give a deadline (for example, 14 days) to schedule repairs. Send it by certified mail and email.
  2. Protect the house. Tarp if needed. Keep receipts. Don't make permanent repairs yet if you may pursue a claim; let the roofer and your own inspector document the condition first, unless it is an emergency.
  3. If the roofer is out of business, check whether you have a manufacturer extended warranty that includes workmanship coverage. Some top-tier warranties cover installation errors, which can outlast the roofer. See roof warranties explained.
  4. Send the pre-suit notice (Chapter 27 or 558) if the roofer still won't act.

Texas: the Residential Construction Liability Act (Chapter 27) 60-day notice

Texas Property Code Chapter 27, often called the RCLA, governs claims against residential contractors for construction defects, including repairs and alterations to an existing home. It prevails over the Texas DTPA and common-law claims where they conflict, and an attempted waiver of it in a contract is void.

The steps and deadlines

StepDeadlineDetails
Your noticeAt least 60 days before you file suit or start arbitrationWritten, by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the contractor's last known address. Describe the defects in reasonable detail and provide evidence such as photos, videos and expert reports.
Contractor inspectionDuring the 35 days after the contractor receives noticeOn written request, the contractor gets a reasonable opportunity to inspect, up to 3 inspections.
Contractor's offerWithin 60 days after receiving noticeOffer to repair (in detail, with timing), a monetary settlement, or both. Sent by certified mail.
Your response if unreasonableWithin 25 days after you receive the offerExplain in writing and in detail why the offer is unreasonable. An offer not accepted within 25 days is considered rejected.
Supplemental offerWithin 10 days after the contractor gets your responseContractor may make one more offer.
Repairs under accepted offerWithin 60 days after the contractor receives your acceptanceUnless you or events beyond its control delay it.

Why the offer matters

If you reject a reasonable offer, or don't let the contractor inspect or repair under an accepted offer, your recovery can be limited to the value of the contractor's last offer, plus fees incurred before rejection. If the contractor makes no reasonable offer, those limits don't apply. If it refuses to start repairs under an accepted offer, the limits don't apply either.

What you can recover

Chapter 27 limits damages to economic losses such as the reasonable cost of repairs, replacement or repair of damaged goods in the home, engineering and consulting fees, temporary housing during repairs, reduced market value for structural failures, and reasonable attorney's fees.

Exceptions

  • Chapter 27 does not apply to damages from the contractor's wrongful abandonment of the project before completion, or to certain fraud claims under Business and Commerce Code 27.01.
  • If the defect creates an imminent threat to health or safety, the contractor must take reasonable steps to cure it as soon as practicable after notice. If it fails, you can have it cured and recover the reasonable cost plus attorney's fees.
  • If you file suit for more than $7,500, either side may move to compel mediation within 90 days.

Your written contract should already contain a 10-point bold Chapter 27 notice. If it doesn't, Texas lets you recover a $500 civil penalty from the contractor.

Texas time limits

Chapter 27 does not extend any limitations period. DTPA claims must generally be brought within 2 years of the deceptive act or its discovery. Contract claims have their own limits. Don't let the 60-day notice period run you past a deadline; if a limitations deadline is close, Chapter 27 lets you file and the notice steps happen during the case.

Florida: the Chapter 558 construction defect notice

Florida Statutes Chapter 558 sets a notice-and-opportunity-to-repair process for construction defect claims against contractors, subcontractors, suppliers and design professionals. It covers defects from defective materials, code violations, design failures, and work not done to 'accepted trade standards for good and workmanlike construction.'

The steps and deadlines

StepDeadlineDetails
Your notice of claimAt least 60 days before filing suit (120 days for associations of more than 20 parcels)Must refer to Chapter 558, describe each defect and the resulting damage in reasonable detail, and identify locations. Serve the person you contracted with. Service means certified mail with delivery record, hand delivery or courier with proof. Try to serve within 15 days of discovering a defect, but late service does not bar your claim.
Contractor inspectionWithin 30 days after serviceYou must give reasonable access during normal working hours. Destructive testing has extra rules.
Contractor forwards to subsWithin 10 days after serviceIt may send your notice to subcontractors or suppliers it thinks are responsible.
Contractor's written responseWithin 45 days after serviceOffer to repair at no cost (with details and timetable), offer to pay, offer both, dispute the claim, or say its insurer will decide within 30 days.
Your acceptance or rejectionWithin 45 days after receiving an offerIn writing. If you sue without responding, the court can stay the case.

If the contractor disputes the claim or doesn't respond in time, you may proceed with a lawsuit without further notice. If you accept and the contractor doesn't repair or pay as agreed, you may sue without further notice. If it does repair or pay as agreed, your claim on those defects ends.

Important details

  • Serving a 558 notice tolls the statute of limitations until 90 days after service (120 for large associations), or 30 days after an accepted repair or payment period ends, whichever is later.
  • The notice is required only after 'completion of a building or improvement' (a certificate of occupancy or equivalent, or substantial completion where none is issued). It is not intended to block an owner from finishing a job the contractor never completed.
  • You can make emergency repairs needed to protect health, safety and welfare.
  • Where an arbitration clause conflicts with Chapter 558, Chapter 558 controls.
  • Your contract should contain the notice 'Any claims for construction defects are subject to the notice and cure provisions of Chapter 558, Florida Statutes,' but leaving it out does not penalize anyone.

Florida time limits

Florida generally allows 4 years to sue over the design, planning or construction of an improvement to real property, running from the certificate of occupancy or completion (or abandonment). For latent defects the clock runs from discovery, but no later than 7 years. Claims on a written contract have their own period. Ask an attorney which applies to your roof.

Can I withhold final payment for a bad roof job?

Sometimes, but it is the riskiest move in a roofing dispute, because it can trigger a lien. Understand the rules first.

Texas

  • You are required to hold back 10% of the contract price (retainage) during the work and for 30 days after completion. That is not 'withholding'; it is the law.
  • If you received a notice of an unpaid claim from a subcontractor or supplier, you may be required to withhold enough to cover it until the dispute is resolved.
  • An original contractor on a residential project can file a lien affidavit by the 15th day of the 3rd month after the month its work was completed, terminated or abandoned. On a homestead, the lien is valid only if the written contract met the homestead formalities (signed before work, both spouses, filed with the county clerk).

Florida

  • A contractor can record a claim of lien up to 90 days after its final furnishing of labor or materials.
  • Before the contractor can sue to enforce its lien, it must give you its final payment affidavit at least 5 days before filing.
  • A lien that willfully exaggerates the amount or includes work not performed is a fraudulent lien, which is a complete defense and can give you a damages claim.

How to withhold more safely

  1. Withhold only an amount that reasonably matches the cost to fix the documented problems, backed by an independent estimate.
  2. Tell the contractor in writing exactly what you are withholding and why, and that you will pay when the items are fixed.
  3. Follow your contract's dispute process.
  4. Send the Chapter 27 or 558 notice so the statutory process starts.

See roofing liens and how to remove one.

What if the roofer abandoned the job after taking a deposit?

Florida

  • If the contractor took more than 10% up front, it had to apply for the permit within 30 days and start within 90 days of the permit, unless you agreed in writing otherwise.
  • A contractor that has been paid more than the value of work done may not stop work for any 90-day period. Misapplying deposit money is a crime: a felony at $1,000 and up, and intent to repay is not a defense.
  • DBPR may presume a project abandoned after 90 days if the contractor terminates without just cause or notice, or fails to work for 90 consecutive days without just cause. Abandonment is one of the grounds that can lead to the Recovery Fund.
  • Florida DFS says a contractor who receives an insurance payment and abandons the job is committing insurance fraud. Report it to DFS at 1-800-378-0445.

Texas

  • Chapter 27's notice-and-offer process does not apply to wrongful abandonment, so you may not need to wait 60 days for that part of your claim.
  • File a complaint with the Texas Attorney General's consumer protection division. Consider a police report if work was never started.
  • Consider a DTPA claim (2-year limit) or contract claim. Talk to an attorney.

Both states: before hiring a new roofer to finish, document the exact state of the job with photos and a written inspection, and send the original contractor written notice that you are terminating for abandonment. See also if a storm roofer took your insurance check.

Can I hire another roofer to fix the first roofer's mistakes?

Yes, eventually, but timing matters if you want to recover the cost.

  • Emergencies first: both states allow necessary emergency repairs. Texas Chapter 27 also lets you have an imminent safety threat cured and recover the cost if the contractor doesn't act after notice.
  • Otherwise, give the statutory chance to inspect and offer. In Texas, if you deny the contractor a reasonable chance to inspect or to repair under an accepted offer, your damages can be limited. In Florida, refusing reasonable destructive testing can bar damages that testing would have avoided.
  • Document before the new roofer touches anything. Your independent inspection report and photos are your evidence after the work is gone.
  • Keep the new contract and invoices separate and itemized by defect, so you can show what each fix cost.

How do I sue a roofer in small claims court?

TexasFlorida
CourtJustice court (small claims cases)County court, under the Florida Small Claims Rules
LimitUp to $20,000, excluding interestUp to $8,000, excluding costs, interest and attorney's fees
Bigger claimsCounty or district courtCounty court handles civil cases up to $50,000 (for cases filed on or after Jan. 1, 2023); circuit court above that

Before you file

  1. Complete the Chapter 27 (Texas) or Chapter 558 (Florida) notice process if your claim is a construction defect. Skipping it can get your case paused (abated in Texas, stayed in Florida).
  2. Get the contractor's exact legal name and registered agent (from the Texas Secretary of State or Florida's Division of Corporations).
  3. Decide what you are asking for: the cost to fix (with an independent estimate), refund of payments for work not done, and damaged property.

At the hearing

  • Bring the contract, payment proof, photos, the inspection report, repair estimates and your correspondence, with copies for the judge and the other side.
  • Bring the inspector as a witness, or a signed report if the court allows it.
  • Keep it to a clear timeline: what you agreed, what you paid, what went wrong, what you asked, what they did, what it costs to fix.

Winning a judgment and collecting it are different steps. In Florida, if the contractor was licensed and the case involves qualifying violations, a judgment you cannot collect may be the first step toward the Recovery Fund.

How do I file a complaint against a roofer?

  • Florida, licensed contractor: DBPR's 'File a Complaint' portal or 850-487-1395. The board can discipline for abandonment, financial mismanagement (for example, liens from unpaid suppliers not removed within 75 days after you paid), and false payment statements, and can order restitution.
  • Florida, unlicensed person: DBPR Unlicensed Activity program.
  • Florida, insurance fraud: DFS Criminal Investigations Division, 1-800-378-0445.
  • Texas: Texas Attorney General consumer complaint (deceptive practices, not receiving what you paid for, scams). Complaints are public, and the AG cannot act as your lawyer. For insurance fraud, TDI's fraud report.
  • Code issues (both states): your city or county building department.

Agency complaints can lead to discipline and sometimes restitution, but they don't replace your own claim. Keep your statutory deadlines running in parallel.

Can I get money from the Florida Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund?

Possibly, if your roofer was licensed. The fund is a last resort for losses caused by specified violations: financial mismanagement, abandonment, false statements about payment or bonding, and violations of s. 713.35. For Division I contracts (including roofing) signed on or after July 1, 2024, it can pay up to $100,000 per claim.

The usual path: get a court judgment, arbitration award or licensing-board restitution order that names your actual damages; try to collect (for example, a writ of execution that returns no assets); exhaust any bond, insurance or warranty; then file with the Construction Industry Licensing Board within 1 year after the action ends. You can't claim if the contractor was unlicensed when you signed the contract.

See Florida license lookup and Recovery Fund details.

Documentation that wins roofing disputes

  • Before the job: photos of the old roof, attic, ceilings, driveway and landscaping.
  • The paper trail: estimate, contract, change orders, invoices, receipts, canceled checks, warranty documents, permit number.
  • During the job: photos of tear-off, deck condition, underlayment, flashing and nailing. These are impossible to get later.
  • Problems: dated photos and video of leaks, stains, and roof defects; weather on the day of leaks.
  • Communications: save texts and emails; follow up phone calls with an email summary.
  • Independent inspection report that cites the manufacturer's installation instructions, the building code, or the contract for each defect.
  • Repair estimates from two other roofers, itemized by defect.

How to choose a provider

  • Tarp or make emergency repairs if water is coming in, and keep receipts.
  • Photograph and video all defects, with dates.
  • Gather the contract, change orders, invoices and payment records.
  • Check the permit and final inspection status with your building department.
  • Get an independent inspection report.
  • Send a written demand to the roofer with a deadline.
  • File a manufacturer warranty claim for material defects.
  • Texas: send the Chapter 27 notice by certified mail at least 60 days before suing.
  • Florida: serve the Chapter 558 notice at least 60 days before suing.
  • Respond to any settlement offer in writing within the deadline (25 days TX, 45 days FL).
  • File a DBPR complaint (Florida) or AG complaint (Texas).
  • Withhold payment only with a documented, proportionate reason, and in writing.
  • Pick the right court: TX justice court up to $20,000; FL small claims up to $8,000.

Related roofing guides

Roofing by state and city

Questions people ask

What is the Texas RCLA 60-day notice?

Under Texas Property Code Chapter 27, before suing a residential contractor over a construction defect you must send written notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, at least 60 days before filing. Describe the defects and share your evidence. The contractor can inspect within 35 days and make a settlement offer within 60 days. Rejecting a reasonable offer can cap your recovery.

What is Florida's Chapter 558 construction defect notice?

It is a written notice of claim you must serve on the contractor at least 60 days before filing a construction defect lawsuit (120 days for large associations). It must refer to Chapter 558 and describe each defect and its location. The contractor can inspect within 30 days and must respond within 45 days with an offer to repair, pay, both, or a denial.

How much can I sue for in small claims court?

In Texas, justice courts hear civil cases up to $20,000, excluding interest. In Florida, the Small Claims Rules apply to county court cases up to $8,000, excluding costs, interest and attorney's fees. Larger Florida claims up to $50,000 go to county court under regular procedures, and above that to circuit court.

Can I withhold final payment for a bad roof job?

You can withhold a reasonable amount tied to documented defects, but it can lead the contractor to file a lien. In Texas, you must keep 10% retainage for 30 days after completion anyway. In Florida, a contractor can record a lien up to 90 days after its last work. Put your reason and the amount in writing and consider talking to a lawyer first.

My roofer won't come back to fix leaks. What now?

Send a written demand under the workmanship warranty with photos and a deadline, by certified mail and email. Protect the house with a tarp if needed. Check whether a manufacturer warranty covers workmanship. If the roofer still won't act, send the Chapter 27 (Texas) or Chapter 558 (Florida) notice and consider an agency complaint and a claim.

How long do I have to sue a roofer?

It depends on the claim. In Florida, actions founded on construction of an improvement generally must be brought within 4 years of completion, with a 7-year outer limit for latent defects. In Texas, DTPA claims generally have 2 years, and contract claims have their own period. Chapter 27 does not extend deadlines. Ask an attorney early.

Does Texas Chapter 27 apply if the roofer abandoned the job?

No. Chapter 27 says it does not apply to damages arising from a contractor's wrongful abandonment of a project before completion. You can pursue other remedies, such as a contract or DTPA claim, and file a complaint with the Texas Attorney General. Document the state of the job before anyone else works on it.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration