Local Guide · Roofing
ACV vs RCV Roof Coverage in Texas: How Do Depreciation, Roof Schedules and Cosmetic Exclusions Work?
Two Texas homes with the same hail damage can get very different checks. Here is how replacement cost, actual cash value, roof payment schedules, cosmetic exclusions and percentage deductibles change what you're paid, with worked math.
In Texas, replacement cost value (RCV) pays to replace a damaged roof at today's prices, minus your deductible, usually in two checks. Actual cash value (ACV) subtracts depreciation for age and wear first. TDI's example: a $10,000 roof with a $2,000 deductible pays $8,000 under RCV but $5,000 under ACV. Roof payment schedules, cosmetic hail exclusions and 1% to 5% wind and hail deductibles can cut payments further.
Key facts
- TDI example: a $10,000 roof replacement with a $2,000 deductible pays $8,000 under replacement cost and about $5,000 under actual cash value (TDI Home insurance guide).
- On replacement cost roof claims, most Texas insurers pay in two checks and hold back depreciation until repairs are done (TDI).
- Texas Insurance Code 707.004 lets an insurer withhold recoverable depreciation until you show proof you paid your deductible.
- Texas created the optional HO-145 cosmetic hail exclusion in 1998, tied to impact-resistant roof credits and void unless signed by the insured (TDI Bulletin B-0030-8).
- TDI says impact-resistant roof discounts are set company by company; TWIA requires UL 2218 labeled products and TDI Form PC068.
- The Texas FAIR Plan eliminated its 1% wind and hail deductible effective July 1, 2026; existing 1% policies move to 2% at renewal.
- Most insurers require insuring your home for at least 80% of replacement cost; some require 100% (TDI).
- TDI and OPIC run HelpInsure.com for comparing Texas home policies; OPIC's line is 1-877-611-6742.
ACV vs RCV: what is the difference for a roof?
Your homeowners policy pays for a damaged roof in one of two ways. Replacement cost value (RCV) pays what it costs to repair or replace the roof at today's prices. Actual cash value (ACV) pays replacement cost minus depreciation, which is the value the roof has lost to age and wear. The Texas Department of Insurance (TDI) puts it simply: replacement cost pays to fix the roof at current prices, and actual cash value pays less if the roof is older or showing wear.
The difference matters most after a hailstorm, because roof claims are big claims. Two neighbors with the same storm, the same roof and the same deductible can end up thousands of dollars apart, only because one has RCV on the roof and the other has ACV.
TDI's own worked example
TDI's home insurance guide uses a 10-year-old roof that would cost $10,000 to replace, with a $2,000 deductible:
| Line | Replacement cost policy | Actual cash value policy |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of a new roof today | $10,000 | $10,000 |
| Value the policy uses | $10,000 (full replacement) | $7,000 (after depreciation) |
| Deductible | $2,000 | $2,000 |
| Insurer pays | $8,000 | $5,000 |
| You pay out of pocket | $2,000 | $5,000 |
Same storm, same roof. The ACV owner pays $3,000 more. On a larger Texas roof the gap grows. The 2025 Cost vs. Value report (Zonda/JLC) priced a full asphalt shingle roof replacement at $27,519 in Houston, $28,211 in Dallas and $22,966 in San Antonio. Those are benchmark jobs on a large roof, not a quote for your house, but they show how big the numbers get.
How RCV is actually paid: two checks
RCV does not mean you get the full amount up front. TDI explains that most companies pay a replacement cost claim in two checks. The first check is the estimated repair cost minus depreciation and your deductible. The insurer holds back the depreciation (often called "recoverable depreciation" or the "holdback") and pays it after it gets the bill for the finished job. You usually must finish repairs within a set time, so ask your adjuster for that deadline in writing.
Texas adds one more condition. Under Texas Insurance Code section 707.004, an insurer with replacement cost coverage may refuse to release the withheld depreciation until it gets reasonable proof you paid your deductible, such as a canceled check, a money order receipt or a credit card statement. Keep that proof. See our guide to Texas deductible and contract laws for why a roofer can't "cover" it for you.
How does depreciation work on a roof claim?
Depreciation is the adjuster's estimate of how much of the roof's useful life is used up. There is no single Texas formula in the statutes. Each insurer and adjuster uses its own method, usually based on the roof's age, its material, its condition and the expected life of that material. That is why two adjusters can come up with different numbers for the same roof.
How much depreciation on a 15-year-old roof?
No law sets the answer, so be wary of anyone who quotes you a fixed percentage. As an illustration only: if an adjuster treats a shingle roof as having a 25-year life and uses a straight-line method, a 15-year-old roof would be about 60% depreciated (15 of 25 years used). On a $20,000 replacement, that is $12,000 of depreciation. Under an ACV settlement with a 2% deductible on a $300,000 home ($6,000), the check would be $20,000 minus $12,000 minus $6,000, or $2,000. Under RCV, you would eventually collect $14,000 ($20,000 minus the $6,000 deductible), once the work is done and paid for.
Life expectancy figures vary by source. A table that the USDA Forest Service attributes to the National Roofing Contractors Association (NRCA) lists asphalt shingles at 15 to 30 years, tile at about 50 years and sheet metal at 20 to 50+ years. Texas heat and hail can shorten those ranges, which adjusters may weigh when they judge condition.
Questions to ask about the depreciation line
- What age did you use for my roof, and where did that age come from?
- What total life did you assume for this material?
- Is the depreciation recoverable (paid back after repairs) or non-recoverable?
- Did you depreciate labor, or only materials? Ask the adjuster to explain the method in writing.
- What is my deadline to finish repairs and claim the holdback?
If you have records showing the roof is younger than the adjuster assumed (a permit, an invoice, a TDI Form PC068 for an impact-resistant roof), send them. A wrong install date is one of the easiest errors to fix.
What is a roof payment schedule endorsement?
A roof payment schedule (insurers use names like "roof surface payment schedule" or "roof surfacing endorsement") is an add-on that changes how the roof is paid. Instead of RCV or a case-by-case ACV, the insurer pays a percentage of the roof's replacement cost based on the roof's age and material, using a table printed in the endorsement. The older the roof, the lower the percentage.
Trade publications have tracked these forms for years. Adjusters International's Adjusting Today described endorsements filed by national rating organizations that pay roof damage from wind or hail on an actual cash value basis, and one carrier endorsement that switched wind and hail roof losses to ACV once the roof passed 15 years old. TDI warns that as roofs age, some companies switch roof coverage to actual cash value at renewal.
How to read a schedule
- Find the endorsement number on your declarations page, then find that form in your policy packet.
- Look for the table. It usually has rows for roof age and columns for roof type (for example, asphalt shingle vs. metal or tile).
- Find your roof's current age. Check whether age is counted from the install date or from the policy's records, and whether it updates each year.
- Multiply the replacement cost by the percentage, then subtract your deductible. That is roughly your best case.
- Check whether the schedule applies only to wind and hail, or to every cause of loss.
Example (hypothetical numbers): if your schedule pays 50% for a 14-year-old shingle roof, and a new roof costs $22,000, the schedule amount is $11,000. Subtract a $5,000 deductible and the payment is $6,000. Your actual schedule may be very different, which is why reading the table before storm season matters.
What is a cosmetic damage exclusion and should I accept it?
A cosmetic damage exclusion says the insurer won't pay for hail damage that changes how the roof looks but doesn't stop it from working. Dents in metal panels are the classic example. The roof still sheds water, so the claim is denied, even though the dents are permanent.
The Texas lineage: Endorsement HO-145 (1998)
Texas regulators created this idea on purpose. In 1998, under Commissioner's Order No. 98-0390, TDI adopted optional Endorsement HO-145, Exclusion of Cosmetic Damage to Roof Coverings Caused by Hail, for Texas homeowners forms, and TDP-022 for Texas dwelling forms. The rules TDI published then said:
- HO-145 could be attached only to a policy on a home receiving a premium credit for an impact-resistant roof.
- It defined cosmetic damage as damage that alters the roof's appearance but does not let water through or cause the roof to fail at keeping out the elements over time.
- It was void unless signed by the insured.
- If the homeowner declined to sign, the insurer could issue the policy without the roof credit.
- The insurer had to tell consumers that cosmetic loss might be excluded if a damaged roof is replaced with a hail-resistant covering.
Today's carrier versions are broader
That 1998 bargain (a discount in exchange for giving up cosmetic coverage) is not the only version you'll see now. Rating organizations and individual insurers have filed their own cosmetic exclusions, and Adjusters International reported that some apply to roofs, siding, doors and windows. TDI's 2026 guidance on metal roofs warns that a metal-roof discount "might come with conditions like an exclusion for cosmetic damage," and that a company can add new exclusions at renewal. Courts have generally enforced these exclusions as written, so the exact wording in your policy controls.
Should you accept it?
| Accept the exclusion if... | Push back or shop if... |
|---|---|
| You have a metal or Class 4 roof and care more about leaks than looks | You plan to sell soon and dents would hurt curb appeal or the inspection report |
| The premium credit is meaningful compared with the coverage you give up | The exclusion comes with no credit at all |
| Your HOA doesn't require repair of cosmetic dents | Your HOA can require you to replace a dented roof at your cost |
Can I buy back cosmetic coverage?
Sometimes. Under the original HO-145 rules, the homeowner could refuse to sign and keep cosmetic coverage by giving up the roof credit. Today it depends on the insurer's filed forms. Ask your agent three questions in writing: Is a cosmetic exclusion on my policy now? Is there an option to remove it, and what would that cost? Will it be added at renewal? If one company won't offer the option, another may, which is what comparison shopping on HelpInsure.com is for.
Why is my wind/hail deductible 2% of my dwelling coverage?
Many Texas policies have two deductibles: one for wind and hail, and one for "all other perils" like fire or a burst pipe. The wind and hail deductible is often a percentage of your dwelling coverage (Coverage A), not a flat dollar amount. TDI tells consumers to ask whether the wind and hail deductible differs from the other deductible, because a higher storm deductible raises what you pay when hail hits the roof.
How to calculate it
Multiply your dwelling coverage limit (from the declarations page) by the percentage.
| Dwelling coverage | 1% | 2% | 3% | 5% |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $200,000 | $2,000 | $4,000 | $6,000 | $10,000 |
| $300,000 | $3,000 | $6,000 | $9,000 | $15,000 |
| $400,000 | $4,000 | $8,000 | $12,000 | $20,000 |
| $500,000 | $5,000 | $10,000 | $15,000 | $25,000 |
Important: the percentage is based on your coverage limit, not the size of the claim. If your dwelling limit rises at renewal (for example, to keep up with building costs), your dollar deductible rises with it.
Recent changes to watch
- Texas FAIR Plan: effective July 1, 2026, the FAIR Plan (the insurer of last resort for many inland homes) eliminated its 1% wind and hail deductible on homeowners policies. Existing 1% policies change to 2% at renewal. Wind and hail options are now 2%, 3%, 4% and 5%, with separate all-other-perils options of 1% to 5%.
- TWIA (coast): TDI's 2026 TWIA overview lists residential deductible options of $100, $250 or 1%, with optional larger deductibles of 1.5% up to 5% in exchange for premium credits.
Rule of thumb: if your roof is older and your deductible is 2% or more, small and medium hail claims may come out to little or nothing after the deductible and depreciation. Run the math before you file. Our guide to hail damage in Texas walks through when a claim is worth filing.
Is replacement cost coverage worth it in Texas?
For most Texas homeowners with a roof less than about halfway through its life, RCV on the roof is worth asking for and paying for, because Texas roofs get hit often. NOAA's billion-dollar disaster database counted 126 severe storm events (the category that includes hail) costing at least $1 billion each in Texas from 1980 through 2024, and the Insurance Information Institute, citing NOAA data, reported Texas led the nation with 902 major hail events in 2025. TDI's own advice is blunt: to be fully protected, make sure your policy has replacement cost coverage.
The trade-off is premium. RCV roof coverage costs more, and on an older roof some insurers won't offer it at all. Compare these three situations:
| Situation | What usually makes sense |
|---|---|
| Roof under 10 years old, standard shingles, inland Texas | Ask for RCV on the roof. The holdback can be large, and you get it back after repairs. |
| Roof 15+ years old, insurer offers only ACV or a payment schedule | Price the difference. Budget for a large out-of-pocket share, or plan a replacement and then re-shop for RCV. |
| New Class 4 or metal roof | Ask for RCV and the impact-resistant credit, and read the cosmetic exclusion terms before signing. |
Also check your insurance-to-value. TDI notes that most companies require you to insure your house for at least 80% of its replacement cost, and some require 100%. Being underinsured can shrink a roof payment even with RCV.
Does a Class 4 roof lower my Texas insurance premium?
It can, but the amount is up to each insurer. Here is how the rules developed and where they stand in late 2026:
- 1998: TDI adopted mandatory premium credits for residential roof coverings meeting UL 2218 (the hail impact test) in the Texas Personal Lines Manual, effective February 17, 1998. The credit had to be shown on the declarations page as "Mandatory Roof Covering Credit - Class ___." Metal roofs were added by a later 1998 order.
- Today: TDI's current page on impact-resistant roofing credits says the amount of discount for each class "is established by the insurance company on a company-by-company basis," and each company decides which tests, labels and paperwork it accepts. We did not find a current statute that sets a required discount amount, so treat any fixed percentage you hear as marketing until your insurer confirms it.
- September 2026: TDI Commissioner's Bulletin B-0008-26 encouraged (it did not require) insurers to offer "meaningful, actuarially supported" discounts for loss mitigation, naming impact-resistant roofing and IBHS FORTIFIED Home. TDI also recommended that the Legislature require insurers to consider these upgrades in rates.
How to get the credit
- Before you buy, ask your agent what credit (in dollars) your company gives for UL 2218 Class 4, and whether a cosmetic exclusion comes with it.
- Make sure every shingle or panel is labeled with the UL (or other TDI-approved lab) mark and impact class. TWIA will not give its credit for unlabeled products, even if they meet the standard.
- Have your roofer complete TDI Form PC068, the Impact-Resistant Roofing Installation Form. TWIA requires it; private insurers may accept it or use their own form.
- Send the form to your agent and check your next declarations page for the credit.
For the full material comparison, see our guide to the best roofing material for Texas.
Can my insurer switch my roof to ACV at renewal?
Yes, insurers can change coverage terms at renewal, and TDI specifically warns that as roofs age, some companies switch roof coverage to actual cash value. TDI says your company should tell you when it changes your coverage. A renewal is essentially a new contract, so read the renewal packet, not just the bill.
Texas law does give you some notice protections. According to TDI, a company must give you 60 days' notice of a nonrenewal if you bought or renewed your policy in 2024 or later, and must tell you the reason if you ask. TDI also says that instead of nonrenewing for bad condition, a company might require repairs, and companies usually give at least six months to make them.
Red flags in a renewal packet
- A new endorsement number you don't recognize next to "roof," "wind/hail" or "cosmetic"
- The phrase "actual cash value" or "payment schedule" applied to roof surfacing
- A wind and hail deductible that changed from a dollar amount to a percentage, or went up a percentage point
- A lower premium that seems too good, which can mean less coverage
If you see any of these, call your agent before the renewal date. You can also compare policies side by side with the OPIC policy comparison tool and rates on HelpInsure.com, which TDI and the Office of Public Insurance Counsel (OPIC) run together.
What should I check on my declarations page before storm season?
The declarations page (the "dec page") is the first page of your policy. TDI describes it as a summary of your coverages, dollar limits and deductibles. Spend ten minutes with it each spring, before hail season peaks.
| Item | What to look for | Why it matters for the roof |
|---|---|---|
| Dwelling coverage (Coverage A) | Does it reflect today's rebuild cost? | Percentage deductibles are based on this number, and underinsurance can cut payments. |
| Wind/hail deductible | Dollar amount or percentage? Convert it to dollars. | This is your first cost on any hail claim. |
| All other perils deductible | Different from wind/hail? | Applies to non-storm roof losses like a fallen tree in calm weather. |
| Loss settlement | Replacement cost, ACV or schedule for the roof? | Decides whether you get depreciation back. |
| Endorsement list | Look for roof, cosmetic or wind/hail exclusion forms (HO-145 or carrier forms). | These change what the policy pays. |
| Roof credit | Impact-resistant or roof credit listed? | If you have a Class 4 roof and no credit, ask why. |
| Wind exclusion (coast) | Is wind and hail excluded because you need TWIA? | Without a TWIA policy, a coastal roof may have no wind coverage. |
Then save a copy of the dec page, your full policy and photos of your roof to a cloud folder. After a storm, those documents and dated photos are your proof.
Is roof coverage different on a TWIA policy?
Yes. On the Texas coast, many homeowners policies exclude wind and hail. TDI explains that if you live on the coast or in Harris County on Galveston Bay, your home policy might not cover wind and hail damage, and the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association (TWIA) sells that coverage. A typical coastal setup is three policies: a homeowners policy (fire, theft, liability), a TWIA policy (wind and hail) and a flood policy.
- Eligibility: most homes need a windstorm certificate of compliance (WPI-8 or WPI-8-E) for roof work. See our TWIA and WPI-8 guide.
- Claim deadline: you must file a TWIA claim within one year of the date of damage (Texas Insurance Code section 2210.573).
- Disputes: TWIA has its own process. You can demand appraisal within 60 days of TWIA's coverage notice if you dispute the amount. Chapter 542A's presuit rules do not apply to TWIA.
- Roof credit: TWIA gives a credit for labeled UL 2218 roofing documented on Form PC068.
- Buy early: TDI notes TWIA won't sell you a policy while a hurricane is in the Gulf of Mexico.
Read your TWIA policy's loss settlement terms the same way you'd read a homeowners policy: look for how the roof is valued, your deductible, and any endorsements. TWIA's claims line is 800-788-8247.
When to get help, and from whom
This guide is general information, not legal advice. These official contacts can help with a specific policy:
- TDI Help Line: 800-252-3439 for questions and complaints about your insurer or agent. Complaints must be in writing (TDI's online portal works).
- OPIC (Office of Public Insurance Counsel): 1-877-611-6742. OPIC answers policy questions and runs consumer tools, but it cannot represent you individually or take complaints.
- HelpInsure.com: TDI and OPIC's site for comparing home policies and rates.
- A licensed public adjuster: works for you on a claim. In Texas, their fee can't exceed 10% of the settlement. Check the license with TDI.
- An attorney: if the claim is denied or underpaid and the gap is large. Texas has strict presuit notice rules; see Chapter 542A and hail lawsuits.
How to choose a provider
- Find your declarations page and write down your dwelling limit, both deductibles in dollars, and your roof loss settlement type.
- List every endorsement number and read any form that mentions roof, cosmetic, wind or hail.
- If you have a payment schedule, find your roof's percentage for this year and next.
- Gather proof of your roof's age: permit, invoice, PC068 form or closing documents.
- Ask your agent in writing whether a cosmetic exclusion applies and whether it can be removed.
- If your roof is impact-resistant, confirm the credit appears on your declarations page.
- Compare at least two other policies on HelpInsure.com before your renewal date.
- Save your policy, dec page and dated roof photos in a cloud folder before hail season.
- After a claim, keep proof you paid your deductible so the depreciation holdback can be released.
Related roofing guides
- Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Roof Replacement? The Plain-English Answer for Texas and Florida
- Hail Damage on Your Roof: How to Spot It, Prove It, and Claim It in Texas
- Roof Insurance Claim Step by Step: From First Call to Final Check
- Roof Claim Denied or Lowballed: Appeals, Appraisal, Public Adjusters, and Lawsuits
- What Is the Best Roofing Material for Texas Hail, Heat and Hurricanes?
- Can You Sue Your Insurer Over a Texas Hail Claim? Chapter 542A, Appraisal and Deadlines Explained
- Do You Need a WPI-8 Windstorm Certificate to Replace a Roof on the Texas Coast?
Roofing by state and city
Questions people ask
What is the difference between ACV and RCV for a roof?
RCV (replacement cost value) pays what it costs to replace your roof at today's prices, minus your deductible. ACV (actual cash value) subtracts depreciation for age and wear first. In TDI's example, a $10,000 roof with a $2,000 deductible pays $8,000 under RCV, but only $5,000 under ACV if the old roof is valued at $7,000. Under RCV, insurers usually hold back the depreciation until the work is done.
What is a roof payment schedule endorsement?
It is a policy add-on that pays a set percentage of the roof's replacement cost based on the roof's age and material, using a table in the endorsement. A newer roof gets a higher percentage, an older one gets less. Find the endorsement number on your declarations page, read the table, and multiply your replacement cost by your roof's percentage, then subtract the deductible to estimate a payment.
How much depreciation will insurance take on a 15-year-old roof?
There is no fixed Texas percentage. Each insurer uses its own method based on age, material, condition and expected life. As an illustration, if an adjuster assumed a 25-year life with straight-line depreciation, a 15-year-old roof would be about 60% depreciated. Ask the adjuster in writing what age and life expectancy were used, and send proof if your roof is younger than they assumed.
Is replacement cost coverage worth it in Texas?
For most owners of roofs that are less than halfway through their life, yes. Texas has more major hail than any other state, and RCV lets you recover held-back depreciation after repairs. TDI advises that to be fully protected you should have replacement cost coverage. On older roofs, RCV may cost more or not be offered, so compare quotes on HelpInsure.com.
Can I buy back cosmetic damage coverage?
Sometimes. When Texas created the HO-145 cosmetic exclusion in 1998, homeowners could decline to sign it and keep cosmetic coverage by giving up the impact-resistant roof credit. Today it depends on each insurer's filed forms. Ask your agent in writing whether you can remove the exclusion, what it would cost, and whether it will be added at renewal.
How do I calculate my wind and hail deductible?
Multiply your dwelling coverage limit (Coverage A on the declarations page) by the deductible percentage. A 2% deductible on a $300,000 dwelling limit is $6,000. The percentage is based on your coverage limit, not the size of the claim, so if your dwelling limit goes up at renewal, your dollar deductible goes up too.
Can my insurer switch my roof to actual cash value at renewal?
Yes. TDI warns that as roofs age, some companies switch roof coverage to actual cash value at renewal, and your company should tell you when coverage changes. Read every renewal packet for new roof, cosmetic or wind and hail endorsements. If you don't like the change, shop other companies before the renewal date.
Does a Class 4 roof guarantee a discount in Texas?
No fixed discount is guaranteed. TDI says each insurer sets its own impact-resistant roofing credit and decides what proof it accepts. TDI's September 2026 bulletin encouraged insurers to offer meaningful mitigation discounts but did not require a specific amount. Get the dollar credit from your agent before you buy, and have your roofer complete TDI Form PC068.
Sources
- TDI: Home insurance guide (cb025)
- TDI: Insurance and your roof
- TDI: Metal roofs and home insurance: 4 key facts
- TDI: Products qualifying for impact-resistant roofing credits
- TDI Form PC068: Impact-Resistant Roofing Installation Form
- TDI Bulletin B-0024-8 (1998): mandatory roof covering credits
- TDI Bulletin B-0030-8 (1998): Endorsement HO-145 cosmetic exclusion
- TDI Commissioner's Bulletin B-0008-26 (2026): loss mitigation discounts
- Tex. Ins. Code ch. 707 (deductible payment and proof)
- Tex. Ins. Code ch. 2210 (TWIA)
- Texas FAIR Plan: Deductible changes effective July 1, 2026
- TDI: TWIA Overview (Oct. 1, 2026)
- Office of Public Insurance Counsel
- HelpInsure.com (TDI and OPIC)
- Adjusters International: Cosmetic Damage Exclusion Stirs Controversy
- USDA Forest Service: Typical life expectancy of building components (NRCA)
- Zonda/JLC Cost vs. Value 2025: Houston
- Zonda/JLC Cost vs. Value 2025: Dallas
- Zonda/JLC Cost vs. Value 2025: San Antonio
- NOAA NCEI: Billion-Dollar Disasters, Texas summary
- Insurance Information Institute: Facts + Statistics: Hail
- TDI: Storm recovery tips
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


