Local Guide · Roofing
Hail Damage on Your Roof: How to Spot It, Prove It, and Claim It in Texas
Texas leads the country in large-hail events. This neutral guide shows how to tell hail bruises from blisters and foot traffic, how adjusters use test squares, what a cosmetic damage exclusion does, how wind and hail deductibles and Texas claim deadlines work, and how to prove the storm date for your address.
Hail damage on asphalt shingles usually shows as random dark spots where granules were knocked off, with a soft, bruised feel and sometimes a cracked mat underneath. Matching dents on gutters, vents and AC fins help prove it. In Texas, report it promptly, since many policies have one-year deadlines, and check your wind and hail deductible and any cosmetic damage exclusion. Insurers must acknowledge your claim within 15 days, and weather-claim lawsuits need 61 days' notice.
Key facts
- Texas had 902 major hail events (hail 1 inch or larger) in 2025, more than any other state and ahead of Kansas (375) and Oklahoma (369), per NOAA Storm Prediction Center data reported by Triple-I.
- NOAA confirmed a Texas record hailstone of 7.1 inches in diameter near Vigo Park in Swisher County on June 2, 2024.
- NCEI lists a May 27-28, 2024 hail event with golf-ball to softball-size hail across north and east Texas, including Dallas and Houston, at about $2.3 billion (CPI-adjusted).
- TDI's Endorsement HO-145 (1998) excludes cosmetic hail damage to roof coverings and may be attached only to policies receiving an impact-resistant roof credit; hail damage that lets water in or stops the roof from working remains covered.
- UL 2218 Class 4, the highest impact rating, uses a 2-inch steel ball; top-surface marks such as granule loss are not failures, while cracks visible on the back are (IBHS).
- In Texas, each insurer sets its own impact-resistant roof discount and criteria, and TDI does not endorse any roofing material (TDI).
- TWIA's impact-resistant roof credit requires a UL 2218 rating and a product label showing the impact class; contractors certify installs on TDI Form PC068.
- Texas insurers must acknowledge a claim within 15 days, decide within 15 business days after receiving all requested items, and pay within 5 business days of accepting (Tex. Ins. Code Ch. 542).
- Weather-claim lawsuits in Texas require written presuit notice at least 61 days before filing (Tex. Ins. Code Ch. 542A, from HB 1774, 2017).
- State Farm paid more than $5.6 billion in hail claims in 2025, with Texas its top state for hail claims (Triple-I).
Why hail is Texas's roof problem
Texas sees more large hail than anywhere else in the country. Triple-I, citing NOAA Storm Prediction Center data, counted 902 major hail events (hail 1 inch or larger) in Texas in 2025, more than twice as many as the next state. NOAA's billion-dollar disaster records show 126 severe-storm events in Texas from 1980 to 2024, the category that includes hail, out of 190 billion-dollar disasters. In 2024 alone, a May 27-28 storm dropped golf-ball to softball-size hail across north and east Texas, including Dallas and Houston, and a hailstone found near Vigo Park in the Panhandle set a new state record at 7.1 inches.
The result: hail claims are routine in Dallas-Fort Worth, Austin, San Antonio and the Panhandle, and disputes over whether a roof is "hail damaged" are just as routine. This page gives you the tools to judge your own roof, prove the storm, and work through the claim. For the full claim walk-through see roof insurance claim step by step.
What does hail damage look like on a shingle roof?
On asphalt shingles, fresh hail damage typically looks like:
- Random dark spots where granules were knocked off, exposing black asphalt. They're scattered, not in lines or patterns.
- A soft or spongy feel when pressed, like a bruise on an apple. This is called a hail bruise.
- Fractured mat: the fiberglass mat inside the shingle cracked under the impact. IBHS's lab testing defines failure as a crack or tear visible on the back of the shingle; granule loss on top alone isn't counted as failure in the UL 2218 test.
- Broken or cracked edges and torn shingle tabs from large stones.
- Shiny or exposed asphalt that looks fresh, not weathered gray.
Hail bruise vs. blister vs. mechanical damage
| Mark | Typical look | Usual cause | Clues |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hail bruise | Round or irregular spot, granules crushed or missing, soft to the touch, sometimes a cracked mat | Hail impact | Random spacing, on slopes facing the storm; matching dents on soft metals |
| Blister or pop | Small raised bubble, or a crater with sharp edges where the bubble popped and exposed asphalt | Trapped moisture or volatiles in the shingle, heat, poor ventilation | Often clustered on sun-facing slopes, edges sharp, no matching metal dents |
| Mechanical or foot traffic | Scuffs, crescent marks, scrapes, tool marks | People walking, ladders, tools, debris | Concentrated near access points, ridges and valleys; directional scuffing |
| Normal weathering | Even, gradual granule loss across the roof, curling, cracking | Sun and age | Uniform, worse on south and west slopes, granules in gutters over time |
| Manufacturing issues | Pattern defects, cracking or granule loss across a batch | Product | Repeating pattern; a warranty claim may be the path |
Take close photos with a coin or ruler for scale, and mark each hit with chalk if a roofer is inspecting. If the adjuster says "blistering" or "manufacturing defect, not hail," ask for photos of the specific marks and the reasoning. See claim denied or lowballed.
Is granule loss hail damage or normal wear?
It can be either. The difference is in the pattern:
- Hail granule loss is in spots: distinct, randomly spaced impact marks, often with crushed granules at the center and a matching story on soft metals.
- Weathering granule loss is spread out: the whole roof gets thinner and grayer over years, with a gradual buildup of granules in gutters.
Lots of granules in your gutters right after a storm, along with fresh spots on the shingles, supports hail. A uniformly worn roof with granules in the gutters every year points to age. Adjusters will look at both, which is why "before" photos of your roof are so valuable.
What size hail damages a roof?
There's no single size that always damages roofs. It depends on hailstone size and density, wind speed (wind-driven hail hits harder), roof material, age, and temperature. A few anchor points:
- NOAA's Storm Prediction Center data counts hail of 1 inch or larger as a "major" hail event (Triple-I).
- The UL 2218 impact test that rates shingles drops steel balls of 1.25 inches (Class 1), 1.5 inches (Class 2), 1.75 inches (Class 3) and 2 inches (Class 4), per IBHS. A Class 4 rating means the product survived the 2-inch test without cracking through.
- IBHS testing found real-world impact resistance varies: in its tests, no product passed more than Class 2 impacts without at least one failing double-impact spot. Rated shingles still did better than unrated ones.
Older, brittle shingles are damaged by smaller hail than new ones. Hail that "only" dented gutters can still have bruised shingles. Don't rule out damage based on the size you remember; inspect.
How do I check for hail damage without going on the roof?
Start with collateral damage, the dents and marks on softer things around your house. Adjusters use them to judge hail size and direction.
- Gutters and downspouts: round dents along the top edge and face.
- Roof vents, turtle vents, ridge vents, flashing: visible from the ground with binoculars or a zoom photo.
- AC condenser fins: rows of bent fins on the top or storm side.
- Window screens and frames: tears or dents.
- Siding, fence stain, painted wood: spatter marks where hail knocked off oxidation or paint.
- Cars, mailbox, patio furniture, outdoor lights.
- Granules washed out of downspouts onto the driveway.
A drone photo of each slope is a safe way to see the roof itself. If you hire a roofer, ask for dated photos of every slope and of the collateral damage.
Does hail damage on gutters and vents mean my roof is damaged?
Not automatically, but it's strong evidence that hail big enough to mark metal hit your property. Metal dents easily; shingles may survive the same hail if they're newer or impact-rated. Insurers usually pay for damaged gutters and vents themselves, even if shingles are fine. If metal is heavily dented, ask for a careful shingle inspection on every slope facing the storm.
Test squares and hits per square: how adjusters decide
Many adjusters and inspectors use test squares: they mark a 10-by-10-foot area (one roofing "square," 100 square feet) on each slope and count hail hits inside it. The count helps decide whether a slope needs repair or replacement.
Here's the key fact for homeowners: the number of hits per square that triggers replacement is an insurer guideline, not Texas law. We found no Texas statute or TDI rule that sets a hit count. Different insurers, and even different adjusters, may use different thresholds or none at all.
Why did the adjuster say there weren't enough hits per square?
That usually means their test squares found fewer hits than their company's guideline. Ask:
- Which slopes were tested, and where were the test squares placed?
- What counted as a hit? Did they include mat fractures that aren't visible from the top?
- Did they test the slopes facing the storm direction?
- What is the guideline, and is it in writing?
- Were damaged ridge caps, vents and flashing included even if field shingles passed?
If your roofer's test squares on the same slopes found more hits, send photos with chalk-marked hits and a measuring tape in frame, and request a re-inspection. A roof with damage on some slopes might get a slope-by-slope repair; ask about matching and whether repairs are possible with available shingles. For coverage of an older roof, see Texas ACV vs. RCV and depreciation.
Does hail damage cause leaks right away?
Sometimes, but often not. Large hail can puncture shingles or crack tile and leak in the next rain. Smaller hail often bruises shingles and cracks the mat without an immediate leak. Over months, the damaged spot loses granules, the asphalt weathers, and water eventually finds its way through. That's why "no leaks" doesn't mean "no damage," and why waiting can be risky: a late claim may be harder to prove, and some policies have one-year reporting deadlines (TDI).
Can hail damage a metal roof? The cosmetic damage exclusion
Yes, hail can dent or scratch metal roofs, panels, and trim. TDI's August 2026 consumer post on metal roofs says these marks may not affect performance but can affect appearance, and warns that a metal roof discount may come with an exclusion for cosmetic damage.
What is a cosmetic damage exclusion?
A cosmetic damage exclusion says the policy won't pay for hail damage that only changes how the roof looks. TDI adopted Endorsement HO-145, "Exclusion of Cosmetic Damage to Roof Coverings Caused by Hail," in Bulletin B-0030-98, effective May 2, 1998. Under that form:
- It's optional and may be attached only to policies insuring risks that receive a premium credit for an impact-resistant roof covering.
- "Cosmetic" means damage that alters the physical appearance of the roof covering.
- Hail damage that lets water penetrate the roof or stops it from performing its intended function remains covered.
- It requires the insured's signature (or a signed copy on file).
Insurers today often use their own versions, and wording differs, especially for metal roofs. Texas court decisions have gone both ways depending on the exact language. If you have a cosmetic exclusion, the fight is usually over whether damage is "functional": dents that break coatings and lead to rust, open seams, cracked panels, loosened fasteners, or water entry. Ask for the exclusion's exact text and get a qualified metal roofer's opinion. See the metal roof guide.
Wind and hail deductibles in Texas
Many Texas homeowners policies have a separate wind and hail deductible, often a percentage of your dwelling coverage. TDI advises asking your agent if it differs from the all-other-perils deductible, because it can raise what you pay for storm roof damage. The Texas FAIR Plan, for example, eliminated its 1% wind and hail option on July 1, 2026 (existing 1% policies move to 2% at renewal), and now offers 2% to 5%.
| Dwelling limit | 1% deductible | 2% deductible | 3% deductible |
|---|---|---|---|
| $250,000 | $2,500 | $5,000 | $7,500 |
| $350,000 | $3,500 | $7,000 | $10,500 |
| $500,000 | $5,000 | $10,000 | $15,000 |
You must pay it. Texas Insurance Code Chapter 707 requires the insured to pay the deductible, and Business and Commerce Code 27.02 makes it a Class B misdemeanor for a roofer to waive or rebate it. An insurer can hold back the depreciation payment until you show proof you paid. See Texas deductible and contract laws.
How long after a hail storm can I file a claim in Texas?
Texas has no single statewide reporting deadline for private homeowners policies. It's set by your policy. TDI says many policies have deadlines, some one year unless you show good cause. TWIA, which covers wind and hail on the coast, requires claims within one year of the date of damage. Report as soon as you find damage; late reports give the insurer room to argue the damage came from a different storm.
The Texas claim clock
| Step | Deadline | Law |
|---|---|---|
| Insurer acknowledges, starts investigating, requests items | 15 days after notice (30 business days for surplus lines) | Ins. Code 542.055 |
| Insurer accepts or rejects in writing | 15 business days after receiving all items; up to 45 more days with notice of the reason | Ins. Code 542.056 |
| Insurer pays after accepting | 5 business days (20 for surplus lines) | Ins. Code Ch. 542 |
| After a declared weather catastrophe | Deadlines extended by 15 days | Ins. Code Ch. 542 |
| Before suing on a weather claim | Written notice at least 61 days before filing | Ins. Code Ch. 542A |
| Time to sue | Set by policy, but a contract can't shorten it below 2 years | Civ. Prac. & Rem. Code 16.070 |
Chapter 542A came from HB 1774 (2017). For claims from hail, wind and other forces of nature, it requires presuit notice, lets the insurer inspect within 30 days of the notice, and ties attorney fee awards to how close the judgment comes to your demand. It changed prompt-payment interest on these claims from 18% to the judgment rate plus 5%. It doesn't apply to suits against TWIA. Details in Texas hail claims and Chapter 542A.
How do I find hail reports or hail maps for my address?
Proving the storm date matters when an insurer asks whether damage came from this storm or an older one, or when you're buying a house.
- NOAA NCEI Storm Events Database: the only publicly accessible source of National Weather Service Storm Data, per NCEI's 2025 user guide. You can search by state and county or by map and address, filter to hail, and download results or PDF reports. Records include reported hail size, date and location.
- Your own evidence: dated photos of hailstones (with a coin or ruler), local news reports, neighbors' claims, and weather alerts on your phone.
- Commercial hail-date reports: private weather firms sell address-level hail history reports built from radar. Roofers and adjusters often use them. They can be useful, but they are estimates; ask how the report was made and treat it as one piece of evidence.
Write down the storm date you're claiming and stick to it. If you're not sure, check the records before you call.
Will my insurance go up if I file a hail claim in Texas? Can my insurer drop me?
According to TDI's home insurance guide:
- A company may nonrenew if you file three or more non-weather-related claims in three years. Weather claims, like hail, don't count toward that test.
- A company can raise your rates if you file two or more non-weather claims.
- Your claims history in general can affect your premium. Most companies check the CLUE database, which shows seven years of claims on you and your house. You can get a free copy yearly from LexisNexis at 866-312-8076.
- A company may not refuse to renew because you filed a claim for something your policy doesn't cover.
- A company may still nonrenew if the house is in bad condition, often giving at least six months to make repairs, or if it decides to limit coverage in your area. Since 2024, nonrenewal requires 60 days' notice.
So one hail claim shouldn't by itself trigger a nonrenewal under TDI's frequency rule, but area-wide rate increases after hail-heavy years affect everyone, claim or not. If you're nonrenewed, ask for the reason in writing; TDI says companies must provide it.
Impact-resistant Class 4 shingles and premium credits
If you're replacing a roof after hail, consider an impact-resistant roof. Key facts:
- UL 2218 rates roof coverings Class 1 through 4 using steel balls of 1.25 to 2 inches. FM 4473 is another impact test used for some products (Owens Corning). Class 4 is the highest rating.
- Discounts vary: TDI says each Texas insurer sets its own impact-resistant roofing discount and decides which tests, labels and paperwork it accepts. TDI does not endorse any roofing material. Roofers' "20 to 35% off" claims are not TDI figures; get a quote from your insurer before and after.
- Paperwork: the installer completes TDI Form PC068, certifying the product's UL 2218 class. TWIA requires it, and private insurers may accept it or use their own forms.
- Labels: for TWIA's credit, the product must be labeled with the UL (or other TDI-approved lab) mark and impact class. Unlabeled products don't qualify, even if they meet the standard. Keep a wrapper and the label.
- Trade-off: a discount can come with a cosmetic damage exclusion, as described above.
- Real-world performance: IBHS's tests found Class 4 shingles outperformed basic shingles but still showed failures under repeated impacts. IBHS's FORTIFIED Hail Supplement uses its own shingle ratings, which it says outperform typical Class 4 shingles against realistic hail up to 2 inches.
See best roofing material for Texas. For cost context, the 2025 Cost vs. Value report put an asphalt shingle roof replacement at $28,211 in Dallas and $22,966 in San Antonio (large benchmark roof, full tear-off); see roof replacement costs.
After the hail: a Texas game plan
- Photograph hailstones, collateral dents and each roof slope (from the ground or a drone) the same day.
- Look up the storm in NOAA's Storm Events Database for your county.
- Read your declarations page: wind and hail deductible in dollars, ACV or RCV roof, cosmetic exclusion.
- Get one or two written inspections with test-square photos.
- Report the claim; ask for the adjuster's estimate and the hit-count guideline used.
- Be wary of door-knockers; Texas has no state roofing license, and contractors can't act as your adjuster (Ins. Code 4102.163). See storm chaser scams.
- If you replace, consider Class 4 products and get Form PC068 and the label for your discount.
Questions? TDI's Help Line is 800-252-3439. TWIA claims: 800-788-8247.
How to choose a provider
- Photograph hailstones with a coin or ruler on the day of the storm.
- Check gutters, vents, AC fins, screens and fences for dents and spatter.
- Photograph every roof slope from the ground or by drone.
- Look up the storm in NOAA's Storm Events Database for your county.
- Find your wind and hail deductible in dollars and any cosmetic damage exclusion.
- Report the claim promptly; TWIA requires claims within 1 year.
- Ask the adjuster which slopes were tested and what hit-count guideline was used.
- Compare your roofer's test-square photos with the adjuster's findings.
- Make temporary repairs only, and save receipts.
- Pay your deductible and keep proof of payment.
- If replacing, ask your insurer about impact-resistant discounts before choosing a product.
- Keep Form PC068 and the product label for any Class 4 discount.
Related roofing guides
- ACV vs RCV Roof Coverage in Texas: How Do Depreciation, Roof Schedules and Cosmetic Exclusions Work?
- Can You Sue Your Insurer Over a Texas Hail Claim? Chapter 542A, Appraisal and Deadlines Explained
- What Is the Best Roofing Material for Texas Hail, Heat and Hurricanes?
- What Texas Roofing Laws Should Every Homeowner Know About Deductibles, Contracts and Public Adjusting?
- Storm Chaser Roofing Scams: 15 Red Flags and What to Do If You Already Signed
- Roof Insurance Claim Step by Step: From First Call to Final Check
- Roof Claim Denied or Lowballed: Appeals, Appraisal, Public Adjusters, and Lawsuits
- Metal Roofs: Standing Seam vs Exposed Fastener, Gauges, Coastal Metals, Costs and Myths
Roofing by state and city
Questions people ask
What does hail damage look like on a shingle roof?
Fresh hail damage usually looks like randomly spaced dark spots where granules were knocked off, often soft to the touch like a bruise, sometimes with a cracked mat underneath. It is more common on slopes facing the storm and usually comes with dents on gutters, vents or AC fins. Even, overall granule loss and curling point to age instead.
What size hail damages a roof?
There's no single threshold. NOAA data counts hail 1 inch or larger as a major hail event, and the UL 2218 impact test uses balls from 1.25 to 2 inches. Older, brittle shingles can be damaged by smaller hail, and wind-driven hail hits harder. Inspect after any storm that dented metal around your house.
What is the difference between hail damage and blistering?
Hail damage is an impact mark: random spots with crushed or missing granules and sometimes a fractured mat, usually matched by dents on soft metals. Blisters are bubbles in the shingle that pop and leave small craters with sharp edges, often clustered on sun-facing slopes and caused by heat or trapped moisture. Blisters aren't storm damage.
What is a cosmetic damage exclusion for hail?
It removes coverage for hail damage that only affects how the roof looks. TDI's HO-145 endorsement, effective 1998, applies only to policies receiving an impact-resistant roof credit, and still covers hail damage that lets water in or stops the roof from working. Insurers' own versions vary, especially for metal roofs, so read your exact policy wording.
Why did the adjuster say there were not enough hits per square?
Many insurers use test squares, a 10-by-10-foot area on each slope, and count hail hits against an internal guideline. That number is a company practice, not Texas law. Ask which slopes were tested, what counted as a hit, and for the guideline in writing. If your roofer found more hits, send marked photos and request a re-inspection.
Can an insurer drop me after a hail claim in Texas?
TDI says insurers may nonrenew for three or more non-weather claims in three years, and weather claims like hail don't count toward that. Your overall claims history can still affect your rate, and insurers can nonrenew for a roof in bad condition or if they pull back from an area, with 60 days' notice for policies bought or renewed since 2024.
Can hail damage a metal roof?
Yes. Hail can dent and scratch metal panels and trim. TDI notes those marks may not affect performance but can affect appearance, and many metal roof discounts come with a cosmetic damage exclusion. Damage that breaks coatings, opens seams, loosens fasteners or lets water in is functional and is generally treated differently from appearance-only dents.
How do I find hail reports for my address?
Search NOAA's Storm Events Database, which NCEI says is the only public source of National Weather Service Storm Data. You can search by state and county or by map and address and filter to hail. Add your own dated photos and local news reports. Private hail-history reports based on radar are also sold; treat them as estimates.
Will my insurance go up if I file a hail claim in Texas?
Possibly. Claims history can affect premiums, and insurers check the CLUE database, which covers seven years. But under TDI's rules, hail and other weather claims don't count toward the three non-weather claims that allow a nonrenewal, and rate increases tied to claim frequency apply to non-weather claims. Large regional hail losses can raise rates for everyone.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute: Facts and statistics, hail
- NOAA NCEI: Billion-dollar disasters, Texas summary
- NOAA NCEI: Texas hailstone record (7.1 inches, 2024)
- IBHS: Relative Impact Resistance of Asphalt Shingles (PDF)
- Professional Roofing: shingle wind and impact standards explained
- Owens Corning: Class 4 impact-resistant shingles
- IBHS FORTIFIED Roof standard
- Texas Department of Insurance: Bulletin B-0030-98 (Endorsement HO-145, cosmetic hail exclusion)
- Texas Department of Insurance: Metal roofs and home insurance, 4 key facts (Aug. 2026)
- Texas Department of Insurance: Insurance and your roof
- Texas Department of Insurance: Home insurance guide
- Texas Department of Insurance: Hail damage to your home or car? What to do next
- Texas Department of Insurance: Roofing discounts for impact-resistant roofs
- Texas Department of Insurance: Form PC068, Impact-Resistant Roofing Installation
- Texas FAIR Plan Association: Deductible changes effective July 1, 2026
- Texas Insurance Code Ch. 707 (payment of deductibles)
- Texas Business and Commerce Code Ch. 27 (insurance deductible notice and waivers)
- Texas Insurance Code Ch. 542 (prompt payment of claims)
- Texas Insurance Code Ch. 542A (weather claim lawsuits)
- Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Ch. 16 (limitations, Sec. 16.070)
- Texas Insurance Code Ch. 4102 (public insurance adjusters)
- Texas Windstorm Insurance Association: Claims process
- NOAA NCEI: Storm Events Database User Guide (2025)
- Cost vs. Value 2025: Dallas
- Cost vs. Value 2025: San Antonio
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


