New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Thu, Nov 19, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · AC and heating

How Do You Compare AC Replacement Quotes? A Line-by-Line Checklist for Texas and Florida

Get three bids, then compare them on model numbers, AHRI certificates, load calculations, scope and warranty, not just the bottom line. Includes Texas and Florida license checks, lien notices and cancellation rights.

Get at least three written quotes from licensed contractors. Compare them line by line: outdoor and indoor model numbers, tonnage, SEER2, EER2 and HSPF2, the AHRI certificate number for the matched combination, a Manual J load calculation, and the full scope (line set, pad, disconnect, drain safety, permit, haul-away, startup). Then compare labor warranty years. Verify each license with TDLR in Texas or DBPR in Florida before signing.

Key facts

  • Florida's energy code requires heating and cooling equipment to be sized with ACCA Manual S using a Manual J load calculation, with no safety factors (FBC-Energy R403.7.1).
  • Texas's 2015 IECC-based energy code also requires sizing per ACCA Manual S based on Manual J loads (IECC R403.7), though local enforcement on replacements varies.
  • CPS Energy and JEA rebates require an AHRI certificate matching all installed components.
  • Florida residential improvement contracts over $2,500 must include a notice of rights under the Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund (Fla. Stat. 489.1425).
  • Florida direct contracts over $2,500 for homes of up to four units must include a bold construction lien law warning (Fla. Stat. 713.015).
  • Texas original contractors must give homeowners a 'Know Your Rights and Responsibilities' disclosure before a residential construction contract is signed (Tex. Prop. Code 53.255).
  • Texas and Florida both give a right to cancel certain home-solicited sales until midnight of the third business day after signing (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code 601.051; Fla. Stat. 501.025).
  • A Florida contractor that takes more than a 10% deposit must apply for permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days after permits issue, absent just cause or a written agreement (Fla. Stat. 489.126).

How many AC quotes should I get?

Three is the practical number. One quote gives you nothing to compare. Two can leave you guessing which is the outlier. Three usually shows you a real middle. If the three disagree on size (for example, 3 tons vs 4 tons), get a fourth, or ask each company to show its load calculation.

Ask all three for the same thing in writing: replace the whole system with equipment of a stated efficiency, plus the same scope items. Then add any upgrades as separate options. That way you compare like with like.

Timing helps. In spring or fall, contractors have time for a proper home visit. In a July breakdown, you may get a phone price and a one-day decision. If your system still runs, get quotes before it fails. See our repair-or-replace guide.

The side-by-side comparison table

Copy these rows into a spreadsheet or onto paper. Fill in one column per quote. Any blank is a question for that contractor.

ItemQuote AQuote BQuote C
Company license number (verified)
Outdoor unit brand and model number
Indoor coil or air handler model number
Furnace model (if gas heat)
AHRI certificate number
Tonnage and how it was chosen (Manual J?)
SEER2 / EER2 / HSPF2 (from AHRI)
Single-stage, two-stage or variable-speed
Refrigerant (R-454B, R-32 or R-410A)
Line set: reuse (flush, test) or replace
Pad, disconnect, whip, breaker check
Drain, trap, float switch, secondary pan
Thermostat
Duct work and sealing included
Permit (who pulls, fee included?)
Refrigerant recovery and haul-away
Startup and commissioning readings provided
Manufacturer warranty, and who registers it
Installer labor warranty (years)
Utility rebate, amount, who files
Deposit and payment schedule
Install date and duration
Total price

Our replacement cost guide explains each line and what it typically costs.

Should the contractor do a load calculation?

Yes. A load calculation estimates how much heat your house gains in summer and loses in winter, room by room, based on its insulation, windows, orientation, air leakage and ducts. ACCA Manual J is the standard method. Manual S then picks equipment that matches that load, and Manual D sizes the ducts.

  • Florida: the 2023 Florida Building Code-Energy Conservation requires residential equipment to be sized with Manual S, based on Manual J or another approved method (R403.7.1). It bans safety factors and "future expansion" allowances. Cooling-only equipment must be at least the calculated load but no more than 1.15 times it, or the closest size the maker offers (R403.7.1.1).
  • Texas: the state's residential energy code is based on the 2015 IECC, which requires sizing per Manual S based on Manual J (R403.7). How strictly cities enforce this on replacements varies. Some rebates require it anyway: Austin Energy requires Manual J or its own sizing guidance, and Oncor's program can require a Manual J depending on the unit.

A contractor who looks at your old unit's label and quotes the same size, or adds a ton "to be safe," is guessing. Your old system may have been oversized from day one. Ask: "Will you do a Manual J, and will I get a copy?" See our sizing guide.

What is an AHRI certificate and why does it matter?

AHRI (the Air-Conditioning, Heating, and Refrigeration Institute) runs a certification directory that lists tested combinations of outdoor units, indoor coils and furnaces or air handlers, with their certified SEER2, EER2 and HSPF2 ratings. Each listed combination has a reference number, and you can print a certificate for it from the AHRI Directory (ahridirectory.org).

Why it matters:

  • The rating belongs to the combination. A "17 SEER2" outdoor unit may rate lower with a different coil.
  • Federal rules. An outdoor unit whose certified combination rates below the regional standard cannot be installed in Texas or Florida (10 CFR 430.32(c)(6)).
  • Florida code. Replacements require matched indoor and outdoor units verified by AHRI data or another approved method (FBC-Energy R501.7).
  • Rebates. CPS Energy requires an AHRI certificate matching the condenser, coil and furnace model numbers. JEA requires one covering all installed components and does not accept ratings for individual pieces. FPL requires AHRI certification.

Ask every bidder for the AHRI reference number of the exact combination they are quoting. Look it up yourself. If the numbers on the certificate do not match the quote, ask why.

Should a quote list model numbers?

Yes, always. "3-ton 16 SEER2 system" is not a quote you can compare or hold a contractor to. Full model numbers let you:

  • Verify the efficiency rating in the AHRI Directory.
  • Check the refrigerant type and manufacture date.
  • Confirm the tonnage. Many model numbers include a size code: "024" is about 2 tons, "036" about 3 tons, "048" about 4 tons and "060" about 5 tons, because they show thousands of Btu per hour. Formats vary by brand, so check the spec sheet.
  • Compare equipment tiers across brands.
  • Make sure the installed equipment matches what you paid for. Check the nameplates after installation.

If a company will only give a price for "our Gold package," ask for the model numbers in writing before signing. If they refuse, that is a reason to move on.

What does good, better, best pricing mean?

Many companies present three or more options, often called good, better, best (or bronze, silver, gold). Typically:

TierUsually meansTrane 2026 installed AC example
GoodSingle-stage, near the minimum efficiency$6,568 to $8,544 (up to 17 SEER2)
BetterTwo-stage or multi-stage, mid efficiency$8,573 to $10,671 (up to 17.1 SEER2)
BestVariable-speed (inverter), highest efficiency, communicating controls$11,525 to $13,669 (up to 24 SEER2)

The tier names are sales packaging. What matters is the equipment and scope inside each. Some "best" tiers add a longer labor warranty, a maintenance plan or air cleaners. Ask for each tier's model numbers and the scope differences. Often the right choice is the "good" equipment with a better installation, or the "better" tier for humidity control in Florida. See our SEER2 guide for payback math.

Is the cheapest AC quote a red flag?

Not automatically, but check why it is cheap. A low quote often means one of these:

  • Smaller scope: reusing the old air handler or coil, line set, pad and disconnect without saying so.
  • No permit. In Florida, starting permit-required work without a permit is a prohibited act for contractors (Fla. Stat. 489.127). In Texas, TDLR lists failing to obtain a permit as a sanctionable violation.
  • No load calculation, with a size guess.
  • Leftover or mismatched equipment without an AHRI certificate.
  • A shorter labor warranty.
  • An unlicensed installer. Florida contracts by an unlicensed contractor are unenforceable by that contractor (Fla. Stat. 489.128), which also means you may have little recourse for the work itself.

A cheap quote that passes the checklist is simply a good price. A cheap quote with blanks in the checklist is a cheaper job.

Is the most expensive quote the best?

No. A high price can reflect premium equipment, a better install, or just high overhead and a hard sell. Judge each quote by the checklist, not the total.

Is it normal for HVAC companies to give prices only in person?

For a full system replacement, yes, mostly. An honest replacement price depends on things a contractor has to see: the air handler location, duct condition, electrical panel, line set route, drain and the home's size and layout. A load calculation also needs measurements. Many companies will give a rough phone range but a firm price only after a visit.

The concern is a visit that turns into a long sales presentation and a "sign today" price. Some tips:

  • Say up front that you are collecting three written quotes and will decide within a set time.
  • Ask for the quote by email, with model numbers and scope.
  • Be skeptical of "today only" discounts. A legitimate price is still good next week.
  • If you sign at home, you may have a right to cancel. See the cancellation section below.

What is a fair markup on HVAC installation? Should I negotiate?

There is no published, verified standard markup for residential HVAC installation, and you should not trust any article that states one as fact. The installed price covers equipment, labor (often two or more installers for a day or more), materials, permits, vehicles, insurance, warranty risk, office overhead and profit. Texas Class A contractors must carry at least $300,000 per occurrence in liability insurance, for example (TDLR).

Better than guessing at markup: compare three complete quotes for the same equipment tier and scope. If one is far above the others, ask what it includes that the others do not.

How to negotiate respectfully

  • Ask whether a lower tier, the same brand's equivalent model, or a different install date lowers the price.
  • Ask the contractor to match scope with another quote rather than just price.
  • Ask whether they can include something of value, such as a longer labor warranty or a first-year maintenance visit.
  • Do not ask a contractor to skip the permit or load calculation to save money.

Which AC brand is best? Are all AC brands made by the same companies?

We do not rank brands. Installation quality, correct sizing and a matched system usually matter more than the name on the box, and every major brand sells equipment that meets federal standards. What we can tell you is that many brand names share a parent company. Ownership changes, so confirm on the manufacturer's site.

BrandWhat the brand's own site shows (checked November 2026)
Bryant"A Carrier Company," copyright Carrier
Payne"Payne is now WeatherMaker by Carrier"
GoodmanCopyright Daikin Comfort Technologies North America
Amana (HVAC)"Manufactured under license by Daikin," copyright Daikin Comfort Technologies North America
RuudCopyright Rheem Manufacturing Company

Sister brands often share components and factories, but they can differ in model lineups, features and warranty terms. Compare the actual model specs and warranties, not the badge. See our who makes what guide.

Local company or national chain?

Either can do good work. What matters: a verified license, a named person responsible for the job, a written scope, a labor warranty in years, and a track record you can check. Ask how long the company has held its license and look it up. Ask who will do the install (employees or subcontractors) and who handles warranty calls.

Check the license before you sign

Texas

  • AC contracting requires a TDLR air conditioning and refrigeration contractor license (Tex. Occ. Code 1302.251). Class A covers any size; Class B covers systems up to 25 tons cooling or 1.5 million Btu/h heating.
  • License numbers look like TACL followed by the class, number and endorsement letter, for example TACL/A/000000/C, per TDLR. Residential comfort cooling needs the Environmental Air Conditioning endorsement.
  • Look it up at TDLR's license search (tdlr.texas.gov/LicenseSearch/).
  • Technicians must be registered or certified with TDLR and work under a licensed contractor.

Florida

  • AC contracting requires a state-certified or locally registered Class A, B or C air-conditioning contractor, or a mechanical contractor (Fla. Stat. 489.105). Certified licenses begin with CA (AC) or CM (mechanical); registered licenses begin with RA or RM and are valid only in the jurisdictions where registered.
  • Look it up with DBPR's license search at myfloridalicense.com. DBPR's contact center is (850) 487-1395.
  • A contractor vehicle that shows the company name must display the license number (Fla. Stat. 489.119).

Also confirm the company has general liability insurance and, in Florida, workers' compensation coverage (required for license renewal under Fla. Stat. 489.114). See our Texas and Florida license guides.

What should an HVAC contract include?

The signed contract should repeat everything in the quote and add:

  • Company legal name, address and license number.
  • Your address and the exact equipment, by model number, plus the AHRI reference number.
  • Full scope, including what is excluded.
  • Price, deposit, payment schedule and what triggers final payment (for example, passed final inspection).
  • Start date, expected duration and who pulls the permit.
  • Labor warranty in years and manufacturer warranty registration.
  • Clean-up, haul-away and refrigerant recovery.
  • Change-order process: no extra charges without your written approval.

Texas notices

  • Before a residential construction contract is signed, the original contractor must give the owner a "Know Your Rights and Responsibilities" disclosure statement (Tex. Prop. Code 53.255).
  • A lien on a homestead requires a written contract signed before work begins, by both spouses if the owner is married, and filed with the county clerk (Tex. Prop. Code 53.254).
  • Texas homeowners must retain 10% of the contract price during the work and for 30 days after completion to protect against subcontractor lien claims (Tex. Prop. Code 53.101).

Florida notices

  • Residential contracts over $2,500 must include a notice of your rights under the Florida Homeowners' Construction Recovery Fund (Fla. Stat. 489.1425). For contracts signed on or after July 1, 2024, the fund pays up to $30,000 per claim against a Division II contractor such as an AC contractor (Fla. Stat. 489.143).
  • Direct contracts over $2,500 for homes of up to four units must include the construction lien law warning in 12-point bold capitals (Fla. Stat. 713.015).
  • A notice of commencement is not required for a direct contract to repair or replace an existing HVAC system under $15,000 (Fla. Stat. 713.135).
  • If you pay a deposit over 10%, the contractor must apply for permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after permits issue, unless there is just cause or a written agreement (Fla. Stat. 489.126).

See our mechanics liens guide. This is general information, not legal advice; for a large or disputed job, talk with a Texas or Florida attorney.

Can I cancel after signing? The 3-day rules

  • FTC Cooling-Off Rule: gives a 3-day right to cancel certain sales made at your home, workplace or a temporary location, for sales of $25 or more at home. It does not cover sales needed to meet an emergency or repairs you asked a company to perform. A replacement you agreed to after the salesperson visited your home may be covered, depending on the facts. The seller has 10 days to refund after a valid cancellation.
  • Texas: a consumer may cancel a home-solicited sale of goods or services over $25 until midnight of the third business day after signing, and the merchant must give a notice of that right in bold type (Tex. Bus. & Com. Code 601.051 and 601.052).
  • Florida: a buyer may cancel a home solicitation sale until midnight of the third business day after signing, by written notice; mailed notice is effective on postmark (Fla. Stat. 501.025). The contract must include a "BUYER'S RIGHT TO CANCEL" statement (Fla. Stat. 501.031).

Send cancellations in writing, keep a copy, and use certified mail if you can, as the FTC suggests. If a contractor will not honor a valid cancellation, see our complaints guide.

How to choose a provider

  • Get three written quotes for the same tier and scope.
  • Verify each license: TDLR in Texas, DBPR in Florida.
  • Require full model numbers for every component.
  • Get the AHRI reference number and look it up yourself.
  • Ask for a Manual J load calculation and a copy of the report.
  • Compare scope line by line: line set, pad, disconnect, drain safety, thermostat, ducts, permit, haul-away, startup.
  • Compare labor warranty years and who registers the manufacturer warranty.
  • Confirm utility rebate eligibility and who files it.
  • Check the deposit size and payment schedule; tie final payment to a passed inspection.
  • In Texas, look for the 'Know Your Rights and Responsibilities' disclosure; in Florida, the Recovery Fund notice and lien warning on contracts over $2,500.
  • Read the cancellation notice and note the deadline.
  • After installation, check that the nameplates match the contract.

Related ac and heating guides

AC and heating by state and city

Questions people ask

How do I compare AC quotes?

Put the quotes side by side and compare each line: model numbers, tonnage, SEER2, EER2 and HSPF2, the AHRI certificate number, whether a Manual J was done, and the scope (line set, pad, disconnect, drain safety, thermostat, ducts, permit, haul-away, startup). Then compare labor warranty years and the payment schedule. Only after that compare the totals.

What questions should I ask an HVAC contractor?

Ask for the license number, whether they will do a Manual J and share it, the AHRI reference number, full model numbers, what happens to the line set, who pulls the permit, what the labor warranty is in years, who registers the manufacturer warranty, which utility rebate applies and who files it, whether installers are employees or subcontractors, and how changes to price are approved.

Should I negotiate an AC quote?

You can, politely. Ask whether a different tier, an equivalent model or a flexible install date lowers the price, or whether they will match another bid's scope. Asking for a longer labor warranty or a first maintenance visit is often easier than a price cut. Never trade away the permit or the load calculation to save money.

Is it normal to pay a deposit for a new AC?

Many contractors ask for a deposit to order equipment. Keep it reasonable and in writing. In Florida, if a contractor takes more than 10% of the contract price as a deposit on residential work, the law requires it to apply for permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days after permits issue, unless there is just cause or a written agreement (Fla. Stat. 489.126).

Do I want a local company or a national chain?

Either can do good work. Judge the company, not its size: a verified license, insurance, a written scope with model numbers, an AHRI certificate, a Manual J, a clear labor warranty in years and a responsive warranty process. Ask who will actually do the installation and who you call if something goes wrong.

What is a good labor warranty on a new AC?

There is no legal minimum. Compare the years each bidder offers, what they cover (labor only, or labor plus refrigerant), and whether the warranty requires maintenance visits. Manufacturer parts warranties usually exclude labor, so the installer's labor warranty is what protects you from labor bills on early failures.

Can I cancel an AC contract after signing?

Possibly. The FTC Cooling-Off Rule and Texas and Florida home solicitation laws give a right to cancel certain sales made at your home until midnight of the third business day after signing. Emergency repairs and repairs you requested are generally excluded from the FTC rule. Cancel in writing, keep proof, and check your contract's cancellation notice.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration