New ebook: Before You Borrow, how lenders decide and how to get your business loan approved. Get it for $7.99 →
New ebookHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, build your own insightsGet it now →
Markets
Real businesses. Bigger perspective. · Thu, Nov 19, 2026News. Tools. Scores. Games. Free.The Morning Chronicle
Donate BTCOpen dDashboard

Local Guide · General and residential contractors

How Do I Compare Contractor Bids Apples to Apples?

A step-by-step method for getting bids you can actually compare: write the scope, set the allowances, level the bids, and judge the rest, with Texas tax and Florida association rules.

To compare contractor bids fairly, give every bidder the same written scope, the same allowance amounts and the same insurance and payment terms, then line the bids up in a leveling table. Mark each item included, excluded or priced, get prices for anything missing, and compare leveled totals. Then weigh license, insurance, schedule, warranty and payment terms. The lowest raw number is often not the lowest real cost.

Key facts

  • Florida condo associations must get competitive bids for contracts requiring payment over 5% of the total annual budget including reserves (s. 718.3026); HOAs over 10% (s. 720.3055).
  • Neither Florida statute requires an association to accept the lowest bid.
  • Under Texas rule 34 TAC 3.291, a lump-sum contractor pays tax on materials and may not collect a separate amount represented as tax from the customer; a separated contractor collects tax on the materials price.
  • Texas treats cost-plus contracts as separated contracts for sales tax when labor is stated separately from materials.
  • NAHB's 2024 Construction Cost Survey found overhead and general expenses at 5.7% and builder profit at 11.0% of the average new single-family home's sales price.
  • Florida local governments may not require the owner-contractor contract or a cost breakdown to issue a building permit (s. 553.79).
  • A Florida contractor taking more than 10% up front on residential work must apply for permits within 30 days and start within 90 days after permits issue (s. 489.126).
  • Texas Property Code 53.255 requires contractors to warn residential owners that oral promises not in the written agreement may not be enforceable.

Why are contractor bids so different?

Getting three bids for the same kitchen and seeing $38,000, $52,000 and $71,000 is normal. It rarely means one contractor is honest and two are crooks. Most of the gap comes from five things:

  1. They priced different jobs. If you described the project out loud, each contractor wrote down a different version of it. One assumed new cabinets, one assumed refacing. One included the permit, one did not.
  2. Different allowances. One bid carries $3,000 for tile, another $9,000. The cheaper bid is not cheaper. It just guessed lower on something you have not picked yet.
  3. Different exclusions. Drywall repair after plumbing work, dumpster fees, electrical panel upgrades and painting are common items that one bidder includes and another leaves out in fine print.
  4. Different business models. A licensed, insured company with a project manager, warranty service and a real office has costs that a one-truck operator does not. Those costs show up as overhead.
  5. Different appetite for your job. A busy contractor may price high because it does not need the work. A contractor with a gap in its schedule may price sharp.

Your job is to remove the first three causes so you can judge the last two. The method on this page does that: write your own scope, ask every bidder to price the same scope in the same format, then level the bids side by side.

Estimate vs quote vs bid: what's the difference?

People use these words loosely, and the legal effect depends on what the document says, not what it is called. In general usage:

TermWhat it usually meansCan the price change?
Ballpark or estimateA rough number to see if the project is in your budget, often given after one short visitYes, freely. It is a guess, not an offer
Quote or proposalA priced offer for a described scope, often with an expiration dateIt should not change for the stated scope while it is valid; changes come by change order
BidA priced offer made in response to your written request, often on your form, your plans and your deadlineSame as a quote; it becomes binding when both sides sign a contract
ContractThe signed agreement, which should incorporate the scope, plans and priceOnly as the contract allows, usually by signed change order

Tip: if a document says "estimate" but you intend to rely on the price, ask the contractor to restate it as a fixed price for the attached scope, or to explain in writing what could make it change.

Step 1: Write your own scope of work

A scope of work is a written description of what will be built, removed, repaired and finished. It is the single most important tool for comparing bids, because it forces every contractor to price the same thing. You do not need to be an expert. You need to be specific.

What a homeowner scope should include

  • Project address and type of property (single-family, condo unit, townhouse, commercial space).
  • Room-by-room list of work. For each room: what is demolished, what is built, and what finishes go in.
  • Who supplies what. Owner-supplied appliances or fixtures should be listed so no one prices them.
  • Specifications or selections where you have them: make and model of fixtures, cabinet type, flooring material, paint level.
  • Allowances for items not chosen yet, with the same dollar amount for every bidder (see below).
  • Permits, plans and inspections. Say the contractor obtains and pays for all permits and schedules inspections, unless you plan otherwise.
  • Site conditions. Working hours, parking, whether you live in the house, pets, HOA or condo rules, elevator reservations.
  • Cleanup and disposal, including dumpster and haul-off.
  • Schedule. Target start and finish dates or a duration.
  • Insurance and license requirements. State the coverage and limits you will require so everyone prices them. See contractor insurance requirements.
  • Payment terms you expect, such as progress payments tied to milestones, so no one assumes a large deposit. See deposits and payment schedules.

For bigger projects such as additions, structural work or a commercial build-out, the scope is usually a set of drawings and written specifications from an architect or engineer. Florida generally requires a building permit before you construct, alter or repair a building, and Texas cities require permits for most structural and trade work, so plans are often needed anyway. See Florida permits and Texas permits.

Example of a weak scope line vs a strong one

WeakStrong
Redo master bathDemo existing tub, vanity, tile floor and wall tile to studs. Install 60 in. curbless shower with linear drain, waterproofing membrane, owner-selected wall tile to ceiling (tile allowance $8 per sq ft material). Replace vanity with owner-supplied 48 in. vanity. New exhaust fan vented to exterior. Patch and paint walls and ceiling. Permit and inspections by contractor.
Paint the houseExterior: pressure wash, scrape loose paint, prime bare wood, two coats of exterior acrylic on siding and trim, one color body and one trim. Exclude: doors, garage door, deck.

Step 2: How many bids should I get?

Three comparable bids is a common, practical target for a homeowner project. More is not always better. Five vague bids teach you less than three bids priced from the same scope.

  • Small repair (a day or two of work): one or two is often realistic. Many good contractors will not travel out to bid a small job against five others.
  • Remodel or roof: three is a good target.
  • Additions, new homes and commercial build-outs: three to five qualified bidders, invited after you check licenses and references first.

Florida condo and HOA associations have legal bid rules

If you serve on a Florida condo or HOA board, the number of bids is not just good practice:

  • Condominiums (s. 718.3026): contracts for materials, equipment or services must be in writing, and if a contract requires payment by the association exceeding 5 percent of the association's total annual budget, including reserves, the association must obtain competitive bids. Associations with 10 or fewer units may opt out by a two-thirds vote of unit owners.
  • Homeowners' associations (s. 720.3055): the competitive bid trigger is a contract requiring payment exceeding 10 percent of the total annual budget, including reserves.
  • Neither statute requires the association to accept the lowest bid. Both exclude certain professional contracts, such as attorneys, accountants, architects, engineers and community association managers, and neither limits buying needed products and services in an emergency. Both also exempt a business that is the only source of supply in the county.

Check your association's declaration and bylaws too, because they can add stricter procedures. Some older guides cite a 10 percent trigger for condos. The 2026 text of s. 718.3026 says 5 percent.

Step 3: Ask for bids in the same format

Send each bidder the same package: your scope, plans if any, allowance amounts, insurance requirements, desired schedule and a bid form. Ask them to break the price into the same groups so you can line them up. A simple bid form for a remodel might ask for:

  • Permits, plans and fees
  • Demolition and disposal
  • Framing and structural
  • Plumbing
  • Electrical
  • HVAC
  • Insulation and drywall
  • Cabinets and countertops
  • Tile and flooring
  • Painting
  • Allowances (listed separately)
  • General conditions (supervision, temporary protection, cleanup, dumpster)
  • Overhead and profit (or a statement that they are included in each line)
  • Total and the date the price expires

Also ask each bidder to list exclusions, assumptions and the expected start date and duration. Give everyone the same deadline and the same answers to questions. If one bidder asks a good question, send your answer to all of them.

Why won't a contractor give me a line-item bid?

Some contractors only quote one lump-sum number. Common reasons: they do not want competitors to see their pricing, they have been "shopped" before (see the ethics section below), or they simply price that way. A lump-sum price for a clearly written scope is not a red flag by itself. What matters is that the scope, allowances and exclusions are spelled out. If a contractor will not break out allowances or tell you what is excluded, that is a bigger problem than missing line items, because you cannot compare the bid or control later costs.

Step 4: Level the bids (an on-page bid leveling sheet)

Bid leveling means adjusting the bids so they price the same scope before you compare totals. Commercial contractors do this for every subcontract. Homeowners can do it with a simple table. Here is a filled-in example for a bathroom remodel. The numbers are illustrations only, not cost data.

LineBidder ABidder BBidder CNotes
Base bid as submitted$24,000$31,500$29,000Raw totals
Permit and inspectionsExcludedIncludedIncludedAdd A's permit cost after asking A for a price
Tile allowance$2,000$4,000$4,000A is $2,000 low against your own allowance
Drywall patch and paintExcludedIncludedIncludedAsk A to price it
Exhaust fan to exteriorIncludedIncludedNot mentionedAsk C to confirm in writing
Dumpster and haul-offIncludedIncludedIncluded
Waterproofing systemNot specifiedSheet membraneLiquid membraneAsk A what it uses; both B and C methods are common
Warranty on laborNot stated2 years1 yearAsk A
Start date and durationNext week, 3 weeks6 weeks out, 4 weeks4 weeks out, 5 weeksA very fast start can mean a gap in their schedule, which is fine, or overbooking, which is not
Payment terms50% down10% down, 4 progress draws25% down, 3 drawsLarge deposit raises your risk; see the payment guide
Leveled totalabout $30,000 after adding missing items$31,500$29,000, pending fan confirmationThe low bid is no longer the lowest

How to use it:

  1. List every scope item from your scope down the left column.
  2. For each bid, mark Included, Excluded, Not mentioned, or the dollar amount.
  3. Replace each bidder's allowances with your standard allowance so they match.
  4. For excluded or unclear items, ask the bidder for a written price or confirmation. Do not plug in your own guess if you can get theirs.
  5. Compare leveled totals, then compare the things a total cannot show: schedule, warranty, payment terms, insurance, references and how they communicate.

What is an allowance, and how do allowances trap owners?

An allowance is a dollar amount in the bid for an item you have not chosen yet, such as tile, light fixtures, countertops or appliances. When you make your selection, the real cost is compared with the allowance. If you spend more, you pay the difference. If you spend less, you should get a credit.

The four allowance traps

  1. Lowball allowances. A contractor puts $1,500 for countertops when the material you want costs several times that. The bid looks cheap, and the true cost shows up later as a change order. Fix: you set the allowance amount for all bidders, based on showroom prices for what you actually like.
  2. Material only or installed? A $5-per-square-foot tile allowance may be material only, while a different bidder's allowance includes labor. Fix: state "material only, labor included in base bid" or the reverse, for every allowance.
  3. Markup on overages. Some contracts add the contractor's markup to any amount over the allowance. That can be fair, because the contractor manages and warrants the extra work, but it should be stated. Fix: ask each bidder, in writing, whether overages carry markup and at what rate, and whether credits for underspending are returned in full.
  4. Too many allowances. A bid that is mostly allowances is not a fixed price. Fix: make as many selections as you can before you sign.

Sample allowance clause: "Allowances are for material cost only, at Contractor's cost before markup. If actual cost exceeds the allowance, Owner pays the difference plus Contractor's markup of __ percent by signed change order. If actual cost is less, Owner receives a credit of the full difference." See change orders for how overages get approved.

What is contractor overhead and profit, and what markup is normal?

A contractor's price has three parts: direct costs (labor, materials, subcontractors, equipment and permits for your job), overhead (costs of running the business that are not tied to one job, such as office rent, insurance, trucks, software, estimating time and warranty service), and profit (what is left as a return for the owner's risk and work). Markup is the percentage added on top of direct costs to cover overhead and profit.

There is no law in Texas or Florida that sets a "normal" markup for private work, and remodeling markups vary with the company's size, market and risk. Be wary of any article that gives a single universal number without a named source. One named, dated data point exists for builders of new homes: the National Association of Home Builders' 2024 Construction Cost Survey, reported January 23, 2025, found that for the average new single-family home, overhead and general expenses were 5.7 percent of the sales price and builder profit was 11.0 percent, with construction costs at 64.4 percent and the finished lot at 13.7 percent. Those figures describe new home builders' sales prices, not remodelers' markups on cost, so do not apply them directly to a kitchen bid.

How to judge markup without a magic number:

  • Compare leveled totals, not percentages. A contractor with a higher markup but tighter crews may still be cheaper in total.
  • Ask what the overhead buys you. Full-time supervision, a written warranty, a service department and proper insurance cost money and protect you.
  • Watch for markup on markup. If subcontractors already include their own overhead and profit, the general contractor's markup applies on top. That is normal, but it should not be applied twice by the general contractor itself.
  • Get the change-order markup in writing up front. This is where markup matters most, because you cannot competitively bid a change in the middle of the job.

Under a cost-plus contract, the markup or fee is visible and becomes a key negotiating point. See fixed-price vs cost-plus vs time-and-materials.

Unit price vs lump sum: how to compare them

Most home bids are lump sum: one price for the described work. Some trades price by the unit, such as per square of roofing, per linear foot of fence, per square foot of flooring, or per sheet of replaced roof decking.

Lump sumUnit price
How it worksOne total for the whole scopePrice per unit times quantity actually installed
Best forWell-defined work you can describe fullyWork where quantity is unknown until opened up, such as rotted roof decking or subfloor
Your riskGaps in scope become change ordersQuantity can grow; you need a way to verify counts
How to compareLevel scope and allowancesMultiply each unit price by the same estimated quantity for every bidder

Many roofing bids combine both: a lump sum for the roof, plus a unit price for any decking that must be replaced. When comparing, plug in the same estimated quantity of decking for each bidder, and ask how replaced units will be counted and shown to you, for example by photos and leaving removed pieces on site until you see them.

What are exclusions and qualifications in a bid?

Exclusions are items the bidder is not pricing. Qualifications (also called assumptions or clarifications) are conditions the price depends on. They are usually at the end of the proposal in small print, and they are where apples-to-oranges comparisons hide.

Common exclusions to watch for:

  • Permit fees, plan or engineering fees, impact fees
  • Repairs to hidden conditions such as rot, mold, termite damage or bad wiring found after demolition
  • Electrical panel or service upgrades
  • Patch and paint after trade work
  • Dumpster, haul-off and final cleaning
  • Appliance installation or hookup
  • Lead-safe work practices in pre-1978 homes
  • Landscaping or driveway repair after heavy equipment

Common qualifications:

  • "Price valid for 30 days." Ask what happens after.
  • "Based on normal working hours and free access." Matters in condos with elevator and hours rules.
  • "Assumes existing framing is level and sound."
  • "Material prices subject to change." This is an escalation clause in disguise. Ask for a fixed price or a clear formula.

For homes built before 1978, federal EPA rules require firms paid to disturb painted surfaces beyond small minor-repair thresholds to be certified and follow lead-safe practices. A bid that leaves this out on an older home may be underpriced or noncompliant. Ask.

Texas sales tax: lump-sum vs separated contracts

In Texas, how a bid is written can change how sales tax is handled. The Texas Comptroller's rule on contractors (34 Texas Administrative Code s. 3.291) divides contracts to improve real property into two types:

  • Lump-sum contract: one agreed price, with materials not separated from labor. The contractor pays sales tax to its suppliers on the materials it buys, and the rule says the contractor shall not collect from the customer any amount represented to be tax on a lump-sum charge. The tax is built into the price.
  • Separated contract: the agreed price is divided into a separately stated price for incorporated materials and a separate amount for skill and labor. The contractor acts as a retailer of the materials and collects tax from the customer on the materials price (the greater of the agreed contract price of the materials or the contractor's cost). The rule treats cost-plus contracts as separated when labor is stated separately from materials.

What this means for comparing bids: if one Texas bid shows "materials $18,000, labor $14,000, sales tax on materials" and another shows "$33,500 total," the second may already include tax that the first adds on top. Ask every bidder whether the price is lump-sum or separated, and whether any tax will be added. Separate rules apply to nonresidential repair and remodeling, which the Comptroller treats as a taxable service (34 TAC s. 3.357), so commercial tenants and landlords should ask about tax on labor as well. For a specific tax question, contact the Texas Comptroller.

Florida bid points to know

  • License class matters to the bid. A bid from a contractor whose Florida license does not cover the work is not comparable to one from a properly licensed firm, because an unlicensed contractor's contract is unenforceable by that contractor and gives no lien rights (s. 489.128), and the Recovery Fund does not cover contracts with unlicensed contractors. Check with the Florida license lookup before you level bids.
  • Deposit terms belong in the comparison. If a contractor takes more than 10 percent of the contract price up front on residential work, Florida law requires it to apply for permits within 30 days and start work within 90 days after permits issue, unless there is just cause or you agreed otherwise in writing (s. 489.126). Large upfront payments raise your risk, so treat them as a real cost in the comparison.
  • Permit offices do not need your price breakdown. Florida local governments may not require the contract, copies of it, or cost breakdowns as a condition of issuing a building permit (s. 553.79). Your detailed bid is for you, not the city.
  • Small jobs and the July 1, 2026 permit exemption. Under Ch. 2026-63, local governments must exempt single-family homeowners or their contractors from building permits for work valued under $7,500, outside flood hazard areas and excluding electrical, plumbing, structural, mechanical or gas work. Projects may not be split to stay under the limit. If one bidder says "no permit needed" and another includes one, ask each to explain which rule applies.

Is it rude or unethical to share one bid with another contractor?

Sharing a competitor's actual bid document so another contractor can undercut it is widely called "bid shopping," and many contractors consider it unfair. Their proposal reflects estimating work they did for free, and some include design ideas they consider their own. It also tends to backfire: contractors who feel shopped may cut quality, pad change orders, or refuse to bid for you again.

Fair practices that get you the same benefit:

  • Tell all bidders up front that you are getting several bids from the same scope.
  • Share your scope, not their numbers.
  • Ask a high bidder, "Your price is above the others for the same scope. Is there anything you priced that the scope does not require, or anything we could change to bring it down?"
  • If one bidder raised an issue the others missed, add it to the scope and send the update to everyone.
  • Tell the unsuccessful bidders promptly and thank them.

For Florida condo and HOA boards, keep a clean paper trail of how bids were requested, compared and chosen. A fair, documented process is easier to defend to owners.

Should I negotiate with a contractor?

Yes, but negotiate on scope and terms more than on the bare number. Squeezing a fair price down by 15 percent usually comes out somewhere else: cheaper materials, rushed work or aggressive change orders.

Things worth negotiating:

  • Value engineering: ask what changes would save money with little loss, such as a standard size window instead of a custom one or a different tile layout.
  • Payment schedule: a smaller deposit and payments tied to completed milestones.
  • Allowance terms and change-order markup.
  • Schedule: flexibility on start date can earn a better price from a contractor filling its calendar.
  • Warranty length and what it covers.
  • Cleanup, protection and working hours.

Get every agreed change into the written contract before you sign. An oral promise that is not in the written agreement may not be enforceable, as the Texas disclosure statement required by Property Code 53.255 warns homeowners.

Red flags when comparing bids

  • A bid far below the others after leveling, with no clear reason.
  • No license number (Florida) or no proof of trade licenses for electrical, plumbing or A/C work (Texas).
  • Pressure to sign today to "lock in" a price or a storm discount.
  • A large cash deposit, or payment to a person rather than the business.
  • Vague one-line scope, such as "remodel kitchen, $40,000."
  • No mention of permits on work that clearly needs them.
  • Refusal to provide a certificate of insurance.
  • A proposal that is mostly allowances.
  • Material prices "subject to change" with no formula or cap.

See contractor scams and red flags for more warning signs.

How long is a contractor quote valid?

As long as the quote says. Many proposals state an expiration such as 15, 30 or 60 days, because material prices and the contractor's schedule change. If there is no date, ask for one in writing. If you need more time, ask the contractor whether it will hold the price and for how long, or whether it will agree to an escalation formula tied to a public index. When a quote expires, the contractor can reprice, so compare bids that are all current.

How do I get contractors to bid on a small job?

Small jobs are hard to staff, and contractors choose which bids to spend time on. You improve your odds by making your job easy to price:

  • Send photos, measurements and a short written scope before the visit.
  • Bundle small items into one visit, such as several repairs in one trip.
  • Be flexible on timing so the job can fill a gap.
  • Do not ask five companies to drive out for a two-hour job. Ask one or two.
  • Be ready to decide quickly.

Still verify the license and insurance on a small job. In Florida, small jobs often still require a licensed contractor, and in Texas, electrical, plumbing and A/C work requires state-licensed trades no matter how small. See how to hire a general contractor.

How to choose a provider

  • Check licenses, insurance and references before inviting a contractor to bid.
  • Write a room-by-room scope with selections, owner-supplied items and exclusions.
  • Set one allowance amount for each unselected item and say whether it is material only.
  • State your insurance requirements and payment terms in the bid request.
  • Send the same package and deadline to every bidder, and share answers with all.
  • Ask for a price breakdown by trade plus a list of exclusions and assumptions.
  • Build a leveling table and get written prices for any missing items.
  • In Texas, ask whether each bid is lump-sum or separated for sales tax.
  • Compare leveled totals, then schedule, warranty, payment terms and communication.
  • Negotiate scope, deposit, allowance terms and change-order markup, not just price.
  • Put every agreed term in the signed contract.
  • Florida associations: confirm the bid threshold and document the process.

Related general and residential contractors guides

General and residential contractors by state and city

Questions people ask

How do I compare contractor bids apples to apples?

Write one scope of work, set the same allowance amounts, and send the same package to every bidder. When bids come back, build a leveling table: list every scope item and mark each bid Included, Excluded or a dollar amount. Ask bidders to price anything they left out, then compare the leveled totals along with schedule, warranty, payment terms, insurance and references.

Should I always take the lowest bid?

No. Take the lowest leveled bid from a contractor you trust, after confirming the license, insurance and references. A low raw total often hides exclusions or low allowances that come back as change orders. Even Florida condo and HOA associations, which must collect competitive bids above a budget threshold, are not required by statute to accept the lowest bid.

What is a bid leveling sheet?

It is a table that puts every bid's line items side by side so you can see what each one includes. You adjust each bid for missing items and allowance differences until all of them price the same scope. Commercial contractors use them for every subcontract. A homeowner can do the same with a spreadsheet or the table on this page.

What should a detailed contractor estimate include?

The project address, a description of the work room by room, who supplies materials, specifications or selections, allowances with amounts and terms, permits and inspections, exclusions and assumptions, schedule, payment terms, warranty, license number where applicable, and the date the price expires. A one-line price with no scope is not something you can compare or enforce well.

Why is one bid so much higher than the others?

Ask. The bidder may have included work the others left out, priced better materials, assumed hidden damage, or carry more overhead for supervision and warranty. It may also be a busy contractor pricing high. Ask what they included that the others did not and whether any part of their price is beyond the scope you asked for.

Is a verbal quote binding?

A verbal quote is weak protection. It is hard to prove what scope was quoted, and the Texas disclosure statement required by Property Code 53.255 warns that oral promises not in the written agreement may not be enforceable. Florida requires specific written notices in many residential contracts. Always get the scope and price in writing and signed before work starts.

Do contractors charge for bids?

Many do not charge for a basic proposal on a remodel. Some charge for detailed design work, drawings or a full estimate on a large project, sometimes credited back if you hire them. Ask before the visit. If a contractor does design work for you, be clear about who owns the drawings before you take them to other bidders.

How do I compare bids from a design-build firm and a contractor?

A design-build bid often includes design fees and may be priced before the plans are complete, so it can have more allowances. A contractor bidding from an architect's finished plans is pricing a fixed set of drawings. Separate the design cost, then compare construction scopes. See the design-build vs architect vs general contractor guide for the tradeoffs.

Sources

This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.

New ebook from The Company ChronicleHow to Research Like a Wall Street AnalystFind original sources, analyze trends, and build your own insights. 36 pages with worksheets.Get the ebook · $29Instant PDF download

Business Spotlight

Want us to publish your business?

Our team writes and publishes articles about your business on The Company Chronicle every month, with a link to your website. Plans from $30 a month, cancel anytime.

Publish with us

The Chronicle directory

What are you into?

The Chronicle, coast to coast

Every corner has a story.

The full Chronicle illustration