Local Guide · Foundation repair contractors
Which Foundation Repair Method Is Best? Piers, Piles, Slabjacking and Foam Compared
A neutral side-by-side of the eight main foundation repair methods, how each carries load, where each fits Texas clay and Florida sand and karst, what partial repairs can and cannot do, and how to read a repair plan.
No single method is best everywhere. Deep supports such as pressed concrete piles, steel push piers, helical piers and drilled concrete piers carry a slab on soil or rock below the zone where moisture changes, and are common on Texas clay. Slabjacking and polyurethane foam fill voids and lift lightly loaded slabs. Florida sinkhole repairs often add grouting. The right choice depends on soil, the cause of movement and the load, so a licensed engineer's sealed plan should pick the method, depth and layout.
Key facts
- The ASCE Texas Section guidelines list slab repair methods including underpinning, grouting, mudjacking, crack injecting, tendon stressing, and partial demolition and reconstruction (Version 3, 2022).
- ASCE Texas guidelines say construction documents should state that underpinning will not improve the foundation's performance in non-underpinned areas, and that elevation adjustments are unlikely to produce a level foundation.
- ASCE Texas guidelines say grouting or mudjacking should not be done beneath underpinned foundations if expected soil swelling in the injected area could damage the structure.
- For slab-on-grade repair, Houston requires plans by a Texas-licensed engineer showing the location, quantity and type of supports (piers or pressed piles), and its 2026 training deck calls for a pile note on refusal criteria or PSI.
- The 2023 Florida Building Code says friction and end-bearing resistance of deep foundation elements shall not be assumed to act together unless a geotechnical investigation supports it (1810.3.3.1.4).
- FBC 1808.6.1 requires foundations that extend into or through expansive soil to be designed to prevent uplift and to resist forces from soil volume change, or be isolated from it.
- Florida Statutes 627.707(5)(a) lets an insurer limit a sinkhole payment to actual cash value, which excludes underpinning or grouting below the foundation, until the owner contracts for the repairs recommended in the insurer's report.
- The Florida Geological Survey says sinkhole repair techniques range from grout or foam injection to engineered reinforced plugs, pins and porous concrete.
- This Old House (updated Oct. 8, 2026, Angi data) puts mudjacking or slabjacking at $550 to $1,300 and piering or underpinning at $1,000 to $3,000 per pier.
What are the main foundation repair methods?
Foundation repair methods fall into three families:
- Deep supports (underpinning): pressed concrete piles, steel push piers, helical piers and drilled concrete piers. These carry part of the house's weight down to deeper, more stable soil or rock. Underpinning just means adding support under an existing foundation.
- Shallow lifting and void filling: slabjacking (mudjacking) and polyurethane foam. These pump material under a slab to fill gaps and raise it.
- Ground improvement: compaction grouting and chemical grouting. These strengthen or densify the soil itself. Grout injection is one of the sinkhole repair techniques the Florida Geological Survey describes.
Pier-and-beam houses (homes with a crawl space) have their own repairs, such as shimming, adding supports and fixing framing. And many problems need no structural repair at all, just better drainage, steady watering, or a fixed plumbing leak. The ASCE Texas guidelines list those non-structural measures first.
Master comparison: how do the methods stack up?
| Method | How it works | Load carried by | Fits Texas clay? | Fits Florida sand or karst? | Main limits |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pressed concrete piles | Short precast concrete cylinders stacked and pressed into the ground with a hydraulic jack until they will not go farther (refusal) | Mostly side friction plus some end bearing | Used in Texas clay; Houston's permit rules list pressed piles as a support type | Less common; sand gives less friction and karst needs deeper, verified bearing | Segments can misalign; depth depends on refusal, not a verified stratum |
| Steel push piers | Steel pipe sections driven by a hydraulic ram that uses the house's weight as the reaction | Mostly end bearing on a firm layer; each pier is load-tested as it is driven | Used where firm strata or limestone can be reached | Used to reach limestone or competent soil under settling homes | Needs enough house weight to drive; corrosion protection matters |
| Helical piers | Steel shafts with screw-like plates turned into the ground | Bearing on the helix plates; capacity correlated to installation torque | Light loads, additions, porches; clay uplift must be designed for | Soft or loose soils, coastal sites, light structures | Rock and debris can stop them; clay heave can pull on plates |
| Drilled concrete piers (straight or bell-bottom) | A hole is drilled, reinforced and filled with concrete; a bell is a widened base | End bearing; bell resists uplift | Specified by some engineers for clay, set below the active zone | Less common for Florida homes; confirm with a Florida engineer | Slow (concrete must cure), messy, needs access |
| Slabjacking (mudjacking) | Cement-based grout pumped under a slab through holes | Soil under the slab | Driveways, walks, patios; limited for houses on active clay | Void filling under flatwork | Does not stop the soil below from moving; heavy material |
| Polyurethane foam | Expanding foam injected through small holes | Soil under the slab | Flatwork, minor voids | Voids under slabs; also part of some sinkhole work | Same as slabjacking; limited by soil below |
| Compaction or chemical grouting | Stiff grout or chemical injected deep to densify soil or fill voids | Improved soil, sometimes down to rock | Occasional | A main tool for sinkhole stabilization | Needs testing to design; can heave if overdone |
| Pier-and-beam shimming and re-leveling | Shims on pier caps, added supports, framing repair | Existing or new piers and footings | Standard repairs for crawl space homes in the ASCE Texas guidelines | Raised homes and older crawl space houses | Shims can need readjusting as soil moves |
Cost ranges from a named, dated source are thin. This Old House (updated Oct. 8, 2026, using Angi data) puts mudjacking or slabjacking at $550 to $1,300, piering or underpinning at $1,000 to $3,000 per pier, and full foundation lifting at $20,000 to $23,000, against a national average repair of $5,179. Treat these as national figures, not quotes. See foundation repair cost.
What is the difference between piers and piles?
In engineering, a pile is usually a long element driven or pushed into the ground, and a pier is often a column drilled and cast in place. In the foundation repair trade, people use the words almost interchangeably. 'Pressed piles,' 'pressed piers,' 'push piers' and 'steel piles' can all mean similar things. Houston's permit rules list supports as 'piers or pressed piles.' What matters is not the name but four questions:
- What material is it (precast concrete, steel pipe, helical steel, cast-in-place concrete)?
- How is it installed (pressed, driven, screwed, drilled)?
- How does it carry load (friction along its sides, bearing at its tip, or both)?
- How will the installer prove each one reached the required capacity?
End bearing vs friction: how do deep supports actually hold a house up?
A deep support holds weight in two ways:
- End bearing: the tip rests on a strong layer, such as dense sand, hard clay or rock, like a table leg on a floor.
- Skin friction: soil grips the sides of the shaft, like a fence post packed tight in the ground.
Most systems use some of each, in different mixes. The 2023 Florida Building Code says friction and bearing 'shall not be assumed to act simultaneously unless determined by a geotechnical investigation,' and it caps the friction that can be assumed for uncased cast-in-place elements unless a geotechnical study or load test supports more. Texas cities adopt their own editions of the model building codes, so ask your city which edition applies. Residential repair work is often designed on the engineer's experience rather than a site boring, which the ASCE Texas guidelines allow for smaller jobs but not major ones: 'for major or comprehensive remedial measures, geotechnical information should be derived from a site specific boring and testing program.'
Why friction is tricky in clay
In expansive clay, the upper soil swells and shrinks. When it swells, it can grip a shaft and pull it upward. When it shrinks, it lets go. That is why engineers try to place support below the active zone, the depth where seasonal moisture changes stop, and why the Florida Building Code requires foundations penetrating expansive soils to be designed to prevent uplift or to be isolated from the soil (1808.6.1). Reinforcement, sleeves or bells are common answers.
Why friction is tricky in Florida
Loose sand gives less friction, and in karst areas (land over limestone that dissolves) a support that stops in loose material above a void is not reliable. FBC 1810.3.4 also says elements driven through subsiding soils must account for the downward drag of those soils. So Florida engineers often specify supports driven or drilled to a verified bearing layer, sometimes combined with grouting.
How deep do foundation piers go?
It depends on the method and the soil, and no single number is right. We do not publish typical depths because the sources we trust do not set one. What sets depth:
- Refusal or torque criteria: pressed and push systems go until the hydraulic force reaches a set level; helical piers go until a set torque and depth. Houston's 2026 permit training calls for a pile note on refusal criteria or PSI on the plans.
- Specified depth: drilled piers are drilled to a depth the engineer chooses, often tied to the active zone or a bearing layer.
- Soil and rock: where a firm layer or limestone is shallow, supports stop shallow; where soft soil is deep, they go deep.
Ask for an installation log that lists every pier's location, final depth, and final pressure or torque. Compare it to the plan. Large swings between neighboring piers are worth a question to the engineer.
What is a load test during installation?
Some systems test themselves as they go. A steel push pier is driven with a hydraulic ram reacting against the house. The pressure gauge reading at the end of the drive shows how much force the pier resisted, which works as a load test on each pier. Helical piers use installation torque as a measure of capacity; the Florida Building Code allows helical capacity from 'well-documented correlations with installation torque' (1810.3.3.1.9) and requires installation to the depth and torque criteria set by a registered design professional (1810.4.11). Pressed concrete piles are pressed to a refusal pressure. Drilled piers are not load-tested this way in residential work; their capacity comes from design, depth and inspection of the hole.
For larger projects, the building code requires formal load tests in some cases, for example where the design load 'is in doubt' (FBC 1810.3.3.1.2), and sets a safety factor of at least two between ultimate and working loads (1810.3.3.1.7). Residential repair plans vary. Ask the engineer what will be recorded and whether they or their representative will observe.
Which method works best in Texas expansive clay?
Texas engineers work from the ASCE Texas guidelines, which leave method choice to the engineer and say underpinning design 'shall be based upon generally accepted engineering practice and appropriate engineering calculations.' In practice, many Texas residential repair plans call for deep supports under the slab perimeter and sometimes interior beams. Houston's permit rules name 'piers or pressed piles,' and Fort Worth requires engineered foundation plans and an engineered structural letter for foundation repair permits.
| Situation in Texas | Often considered | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Perimeter settlement from drought or trees | Pressed piles, push piers, drilled piers | Support below the drying zone |
| Heave in the middle from a leak | Fix leak, monitor; piers may make it worse | Lifting the edges to match a heaved center risks damage |
| Engineer wants uplift resistance | Drilled bell-bottom or reinforced piers | Bell and steel resist clay pulling up |
| Older pier-and-beam home | Shimming, added supports, framing repair | Floor framing can be adjusted from the crawl space |
| Sunken driveway or patio | Slabjacking or foam | Light load; low cost |
Texas law adds a rule: the exemption that lets non-engineers design work on private homes does not apply to design for repairing a dwelling slab on expansive soil as classified under the locally applied residential code (Occupations Code 1001.056(c)(2)). In clay areas, get a licensed engineer's plan. See expansive clay soil in Texas and Texas licensing.
Which method works best in Florida sand and sinkhole areas?
Florida movement often comes from poorly compacted fill, organic layers, erosion, leaks, or sinkhole activity over limestone. The Florida Geological Survey says repair techniques 'vary from injection of grout and/or foam into the hole to systems of engineered reinforced plugs, pins and porous concrete,' and that consultants may use ground-penetrating radar, electrical resistivity and soil borings to find cavities.
| Situation in Florida | Often considered | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Settlement on loose fill or organic soil | Push piers or helical piers to a firm layer | Bypass weak soil |
| Verified sinkhole activity | Compaction grouting, chemical grouting, often with underpinning | Fill voids and densify raveled soil down to rock |
| Voids under a slab from a broken drain | Fix pipe, then foam or grout | Restore support where soil washed out |
| Coastal or soft soils, light structures | Helical piers | Install without heavy equipment; work in soft ground |
Insurance shapes method choice in sinkhole claims
Under Florida Statutes 627.707(5), if a sinkhole loss is verified, the insurer pays to stabilize the land and building and repair the foundation according to the recommendations of the professional engineer it retained, subject to the policy, and the owner must repair according to those recommendations. Until the owner signs a repair contract, the insurer may limit payment to actual cash value, which excludes underpinning or grouting below the foundation. The owner must enter a repair contract within 90 days after coverage is confirmed (tolled during neutral evaluation), and repairs must generally be completed within 12 months. See the Florida sinkhole claim process.
Can a foundation be lifted back to level?
Usually not perfectly, and you should not expect it. The ASCE Texas guidelines say elevation adjustments 'should be governed by field judgment to limit damage to the foundation and finishes' and that 'it is unlikely that elevation adjustments will result in a level foundation.' Slabs are often not built level to begin with. Pushing too hard can crack the slab, break pipes and damage finishes. A good plan states a target, such as reducing slope or deflection within tolerances, rather than promising level floors.
After the lift, the ASCE guidelines call for a post-repair floor elevation survey and plumbing tests if the house was lifted. See elevation surveys and slab leaks and plumbing tests.
What is a partial vs full perimeter repair?
A partial repair supports only the area that moved, such as one corner or one side. A full perimeter repair supports the entire outside edge, sometimes with interior supports too.
Partial repairs cost less, but they have a known risk. The repaired area is now anchored to deep soil, while the rest still rides on soil that moves. That can cause relative movement between the two areas, with new cracks along the line between them. The ASCE Texas guidelines say partial underpinning may be specified when 'calculations, tests, or experience show that the unsupported structure can support its design loads,' and that the documents should state that underpinning 'will not improve the performance of the foundation in non-underpinned areas.'
| Question | Partial | Full perimeter |
|---|---|---|
| Upfront cost | Lower | Higher |
| Risk of new movement in unpiered areas | Higher | Lower at the edges; interior can still move |
| Warranty scope | Often only the piered area | Broader, but read the terms |
| Best when | Movement is clearly local and the cause is fixed | Movement is widespread or the soil is very active |
Ask any bidder to put in writing which areas their warranty covers. See foundation warranties.
Why do contractors recommend different methods?
Because most installers sell one or two systems they own the equipment for. A company that installs pressed concrete piles will usually propose them. One that installs steel piers will propose steel. That does not make either wrong, but it means the method choice should come from someone who is not selling it.
- Hire an independent engineer first, or require that the contractor's plan be designed and sealed by a licensed engineer who is the engineer of record. The ASCE Texas guidelines say the engineer who seals the documents has approval authority over changes, and that Texas rules prohibit 'plan stamping.'
- Ask each bidder why their method fits your soil and cause of movement, not just why it is good.
- Compare bids on the same plan: number, location and type of supports, depth or refusal criteria, testing, and warranty.
See how to compare foundation repair quotes and questions to ask a salesperson versus an engineer.
Is one method required by code?
No code in Texas or Florida names a single required repair method for homes. Codes set performance and design rules, and local permit offices set what plans must show:
- Houston: slab repair plans by a Texas-licensed engineer showing support type, location and quantity, plus structural and flood reviews.
- Fort Worth: engineered foundation plans and an engineered structural letter.
- San Antonio: foundation repair permits issued over the counter with form IB 172.
- Austin: foundation repairs over 128 square feet are not on the permit-exempt list, so confirm permit needs with Development Services.
- Florida: Florida Statutes 553.79 requires a permit to repair a building, and the FBC allows minor repairs without a permit only if they do not remove or cut a structural beam or load-bearing support. Engineers must seal plans and reports they give to owners or file for public record (471.025).
See foundation repair permits by city.
What should a repair plan include, whatever the method?
The ASCE Texas guidelines list 12 items for remediation documents. Use them as a checklist when you get a plan:
- Site address
- Engineer and firm name, address and phone
- Client name and address
- Purpose and limitations of the repair
- Geotechnical information and its source
- A plan view locating the relevant structural components
- Details showing how to build the repair parts
- Specifications for materials and methods
- Required construction observation or testing
- Existing elevations and any elevation adjustment requirements
- A requirement for a floor elevation survey after the work
- Site restoration requirements
The guidelines also call for a letter of substantial completion from the engineer, if retained, confirming the work generally matches the plan. See what to expect during foundation repair.
How to choose a provider
- Get an independent engineer's evaluation with an elevation survey before choosing a method.
- Find and fix causes first: leaks, drainage, trees and watering.
- Ask whether your movement is settlement, heave or both.
- Ask what bearing the method relies on: friction, end bearing or both.
- Ask whether a soil boring is needed for your job size.
- Get a sealed plan listing support type, number, locations and depth or refusal criteria.
- Compare all bids against the same plan.
- Ask how each support's capacity will be shown (pressure, torque or inspection) and get the log.
- Confirm whether the repair is partial or full perimeter and what the warranty covers.
- Pull the permit your city requires.
- Require pre- and post-lift plumbing tests and a post-repair elevation survey.
- Get the engineer's letter of substantial completion.
Related foundation repair contractors guides
- What Are Pressed Concrete Piles, and Are They the Right Foundation Repair for Your House?
- What Are Steel Push Piers, and How Do You Know They Will Hold?
- What Are Helical Piers, and When Do They Make Sense for a Texas or Florida Foundation?
- What Are Bell-Bottom and Drilled Concrete Piers, and Why Do Engineers Specify Them in Clay?
- Slabjacking, Mudjacking and Polyurethane Foam: What Do They Fix and What Don't They?
- How Do You Repair a Pier-and-Beam Foundation? Shimming, Re-Leveling, Rot and Crawl Spaces
- How Much Does Foundation Repair Cost in Texas and Florida? Real Price Ranges by Method
- How Do You Compare Foundation Repair Quotes Line by Line?
Foundation repair contractors by state and city
Questions people ask
What is the most permanent foundation repair?
No method is permanent in every soil. Deep supports placed on stable soil or rock below the active zone, with proper design and installation, tend to last longest because they bypass the soil that moves. But they only support the areas where they are installed, and drainage, leaks and trees still matter. Ask the engineer to explain the expected performance and limits, which the ASCE Texas guidelines say a repair plan should state.
Are steel piers better than concrete piles?
Neither is better everywhere. Steel push piers can reach deeper firm layers and are load-tested as they are driven, but need corrosion protection. Pressed concrete piles are widely used in Texas clay and rely on friction and refusal pressure. Drilled concrete piers resist uplift with bells and steel. The engineer should choose based on soil, depth to firm strata and the cause of movement.
What is underpinning?
Underpinning means adding support beneath an existing foundation so it rests on deeper, firmer soil or rock. Pressed piles, push piers, helical piers and drilled piers are all forms of underpinning. The ASCE Texas guidelines say underpinning plans should show the location, size, depth, material and minimum strength of each element, based on engineering calculations.
Is slabjacking or foam enough for a house?
Sometimes for voids under a slab, but often not as a long-term fix for a house on active clay, because it does not stop the soil beneath from moving. It is commonly used for driveways, walks and patios. In Florida, grout and foam injection are part of some sinkhole repairs, often with other measures. The ASCE guidelines warn against grouting under underpinned foundations if soil swelling could cause damage.
How many piers will my house need?
It depends on the house's weight, the foundation, the soil and how much area moved. There is no reliable rule of thumb. A licensed engineer sets the number and spacing in a sealed plan, and Houston requires that plan to show location, quantity and type. If bids differ widely in pier counts, ask each bidder to price the same engineer's plan.
Why does one company say 12 piers and another says 30?
They may be proposing different scopes (partial versus full perimeter), different systems with different capacities, or simply different sales approaches. Without a common engineered plan, you cannot compare them. Hire an independent engineer, get one plan, and ask every contractor to bid that plan. See our guide to comparing foundation repair quotes.
Do Florida sinkhole repairs use piers?
Often they combine methods. The Florida Geological Survey describes techniques from grout or foam injection to engineered plugs, pins and porous concrete. Many sinkhole repair plans pair grouting that fills voids and densifies soil with underpinning that supports the structure. Under 627.707, a verified sinkhole claim is paid for repairs according to the insurer's engineer's recommendations, subject to the policy.
Does my repair method affect resale?
Buyers and their engineers mainly want to see a sealed plan, a permit, the installation log, a post-repair elevation survey, the engineer's completion letter and a transferable warranty. A well-documented repair with any common method is usually easier to sell than an undocumented one. Keep every document.
Sources
- ASCE Texas Section, Guidelines for the Evaluation and Repair of Residential Foundations, Version 3 (2022)
- 2023 Florida Building Code, Building, chapter 18 Soils and Foundations (UpCodes)
- 2023 Florida Building Code, Building, chapter 1 (UpCodes)
- Houston Permitting Center, Foundation repair
- Houston Permitting Center, One-Stop Shop residential training deck (Feb. 2026)
- Fort Worth, Residential remodel checklist and packet (May 27, 2026)
- San Antonio Development Services, Residential permits
- City of Austin, Work exempt from building permits
- Texas Occupations Code chapter 1001
- Florida Statutes 627.707 (2025)
- Florida Statutes 553.79 (2025)
- Florida Statutes 471.025 (2025)
- Florida Geological Survey, Sinkhole FAQ
- This Old House, Foundation repair cost (updated Oct. 8, 2026)
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


