Local Guide · Hurricane shutters and impact windows
Which Hurricane Storm Panels Are Best: Steel, Aluminum or Clear Polycarbonate?
Removable storm panels are the lowest-cost approved shutter, but they shift the cost to your time, your back and your garage. Here is how the three materials compare, what the hardware is called, and how to label, store and test-fit panels before a storm.
Hurricane storm panels are removable corrugated sheets of galvanized steel, aluminum or clear polycarbonate that bolt or slide onto permanent tracks or studs around each opening. They are usually the least expensive approved shutter. Steel is heaviest, aluminum is lighter, and polycarbonate lets daylight in. TDI says metal panels tested to the same standard should perform the same. The trade-off is labor and storage: someone must carry, line up and fasten every panel before each storm.
Key facts
- TDI says galvanized and aluminum shutters tested and qualified to the same impact and wind pressure standard should perform the same.
- TDI advises having the installer pre-mark panels and leave a layout plan and instructions, and practicing installation on one or two openings ahead of time.
- Florida requires metal and plastic panels to carry the approval label embossed or printed at intervals of no more than every 3 lineal feet on each panel, facing outside (FBC 1709.9.3).
- Miami-Dade issues removable panel permits under category 101 and requires the current NOA, marking the specific panel and connection when the NOA covers more than one.
- Florida HOA law names polycarbonate panels as hurricane protection that an HOA may not deny if the installation conforms to its specifications (s. 720.3035(6)).
- In the HVHZ, shutters must not deform into contact with the glass under the large missile test (FBC 1626.2.6.1) and are limited to L/30 deflection with at least 1 inch of clear separation (Table 1616.3).
- Citizens tells policyholders to make stored shutters or panels available to the wind mitigation inspector.
- On Florida's 2026 wind mitigation form, approved panels can earn Level A, while plywood or OSB panels are Level C.
What are hurricane storm panels?
Storm panels are removable shutters made of corrugated sheets, usually about the height of the window, that overlap side by side to cover an opening. The ribs (corrugations) give them stiffness. Permanent hardware stays on the house year-round; the panels themselves are stored and put up only when a storm threatens. Florida's code calls them impact-resistant coverings, and each panel must carry a permanent label from the approval holder, embossed or printed at least every 3 lineal feet (FBC 1709.9).
Many Florida builders install the permanent anchors and a set of aluminum or steel panels on new homes because it meets the opening protection rule at the lowest cost. Panels are also the common retrofit for budget-minded owners in both states.
Steel vs. aluminum vs. clear polycarbonate
| Factor | Galvanized steel | Aluminum | Clear polycarbonate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Relative cost | Generally lowest | Low to moderate | Usually highest of the three |
| Weight to carry | Heaviest | Lighter | Light |
| Light indoors when installed | Dark | Dark | Daylight passes through |
| See out during storm | No | No | Partly |
| Corrosion | Coating protects; cut edges and scratches can rust | Does not rust, but can corrode in salt; hardware matters | Does not corrode; can scratch, cloud or yellow with sun and wrong cleaners |
| Edges | Sharp | Sharp | Smoother but still use gloves |
| Storage | Stacks flat; heavy stack | Stacks flat | Store so surfaces do not scratch |
| Performance | Same as aluminum if tested to the same standard (TDI) | Same as steel if tested to the same standard (TDI) | Depends on its approval; check span and clearance |
The headline: material does not decide strength. The approval does. A panel's NOA or FL# lists its design pressure, maximum span, required overlap, fastener spacing and minimum clearance from the glass. Choose the material based on weight, light and corrosion, then pick a product whose approval fits your openings.
Why choose clear polycarbonate?
- The house is not dark for days, which matters if you shelter at home or the power is out.
- You can see outside, so you know when the storm has passed or if someone is at the door.
- It is easier to spot an escape route, though the panel still blocks the opening; code allows covering bedroom escape windows only during the threat of a storm, with a first-floor exit kept open (FBC R310.4).
- Lighter panels are easier for one person.
Downsides: higher cost, surfaces scratch, and sunlight and harsh cleaners can degrade some plastics over time. Follow the care sheet.
Hardware glossary: headers, tracks, studs and wing nuts
| Term | What it is |
|---|---|
| Header (top track) | A metal channel fastened above the opening. Panels slide up into it or hook behind it. |
| Sill track (bottom track) | A channel or angle below the opening where the panel bottoms bolt. |
| F-track | A track shaped like the letter F in cross section; common for top or bottom mounting. |
| H-track or H-header | A track shaped like an H that can hold panels or join panel runs. |
| Build-out or angle | Hardware that holds the panel out from the wall to give clearance over trim or sills. |
| Studs (direct mount) | Threaded bolts permanently set in the wall around the opening; panels slip over them. |
| Wing nuts | Nuts with 'wings' you tighten by hand onto bolts or studs. Florida's plywood rule calls for washered wing-nuts with at least 1-inch washers; metal panel approvals list their own hardware. |
| Sidewalk bolt or embedded anchor | A female anchor set flush in the slab or sidewalk; a bolt threads in when panels go up. Some owners call these sidewalk anchors. |
| Overlap | How far each panel laps the next; the approval sets the minimum and the fastener spacing at laps. |
Embedded anchors vs. surface studs
Embedded (flush) anchors sit inside the wall or slab with only a threaded hole showing, so nothing sticks out between storms. Surface-mounted studs or tracks are simpler to install but stay visible and can snag. Both must match the approval's anchor type, embedment depth and edge distance for your wall (block, concrete or wood frame). If an anchor spins, pulls out or is missing, the panel at that spot is not secured to the approval.
How long does it take to put up panels?
It depends on the number of openings, panel count, height and practice. A small, single-story house with labeled panels and two people goes far faster than a two-story house with mixed panels and no plan. We will not quote hours without a neutral source; instead, time yourself. TDI suggests doing one or two openings at your leisure to learn the time and difficulty. Then multiply. If the answer is more than you can do between a hurricane watch and the arrival of tropical-storm winds, change the plan: get help lined up, switch hard openings to permanent shutters, or consider impact windows (see impact windows vs. shutters).
Pre-season test fit: step by step
- Pick a calm day in spring. Before June 1, when hurricane season starts.
- Pull out the layout plan. If you do not have one, make one: a sketch of the house with each opening numbered.
- Check every panel's number and label. Replace missing number tags.
- Inspect anchors and tracks. Run a bolt into each embedded anchor; clean out dirt, wasp nests and corrosion. Note any that spin or are cracked.
- Count the hardware. Every wing nut, washer and bolt for every opening, plus spares.
- Install one or two openings fully, including the hardest one (highest, widest, behind a shrub).
- Time it. Write the time on the plan.
- Remove, clean and restack in the order you will need them.
- Fix problems now: missing anchors, bent panels, lost hardware. Service is hard to get once a storm is named. See lead times and season timing.
How to label and store panels
- Label both ends: opening number and position (for example, '7-L, 7-2, 7-R') with paint pen or engraved tags. Mark the matching opening with a small tag or paint dot near the header.
- Stack in order: by opening, with the first ones you will hang on the outside of the stack.
- Keep hardware with panels: a labeled bin of wing nuts, washers, bolts, a nut driver or wrench, gloves and the layout plan.
- Store off the floor on a rack or wall hooks, dry, so panels do not bend or sit in water.
- Protect clear panels: keep them from rubbing on each other or on concrete; use the maker's recommended cleaner.
- Plan the space: before buying, ask how many panels your house needs and where they will go. A full set can take a large section of garage wall, and HOA rules may bar outdoor storage.
- Keep them accessible for inspections: Citizens asks policyholders to show stored panels to the wind mitigation inspector.
Handling panels safely
Metal panel edges are thin and sharp, and a panel can catch the wind like a sail. To stay safe:
- Wear cut-resistant work gloves, long sleeves and eye protection.
- Carry panels vertically and close to your body; get help with long or heavy ones.
- Do not hang panels from a ladder in rising wind. Do upper floors first, early, or use permanent shutters there.
- Keep children and pets away while you work.
- Lay panels flat when you set them down so they cannot blow over.
- Use a power driver with the right socket for nuts, but finish by hand so you do not strip threads.
Are panels the cheapest code-approved protection?
In cash outlay, approved panels are usually the lowest-cost product option, and many Florida builders use them for that reason. Plywood can cost less in materials, but it is a code exception with strict limits, not a shutter product: Florida allows 7/16-inch wood structural panels only on homes with a mean roof height of 33 feet or less where Vult is 180 mph or less, precut, predrilled and fastened to permanent corrosion-resistant anchors (FBC R301.2.1.2). Plywood also earns only Level C on Florida's wind mitigation form, while approved panels can earn Level A. See DIY plywood protection and shutter cost.
Count the hidden costs too: your time or paid labor every time a storm threatens, lost hardware, garage space, and the risk of not getting them up in time.
Can I install panels myself?
Putting up and taking down panels on existing anchors is something owners do themselves every season. Installing a new system (setting anchors and tracks) is different:
- Florida: a permit is generally required. Miami-Dade lists category 101 for removable panels, the NOA for each panel, a drawing of openings with mean roof height, and marking which panel and connection are used. Florida's owner-builder exemption lets owners work on their own one- or two-family home for their own use with a permit (s. 489.103(7)), but anchors must match the approval exactly. Contractors who install hurricane protection devices are licensed, for example as Specialty Structure Contractors (rule 61G4-15.015).
- Texas coast: for TWIA eligibility, file a WPI-1 and have the work inspected during installation. Coastal DIY panel kits exist, but the product must match a TDI-accepted evaluation and be installed per it for a WPI-8. Since April 1, 2026 TDI certifies to the 2024 IRC/IBC.
How heavy are hurricane panels?
Weight depends on material, gauge, length and width, and is listed on the maker's spec sheet. Steel is heaviest, aluminum lighter, and polycarbonate lighter still. Long panels for tall windows or doors are the hard ones. Before you buy, ask for the weight of the longest panel in your set and try lifting a sample. If you cannot handle it safely, plan for help or a different shutter on those openings.
Storm-day sequence: putting panels up
- Start at the hurricane watch, not the warning. A watch means hurricane conditions are possible; a warning means they are expected (FLASH). Panels take time.
- Bring in loose outdoor items first so they do not become debris while you work.
- Work from the most exposed side and the highest openings first, while wind is still light.
- Hang panels in numbered order, sliding each top edge into the header or over the studs and letting it overlap the last panel as the approval shows.
- Fasten every hole the approval calls for. Skipping fasteners to save time is the most common mistake; the rating assumes all of them.
- Snug, do not crush, wing nuts and bolts.
- Leave one exit door usable on the first floor, and do not panel over the only way out of a bedroom area.
- Walk around and check for gaps at panel ends and loose corners.
After the storm, remove panels from bedroom escape windows first, then the rest. Rinse, dry and restack them in order.
Clearance from the glass
A panel flexes when debris hits it and when wind pushes and pulls on it. If it flexes far enough to touch the glass, the glass can break even though the panel held. That is why approvals specify how far the panel must sit from the glass, and why build-outs are used over protruding sills and trim. In Miami-Dade and Broward, the code says shutters must resist the large missile without deforming into contact with the glass (FBC 1626.2.6.1), and the HVHZ deflection table limits storm shutters to L/30 with at least 1 inch of clear separation from the glass at maximum permissible deflection (Table 1616.3). Outside the HVHZ, follow the separation shown in the product's approval drawings. If your windows have been replaced with a different depth since the panels were installed, recheck the clearance.
When to replace panels or anchors
- A panel is creased, torn at a bolt hole, or bent so it no longer seats in the track.
- Steel panels show rust through the coating, especially at cut edges.
- Clear panels are cracked, crazed or so cloudy you can no longer see through them.
- Anchors spin, pull out, are cracked in the surrounding block or stucco, or are missing.
- You replaced windows or doors and the old panels no longer fit the new opening sizes.
- You cannot find any label or approval paperwork for the system, which leaves it scored as undocumented (Level N) on the Florida form.
Replacement panels should come from the same approved product line so that panels, overlaps and anchors still match the approval. Mixing brands on one opening breaks the tested system.
Florida and Texas notes
Florida: panels must carry an FL# or NOA; in Miami-Dade and Broward the approval must be valid for the HVHZ. The Miami-Dade Product Control search lets you filter HVHZ approvals. Florida law prohibits marketing a product as hurricane protection unless it is approved (s. 553.842(5)). Florida HOAs must allow polycarbonate panels and other hurricane protection that conforms to their specs (s. 720.3035(6)).
Texas: TDI lists hurricane shutters custom fitted to openings as one of three choices, with plywood as an emergency measure, and tells owners to use only products tested to ASTM E1886 and E1996 with a recognized product approval. Product evaluations are on TDI's Windstorm System. Salt air from Galveston to South Padre is hard on steel; rinse panels and anchors with fresh water and replace rusted hardware with what the approval allows. See TWIA windstorm certification.
How to choose a provider
- Get the NOA or FL# and confirm it covers each opening's span and design pressure.
- Choose material by weight, light and corrosion, not by assumed strength.
- Ask for a numbered layout plan and labeled panels at install.
- Plan storage space before buying.
- Keep a hardware bin with spare wing nuts, washers and bolts.
- Test-fit one or two openings each spring and time it.
- Clean and check every anchor before June 1.
- Do upper-floor openings first and early.
- Wear cut-resistant gloves and eye protection.
- Show stored panels to your wind mitigation inspector.
Related hurricane shutters and impact windows guides
- What Are the Types of Hurricane Shutters? Accordion, Roll-Down, Panels, Fabric, Colonial and Bahama Compared
- Can You Use Plywood for Hurricane Shutters? Code Rules, Thickness, Fasteners and Where Plywood Is Not Allowed
- How Much Do Hurricane Shutters Cost? Prices by Type for Panels, Accordion, Roll-Down, Fabric and Bahama
- Impact Windows vs. Hurricane Shutters: Which Protection Is Right for Your Home or Business?
- How Do You Maintain Hurricane Shutters and Impact Windows? An Annual Pre-Season Checklist for Florida and Texas
- When Should You Put Up Hurricane Shutters? Watch vs. Warning, How Long It Takes, and a Last-Minute Checklist
- Florida Product Approval (FL Number): How Do You Search floridabuilding.org and Verify Windows, Doors and Shutters?
- Do You Need a Texas Windstorm Certificate (WPI-8) for New Windows, Doors or Shutters?
Hurricane shutters and impact windows by state and city
Questions people ask
Steel or aluminum hurricane panels: which is better?
Neither is stronger by material alone. TDI says galvanized and aluminum shutters tested to the same standard should perform the same. Steel is heavier and usually cheaper; aluminum is lighter to carry. Near salt water, watch coatings and hardware on both. Pick by weight and corrosion, then check the approval.
Are clear polycarbonate panels worth the extra cost?
They are worth it if daylight, seeing outside and lighter panels matter to you, for example if you shelter at home through long outages. They cost more and scratch more easily. Make sure the approval fits each opening and follow the care sheet so the plastic stays clear.
Do panels come with new homes in Florida?
Many new Florida homes in wind-borne debris regions are built with permanent anchors and a set of panels, because that meets the opening protection rule at low cost. Others get impact windows. Ask the builder which you are getting, and get the approval documents and layout plan at closing.
What if I lost my wing nuts or a panel?
Replace them before the season with parts that match the product approval. Generic hardware may not hold the rated load. Contact the original installer or maker for exact parts. A missing panel leaves an unprotected opening, which drops your Florida wind mitigation rating to the weakest opening.
Why do panel edges cut hands?
Metal panels are thin sheets with sharp cut edges, and wind can jerk them while you hold them. Wear cut-resistant gloves and long sleeves, carry panels close to your body, and get help with long panels. Never handle panels on a ladder in rising wind.
Can I leave panels up all season?
Leaving panels over bedroom windows blocks escape; code allows it only during the threat of a storm. Long-term panels also trap moisture and may break HOA or condo rules. Take them down after the storm and store them. See our guide on shutters left up.
Do storm panels qualify for insurance discounts?
Yes, in Florida approved panels verified to the large-missile standard can earn Level A on the wind mitigation form if every opening is protected and documented. Keep the NOA and labels, and have the panels available for the inspector. Plywood panels are Level C.
Can panels protect a sliding glass door?
Yes, if the approval covers the door's height and span, but tall door panels are long and heavy. Leave at least one other exit door usable while the slider is covered. For wide sliders used often, many owners choose accordions, roll-downs or impact sliding doors instead, so they are not hauling long panels.
What are embedded anchors?
They are female threaded anchors set flush into the wall or slab so nothing sticks out between storms. When you hang panels, you thread bolts or studs into them. They must match the approval's type and embedment. Clean them yearly so dirt and insects do not block the threads.
Sources
- Texas Department of Insurance, Questions to Ask Your Contractor Before Installing Opening Protection
- Texas Department of Insurance, Windstorm Product Evaluations
- Texas Department of Insurance, Windstorm adopted building codes
- Florida Building Code, Building 8th Ed. (2023), Chapter 17 Special Inspections and Tests (UpCodes)
- Florida Building Code, Building 8th Ed. (2023), Chapter 16 Structural Design (UpCodes)
- Florida Building Code, Residential 8th Ed. (2023), Chapter 3 Building Planning (UpCodes)
- Miami-Dade County, Windows, Shutters and Doors permits
- Miami-Dade County, Product Control Search
- Florida Statutes s. 553.842, Product evaluation and approval
- Florida Statutes s. 720.3035, HOA architectural control; hurricane protection
- Florida Statutes s. 489.103, Exemptions (owner-builder)
- Florida rule 61G4-15.015, Specialty Structure Contractor
- Florida OIR Form OIR-B1-1802, Uniform Mitigation Verification Inspection Form (Rev. 04/26)
- Citizens Property Insurance, Your Wind Inspection
- FLASH, How to Prepare Your Home for a Hurricane
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


