Local Guide · Roofing
How to Compare Roofing Quotes Apples-to-Apples (With a Line-Item Checklist)
Why roofing bids for the same house can differ by thousands, how to check the squares, pitch and waste math, which line items Texas and Florida code require, and how to turn three different bids into one fair comparison.
To compare roofing quotes, put every bid on the same worksheet: number of squares (1 square = 100 sq ft), waste factor, tear-off layers, deck repair price per sheet, underlayment type, drip edge, starter, hip and ridge, flashing, ventilation, permit, disposal, cleanup and warranty tier. Most price gaps come from scope differences, not profit. In Florida, check for the required secondary water barrier and deck nailing. Ask each roofer to fill in anything missing before you choose.
Key facts
- A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof surface, and standard asphalt shingles usually come 3 bundles to a square (This Old House; Owens Corning).
- This Old House suggests adding about 15% to measured squares for waste on a shingle job; complex roofs with many valleys and hips need more (This Old House).
- The 2021 International Residential Code requires drip edge at eaves and rakes of shingle roofs, mechanically fastened at no more than 12 inches on center (IRC R905.2.8.5).
- The model residential code requires tear-off to the deck for a roof replacement and does not allow a recover over two or more existing roof coverings (IRC R908.3).
- Florida requires site-built single-family reroofs to include a secondary water barrier and improved roof-deck attachment (Fla. Stat. 553.844).
- Under the 9th Edition Florida Building Code, every tile underlayment in the HVHZ must have product approval, and HVHZ hip and ridge shingles must pass UL 2375 testing for permits from Jan. 1, 2027 (Miami-Dade RER).
- Owens Corning's top extended warranties require a set number of its own components and installation by a Platinum or Preferred contractor, and exclude tear-off and disposal costs (Owens Corning).
- 2025 Cost vs. Value put a benchmark asphalt shingle replacement at $27,116 in the West South Central region (includes Texas) and $32,253 in the South Atlantic region (includes Florida) (JLC/Zonda).
- In the TWIA area, most roof replacements need a TDI windstorm inspection and certificate of compliance (TDI).
Why are roofing quotes so different?
It is normal for three bids on the same house to be thousands of dollars apart. Most of the gap usually comes from different scopes of work, not from one roofer being greedy. Common reasons:
- Different roof size. One roofer measured 32 squares, another 36. That alone can be a 10% swing.
- Different waste factors (how much extra material is ordered for cuts and starters).
- Tear-off vs overlay, and how many existing layers are being removed.
- Decking assumptions. One bid includes a few sheets of new plywood; another includes none and charges extra later.
- Underlayment. Felt vs synthetic, and how much self-adhered membrane.
- Metal work. New drip edge, step flashing, valley metal and pipe boots vs reusing old pieces.
- Ventilation changes. Adding ridge vent or intake vents costs more.
- Code items that only some bids include (for example, Florida's secondary water barrier and deck re-nailing).
- Warranty tier. An extended manufacturer warranty requires more matching components and a certified installer.
- Overhead and insurance. A company paying for workers' comp, liability insurance, permits and a real office has costs a cash crew may not.
The only way to know which reason applies is to line the bids up item by item.
What is a square, and how do I check the math?
A roofing square is 100 square feet of roof surface. Shingles and many other materials are priced and ordered by the square. This Old House notes that standard shingle bundles each cover one-third of a square, so three bundles make one square.
Step 1: roof area is bigger than floor area
A sloped roof has more surface than the footprint under it, because of pitch (steepness) and overhangs. Pitch is written as rise over 12 inches of run, such as 6/12. You can convert footprint area to surface area with a pitch factor, which is simple geometry: the square root of (12 squared plus rise squared), divided by 12.
| Pitch | Multiply footprint by |
|---|---|
| 4/12 | about 1.054 |
| 6/12 | about 1.118 |
| 8/12 | about 1.202 |
| 10/12 | about 1.302 |
| 12/12 | about 1.414 |
Step 2: add waste
Some material is cut off at valleys, hips, rakes and around chimneys, and some is used for starter rows and caps. This Old House recommends adding about 15% to the measured squares for a typical shingle job. Simple gable roofs may need less; roofs with many hips, valleys and dormers may need more.
Worked example
A ranch house in San Antonio has a 2,000 sq ft footprint including overhangs, with a 6/12 pitch.
- 2,000 x 1.118 = 2,236 sq ft of roof surface, or about 22.4 squares.
- Add 15% waste: 22.4 x 1.15 = about 25.7 squares of shingles ordered.
- At 3 bundles a square, that is about 77 bundles.
If one bid says 22 squares and another says 30, ask each roofer to show the measurement and waste factor. Many roofers use aerial measurement reports. Ask for a copy. Our roof calculator walks through this.
The line-item checklist: what a complete estimate includes
Copy this table for each bid. If a line is blank, ask the roofer to fill it in writing.
| Line item | What to look for | Bid A | Bid B | Bid C |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Measured squares and waste % | Total squares, waste factor, measurement source | |||
| Tear-off | Number of existing layers removed, down to the deck | |||
| Deck inspection and repair | Price per sheet of plywood or OSB, thickness, how many sheets included | |||
| Deck re-nailing (FL) | Nail type and spacing to meet Florida's deck attachment rule | |||
| Secondary water barrier (FL) | Method: taped deck seams, self-adhered membrane, or other code option | |||
| Underlayment | Brand and type (felt, synthetic, self-adhered), where each goes | |||
| Drip edge | New at eaves and rakes, metal gauge or type, color | |||
| Starter strip | Manufacturer starter at eaves (and rakes, if needed for wind warranty) | |||
| Field shingles or tile | Brand, product line, color, wind and impact rating | |||
| Hip and ridge caps | Manufacturer hip and ridge product (needed for some warranties) | |||
| Valleys | Open metal, closed-cut, or woven; membrane under valleys | |||
| Flashing | New step flashing, counterflashing, chimney and skylight flashing, wall flashing | |||
| Pipe boots and penetrations | New boots or lead jacks, exhaust vent caps | |||
| Ventilation | Intake and exhaust type, quantity, net free area | |||
| Gutters | Remove and reset, replace, or not included | |||
| Permit and inspections | Who pulls it, fee included, final inspection | |||
| Windstorm certificate (TX coast) | TDI WPI-8 inspection and fee, if in the TWIA area | |||
| Dumpster and disposal | Included, where it goes, driveway protection | |||
| Cleanup | Daily cleanup, magnetic nail sweep | |||
| Manufacturer warranty | Exact warranty name, length, non-prorated period, who registers | |||
| Workmanship warranty | Years, what it covers, in writing | |||
| Schedule | Start window, expected duration | |||
| Payment schedule | Deposit, progress, final, retainage | |||
| Total |
Tear-off, layers and decking
Tear-off
The 2021 International Residential Code says a roof replacement includes removing existing layers down to the deck. It allows a new covering over an old one (a recover) only in limited cases, and never where the existing roof has two or more layers, is water-soaked or badly deteriorated, or is slate, clay, cement or asbestos-cement tile. Florida's existing-building code has the same core rule: tear off to the deck when there are 2 or more coverings or the roof is wet or deteriorated.
Texas adopts the 2012 IRC as its statewide minimum for cities, and cities can adopt newer editions. Houston, Dallas, San Antonio and Austin each set their own code edition, so ask the permit office which applies.
Rotten decking: the per-sheet clause
No one can see the full deck until the old roof comes off. Good bids handle this with a unit price: '$X per 4x8 sheet of 1/2-inch (or 7/16 or 5/8) plywood or OSB, installed, beyond the first N sheets included.' Look for:
- The thickness and material (plywood vs OSB) matching your existing deck or code.
- Whether the price includes labor and disposal.
- A requirement that the roofer photograph rotten sheets and get your approval (text or email is fine) before replacing more than a set number.
- A cap or a requirement for written approval above a dollar limit.
We could not find a reliable, dated public source for a 'typical' per-sheet price in Texas or Florida, so we don't print one here. Compare the per-sheet prices across your three bids instead, and be wary of any bid that has no unit price at all.
Florida's deck attachment rule
Florida law requires roof replacements on site-built single-family homes to include improved roof-deck attachment. IBHS testing shows the difference this can make: switching from smooth nails to 8D ring-shank nails with tighter spacing can double the deck's uplift resistance. Ask each Florida bidder how they will meet the rule and whether ring-shank nails are included.
Underlayment, secondary water barrier and ice-and-water shield
Do I need ice-and-water shield in Texas or Florida?
The model code's ice barrier requirement applies only in areas with a history of ice forming at the eaves, as designated by the local jurisdiction. Most of Texas and all of Florida are not in that category. But self-adhered membrane (often sold as 'ice and water shield') is still widely used in both states, for different reasons:
- Florida: state law requires a secondary water barrier on site-built single-family reroofs. The code allows several methods, such as taping deck seams or covering the deck with self-adhered membrane. Ask which method each bid uses.
- Texas coast: TDI's coastal windstorm guidance recommends a secondary water barrier, such as self-adhering tape or modified bitumen strips over deck joints, with 30# felt underlayment.
- Everywhere: valleys, around chimneys and skylights, and low-slope sections are common places for self-adhered membrane even when code doesn't require it.
Why it matters: IBHS says that for every inch of rain on an exposed deck, the equivalent of 9 bathtubs of water can enter the home. When shingles blow off in a hurricane, the secondary barrier is what keeps the water out.
Should I pay extra for synthetic underlayment?
Both felt and synthetic underlayments are used on code-compliant roofs. Price differences matter less than two practical questions: does your chosen warranty require a specific underlayment (Owens Corning's top warranties, for example, count one of its own underlayments among the required components), and does the product have the approvals your area needs (Florida's HVHZ requires product approval for tile underlayments)? Ask each roofer to name the exact product. The fair comparison is the same underlayment in every bid, or a stated price difference.
Florida tile roofs: the 2027 change
Under the 9th Edition Florida Building Code's high-velocity hurricane zone rules (Miami-Dade and Broward), every underlayment under roof tile must have product approval, and the old allowance for prescriptive 'yellow stripe' underlayments is gone. If your tile roof permit will be applied for after the new code takes effect, ask whether the bid reflects it. The state says the 9th Edition takes effect December 31, 2026; Tampa and Miami-Dade notices reference January 1, 2027. The code in effect on your permit application date governs the job.
Drip edge, starter, hip and ridge, and flashing
Drip edge
The 2021 IRC requires drip edge at the eaves and rake edges of shingle roofs, overlapped at least 2 inches, extended at least 1/4 inch below the sheathing, and fastened at no more than 12 inches on center. A bid that 'reuses existing drip edge' should explain why.
Starter strip
Starter shingles at the eaves seal the first row. Many wind warranties depend on them. Owens Corning says its 160 mph wind coverage applies only when its component requirements are met and starter shingles are installed on both the eaves and rakes. CertainTeed says its standard 110 mph wind rating upgrades to 130 mph with the right combination of starter shingles and hip and ridge accessories. If a wind warranty matters to you (it should in coastal Texas and Florida), check that the bid includes the required starter on both edges.
Hip and ridge
Manufacturer hip and ridge caps are often a required warranty component. In Florida's HVHZ, hip and ridge shingles on permits applied for starting January 1, 2027 must be tested and classified to UL 2375's wind test (modified to 110 mph) with labeled packaging.
Flashing
Flashing is the metal that seals joints at walls, chimneys, skylights and valleys. It is the most common leak source. The 2026 Florida Building Code expands where flashing is required, including roof edges, penetrations, wall intersections, gutters and slope changes. Ask each roofer: new step flashing and counterflashing, or reuse? A bid that says 'caulk as needed' at a chimney is not equal to one that replaces the flashing.
Why is one roofer quoting ridge vent and another box vents?
Both are exhaust vents. Ridge vent runs along the peak; box vents (also called static or turtle vents) are individual units near the top of the roof. Roofers choose based on the roof shape, existing intake vents at the soffits, and the shingle maker's requirements. Some reasons bids differ:
- One roofer is matching the existing setup; the other is redesigning it.
- Some roofs don't have enough ridge length for ridge vent alone.
- The intake side (soffit vents) may be blocked or missing, and one bid fixes it.
Ask each roofer to explain the intake and exhaust plan and to show the shingle maker's ventilation requirement. Owens Corning's home buyer guide warns that improper attic ventilation can affect or void certain warranties. Our deck, underlayment and ventilation guide covers the details.
Does the quote include permit fees and the dumpster?
It should, and it should say so. Permit costs and rules vary by city:
- Dallas requires a Residential Roofing Permit when the roofing work exceeds $500.
- Houston requires a residential roofing permit (with the CE-1109 re-roof worksheet) through iPermits, and the permit and worksheet must be on site for inspection.
- San Antonio requires a permit any time a roof is replaced. Its homeowner guide lists a $26.50 fee, but the handout is undated, so confirm the current fee with the city.
- Austin exempts some like-for-like roof covering replacements from permits, with exceptions in the wildland-urban interface area.
- Florida reroofs generally need a permit. A 2026 law requires local governments to exempt some single-family work under $7,500 on written request, but it excludes structural work and flood-hazard-area properties. Ask your building official how it applies to your roof.
- Texas coast (TWIA area): most roof replacements need a TDI windstorm inspection and certificate. TDI does not regulate those inspection fees.
Dumpster, haul-off and landfill fees should be in the bid, with where the dumpster will sit and who repairs driveway damage.
What is a 'full system' warranty, and why does it change the price?
Shingle makers sell layered warranties:
| Tier | What it typically covers | What it requires |
|---|---|---|
| Standard limited lifetime (materials) | Manufacturing defects in the shingles. Owens Corning's standard warranty reduces coverage after 25 years based on roof age. | Correct installation per instructions and code; any installer |
| System warranty | Longer full coverage on shingles plus listed accessories | A minimum number of the maker's components (Owens Corning: hip and ridge plus 2 others) |
| Top extended warranty | Longer non-prorated materials coverage, plus workmanship coverage for installation errors | More components (Owens Corning: hip and ridge, underlayment, plus 2 others) and a certified contractor (Platinum or Preferred, or Platinum only for the top tier) |
The higher tiers cost more because they require the maker's own starter, hip and ridge, underlayment and vents instead of generic parts, plus a certified installer and sometimes a registration fee. Owens Corning notes its warranties exclude tear-off and disposal costs if required.
When comparing bids, make sure they quote the same tier. One bid with a top-tier warranty is not comparable to another with the standard warranty. See our roof warranty guide.
Red flags in a roofing estimate
- Vague scope: 'Replace roof, 30-year shingles, labor and materials.' No line items, no brand, no square count.
- 'Or equal' substitutions: 'Architectural shingle, GAF or equal.' This lets the roofer swap in a cheaper product. Insist on brand, line and color, with any substitution only by your written approval.
- No unit price for decking or other hidden conditions.
- 'Reuse existing flashing' everywhere with no explanation.
- Missing code items that other bids include.
- A price far below the others with no explanation. Florida's consumer advocate lists an estimate notably lower or significantly higher than others as a red flag.
- Lump-sum bids tied to an insurance claim. Florida law bars contractors from giving an insured a repair agreement without a good-faith itemized estimate.
- Deductible 'discounts' or a price that conveniently equals the insurance payout minus nothing. Covering your deductible is illegal in both states.
Should I take the cheapest roofing quote?
Only if it is the same scope as the others, from a verified company, with the same warranty. After you level the bids (add the missing items to the cheaper ones at the roofer's own unit prices), the 'cheapest' often isn't.
For context, the 2025 Cost vs. Value report priced a full asphalt shingle replacement on its benchmark house at $27,116 in the West South Central region (which includes Texas) and $32,253 in the South Atlantic region (which includes Florida). City figures ranged from $22,966 in San Antonio to $39,729 in Miami. These are for one standardized large roof with full tear-off, so they are a sanity check, not a target for your house. Online 'average cost' figures from lead-generation sites can be much lower because they price different jobs.
Can I negotiate a roofing quote?
Yes, but negotiate scope, not just price:
- Ask each roofer to match the others' scope, then compare.
- Ask about timing. Some roofers have more flexibility outside storm season.
- Choose a different shingle line or color that is in stock.
- Drop extras you don't need (for example, gutter replacement if gutters are sound).
- Ask whether paying by check vs card changes the price.
What not to do: don't ask a roofer to absorb your insurance deductible or to bill the insurer for things that won't be installed. That is illegal in Texas and Florida and can expose you to insurance fraud claims.
Insurance jobs: comparing to the adjuster's estimate
If insurance is paying, put the adjuster's estimate in a fourth column. Line items the adjuster missed, like code-required drip edge or Florida's secondary water barrier, are worth raising with the insurer in writing. TWIA encourages line-item contractor estimates that break out labor and materials and will compare them with its adjuster's estimate. In Florida, you are generally not required to pay for code-required upgrades beyond your deductible unless your policy specifically excludes or limits them. See storm damage claims step by step.
How to choose a provider
- Ask every roofer for an itemized written estimate.
- Get the measured square count, pitch and waste factor from each.
- Check the math: footprint x pitch factor, plus waste, divided by 100.
- Confirm full tear-off and the number of layers being removed.
- Get a per-sheet price for decking, with photo approval before extra sheets.
- Florida: confirm secondary water barrier and deck re-nailing are included.
- Confirm new drip edge, starter, hip and ridge, and flashing.
- Ask for the ventilation plan, intake and exhaust.
- Confirm permit, inspection, dumpster, disposal and cleanup are included.
- Texas coast: confirm the TDI windstorm inspection is in the bid.
- Make sure all bids quote the same warranty tier.
- Reject 'or equal' language unless substitutions need your written approval.
- Level the bids before comparing totals.
Related roofing guides
- How to Choose a Roofing Contractor: 30 Questions to Ask (and the Answers That Should Worry You)
- Roofing Contract Checklist: What Must Be in Writing in Texas and Florida
- How Much Does a New Roof Cost in Texas and Florida? (What Actually Drives the Price)
- What's Under Your Shingles: Decking, Underlayment, Secondary Water Barrier and Ventilation Explained
- Roof Warranties Explained: Manufacturer vs Workmanship, Transferability, and What Voids Them
- How to Measure a Roof and Estimate Squares (With Pitch Multipliers)
- Florida Building Code for Roofs: HVHZ, Miami-Dade NOAs, and the 2026 9th Edition Changes
- Do I Need a Permit to Replace My Roof? Texas and Florida City-by-City Basics
Roofing by state and city
Questions people ask
What should be included in a roofing estimate?
A complete estimate lists the square count and waste factor, tear-off layers, decking price per sheet, underlayment type, drip edge, starter, field shingles or tile by brand and color, hip and ridge, valleys, flashing, pipe boots, ventilation, gutters, permit, disposal, cleanup, manufacturer warranty name, workmanship warranty, schedule and payment terms. In Florida it should also show the secondary water barrier and deck attachment method.
What is a reasonable waste factor on a roof quote?
This Old House suggests adding about 15% to measured squares for a typical shingle roof. Simple gable roofs may need less, and complex roofs with many hips, valleys and dormers may need more. If one bid's waste is far higher than another's, ask why. If it is far lower, ask whether starter and cap material are counted separately.
What is the cost of replacing rotten decking per sheet?
We could not find a reliable, dated public source for a typical Texas or Florida per-sheet price, so compare the unit prices in your own bids. A good bid states the price per 4x8 sheet installed, the material and thickness, how many sheets are included, and requires photos and your approval before replacing more.
Is ice and water shield needed in Texas or Florida?
Code-required ice barriers apply only where there is a history of ice damming, which does not include most of Texas or Florida. But Florida requires a secondary water barrier on site-built single-family reroofs, and self-adhered membrane is one way to meet it. On the Texas coast, TDI recommends a secondary water barrier. Most roofers also use membrane in valleys and around penetrations.
Should my quote include new underlayment, drip edge and flashing?
Yes for underlayment and drip edge on a full replacement; the model code requires drip edge at eaves and rakes of shingle roofs. Flashing should be replaced unless the roofer can explain why existing metal is sound and compatible. Reused, rusted or caulked flashing is a common leak source, and the 2026 Florida code expands where flashing is required.
Why do roofers measure my roof differently?
Some measure by hand, some use aerial reports, and some estimate from the floor area. Differences in pitch assumptions, overhangs, and how waste is counted all change the total. Ask each roofer for the measured surface area before waste and the waste percentage separately. Then the numbers can be compared fairly.
Do I need a permit for a roof replacement in Texas?
It depends on the city. Dallas requires a roofing permit for work over $500, Houston requires one for reroofs through iPermits, and San Antonio requires one any time a roof is replaced. Austin exempts some like-for-like shingle replacements. On the coast, TWIA eligibility usually also requires a TDI windstorm inspection. Your roofer should pull the permit.
Sources
- This Old House, How to measure a roof for shingles
- Owens Corning, DIY roofing: measuring roof squares
- International Residential Code 2021, Chapter 9 (UpCodes)
- Tex. Local Gov't Code ch. 214 (residential building code)
- Fla. Stat. 553.844, Windstorm loss mitigation; roofing requirements (2026)
- Fla. Stat. 553.79, Permits (2026)
- Fla. Stat. 489.147, Prohibited property insurance practices (2026)
- Fla. Stat. 626.9744, Claim settlement practices; matching and code upgrades (2026)
- FRSA, 2026 FBC updates (recover vs replacement)
- FRSA, Additional 2026 FBC changes (flashing)
- Miami-Dade RER, 9th Edition FBC roofing underlayment
- Miami-Dade RER, 9th Edition FBC hip and ridge shingles
- Florida Building Commission, 2026 FBC workplan
- City of Tampa, 9th Edition building code announcement
- IBHS FORTIFIED Roof
- TDI, Windstorm building FAQ
- TDI, Do you need a windstorm inspection?
- TWIA, Policyholders
- Owens Corning, Roofing warranty information
- Owens Corning, Home buyer's roofing warranty guide
- CertainTeed, Residential roofing warranties
- City of Dallas, Building inspection guide
- Houston Permitting Center, Residential roofing permit
- City of San Antonio DSD, Home remodeling guide
- City of Austin, Work exempt from building permits
- Florida DFS, Don't Be a Victim: Prevent Contractor Fraud and Abuse
- JLC Cost vs. Value 2025, West South Central
- JLC Cost vs. Value 2025, South Atlantic
- JLC Cost vs. Value 2025, San Antonio
- JLC Cost vs. Value 2025, Miami
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


