Local Guide · Hurricane shutters and impact windows
Hurricane Window Myths: Does Tape, Window Film, Cracking a Window or Double-Pane Glass Protect Your Home?
Taping windows, cracking a window to equalize pressure, and trusting security film are some of the most repeated hurricane tips, and none of them is opening protection. Here is what the building code, IBHS, FLASH and the Texas Department of Insurance actually say, myth by myth.
Tape does not protect windows. IBHS says taping "provides no protection and even wastes valuable time," and FLASH tells homeowners not to tape. Opening windows to equalize pressure is also wrong: IBHS explains that wind entering a home creates internal pressure that pushes up on the roof and out on the walls. Real protection is impact-rated windows or shutters tested to standards such as ASTM E1886 and E1996 and listed with a product approval. Window film, ordinary double-pane glass and tempered glass are not impact protection on their own.
Key facts
- IBHS: "Taping windows provides no protection and even wastes valuable time."
- FLASH, the Federal Alliance for Safe Homes, tells homeowners preparing for hurricane season to strengthen their homes and "DO NOT tape your windows."
- IBHS says broken windows let in wind and rain and create internal pressures that push up and out on the roof and walls.
- Florida law (s. 553.842(5)) bars advertising or selling a product as hurricane, windstorm or wind-borne-debris impact protection unless it has state product approval; violators face the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act.
- The Florida Building Code (s. 1609.1.2) requires glazed openings in wind-borne debris regions to be impact resistant or covered by a product tested to standards such as ASTM E1886 and E1996, TAS 201, 202 and 203, or AAMA 506.
- TDI warns that a product rated for "Force 12" winds only meets the minimum of a Category 1 hurricane (74 mph).
- Ready.gov: "Historically, storm surge is the leading cause of hurricane-related deaths in the United States."
- Florida's Division of Emergency Management says people in an ordered evacuation zone, a low-lying flood area or a mobile home should follow all evacuation orders.
- On Florida's 2026 wind mitigation form, coverings that look rated but lack documentation are Level N, rated "Ordinary" rather than "Hurricane" for discount purposes.
Why hurricane window myths matter
Most hurricane myths are about windows because windows are the easiest part of a house to break and the most expensive to protect properly. A $5 roll of tape looks like a bargain next to a set of shutters. The problem is that a myth does not just fail. It gives you a false sense of safety, and it uses up the hours before landfall when you could have put up real protection or left.
The test for every myth on this page is simple. Building codes in Florida and Texas treat a window as protected only when the window, or something covering it, has been tested to resist the impact of wind-borne debris and repeated wind pressure. In Florida, s. 1609.1.2 of the Florida Building Code lists the accepted tests: ASTM E1886 and E1996, TAS 201, 202 and 203, AAMA 506 and ANSI/DASMA 115 for garage doors. TDI tells Texas homeowners to use only opening protection tested to ASTM E1886 and E1996 and designated by a recognized product approval. If a product or a trick has not passed those tests, it is not opening protection. Our guide to missile impact testing standards explains the tests.
| Myth | Verdict | What to do instead |
|---|---|---|
| Tape stops windows from breaking | False | Shutters, impact windows, or code-compliant panels |
| Crack a window to equalize pressure | False and harmful | Keep every opening closed and protected |
| Security window film is hurricane protection | Not on its own | Check for a product approval before you rely on any product |
| Double-pane glass is hurricane-proof | False | Look for an impact rating, not a pane count |
| Tempered glass is impact-rated | False | Impact glazing is a tested assembly |
| "Hurricane-rated" means impact-rated | Not necessarily | Ask for the test standard and approval number |
| Impact windows mean I can stay | False | Evacuation is about surge, flooding and orders |
| Shutters protect from storm surge | False | Elevation, flood vents, flood insurance |
| Closing blinds or curtains helps | Only slightly, against small glass | Stay in an interior room away from windows |
Myth 1: Taping windows keeps them from breaking
This is the oldest and most persistent myth. IBHS, the insurance research group behind the FORTIFIED program, is blunt: "Taping windows provides no protection and even wastes valuable time." FLASH tells homeowners to strengthen their homes before hurricane season and, in capital letters, "DO NOT tape your windows."
Why it fails: tape does not make glass stronger. A flying roof tile, branch or piece of fence hits with far more force than tape can resist. The HVHZ large-missile test in the Florida Building Code, for example, fires a 9-pound 2x4 at 50 feet per second. Tape does nothing against that. Once the glass breaks, the opening is open, whatever is stuck to it.
Some people believe tape at least holds the pieces together. Even if a few pieces stick, the opening still lets in wind and rain, which is the failure IBHS warns about. The goal is not a neater break. The goal is to keep the opening closed.
What to do instead
- Close tested shutters or panels over every window and glass door. See types of hurricane shutters.
- If you have no shutters, IBHS says to use plywood "at least ¾ inch thick" as a last resort. The Florida code allows thinner 7/16-inch wood structural panels on some one- and two-family homes, but only with a maximum 44-inch span between fastener lines and permanently installed corrosion-resistant anchors. See DIY plywood hurricane protection.
- Stay away from windows during high winds.
Myth 2: Crack a window to equalize the pressure
The idea is that a hurricane's low pressure outside will make the house "explode" unless you let air out. None of the safety and building authorities we checked recommend this, and the research points the other way.
The real danger is wind getting inside. IBHS explains that when a window breaks, wind and rain enter the home and create "internal pressures that push up and out on the roof and walls." It describes the same chain of events when a garage door is pushed in: pressure builds inside the home, pushing up on the roof and out on the walls, "often causing significant structural damage." An open window on the windward side does exactly what a broken window does. It invites wind in.
That is why the building codes in both states require protection on all glazed openings in wind-borne debris regions, not vents. Florida's code requires glazed openings to be impact resistant or protected. Texas adopted the 2024 IRC and IBC for windstorm certification starting April 1, 2026, and TDI says most designated catastrophe areas are now in the windborne debris region, where those codes require protection. Neither code asks you to leave a window open.
What to do instead: close and latch every window and door, close every shutter, and brace the garage door if it is not wind rated. Then move to an interior room.
Myth 3: Security window film protects against hurricanes
Security film is a clear plastic layer stuck to the inside of the glass. It can help hold broken glass in place, which may reduce flying shards. That is not the same as keeping the opening closed. In a hurricane, a window that cracks and then falls out of the frame, or bows in under pressure, has still failed.
Three things to know before you pay for film as "hurricane protection":
- Florida law controls the marketing. Under s. 553.842(5), a product may not be advertised, sold, offered or marketed as hurricane, windstorm or wind-borne-debris impact protection unless it is approved under the state product approval system (s. 553.842 or s. 553.8425). A seller who makes that claim without approval faces the Florida Deceptive and Unfair Trade Practices Act.
- Approvals cover whole systems. Impact approvals cover a tested assembly, including how it is attached to the frame and wall. TDI makes the same point about impact windows: they are tested as a unit, meaning glass, frame, attachment hardware and installation method. A film stuck to the glass of a window that was never tested as an impact unit is not the same thing.
- The insurance form is strict. Florida's 2026 wind mitigation form (OIR-B1-1802, Rev. 04/26) gives Level A or B credit only to products listed as wind-borne debris protection in the Florida or Miami-Dade product approval systems. Coverings that cannot be identified as A, B or C are Level N, rated "Ordinary" instead of "Hurricane" in the form's discount factor table.
The Chronicle did not find any Florida product approval or Miami-Dade NOA that treats an aftermarket window film alone as impact protection for a residential window. That does not prove none exists. If a seller tells you their film is approved, ask for the FL number or NOA, and look it up yourself. Our guides to the Florida product approval lookup and Miami-Dade NOA lookup show how. Read what the approval actually covers: the product, the opening sizes, the anchoring and any limits.
In Texas, TDI says to use only opening protection tested to ASTM E1886 and E1996 and designated by a recognized product approval. The same question applies: ask for the product evaluation and read it.
Myth 4: Storm windows are the same as impact windows
"Storm window" is a loose term. In much of the country it means an extra pane added outside or inside an existing window to cut drafts. Those are energy products. They are not tested for wind-borne debris unless the label and approval say so.
An impact window is a complete window that passed missile impact and cyclic pressure tests. In Miami-Dade and Broward, the High-Velocity Hurricane Zone (HVHZ) tests are especially demanding. A specimen takes two hits from a 9-pound 2x4, then 9,000 cycles of positive and negative pressure. It passes only if all three specimens resist the impacts without penetration and finish the pressure cycles with no crack longer than 5 inches and wider than 1/16 inch through which air can pass. That is why an impact window is a different product, not an add-on.
If someone offers "storm windows," ask: what test standard, what approval number, and what design pressure? See impact windows explained and design pressure ratings explained.
Myth 5: Double-pane windows are hurricane-proof
Double-pane (insulating) glass is two panes with a sealed air or gas space between them. It is an energy feature. Two thin panes of ordinary glass can both break from a single piece of debris.
Some impact windows are double-pane, which adds to the confusion. In those windows, one or more of the layers is laminated glass with a strong interlayer, and the whole unit was tested. The pane count is not what makes it impact rated. The test and the approval are.
How to check your own windows: look for a permanent label or an etched mark in a corner of the glass, then match it to a product approval. In Florida, Citizens Property Insurance tells policyholders to give their wind mitigation inspector NOA letters for mitigation products so features that are not clearly marked still earn credit. Without documents, the inspector may have to mark the opening as unverified.
Myth 6: Tempered glass is impact-rated
Tempered glass is safety glass. It is heat-treated so that when it breaks, it shatters into small pieces instead of long, sharp shards. That makes it safer for doors and showers. It does not keep a window closed after a hit. Once tempered glass breaks, the whole pane usually comes out.
Impact glazing is usually laminated, meaning it has a plastic interlayer that holds the broken glass in the frame. Even then, what qualifies it is passing the tests. The Florida Building Code requires glazed openings in wind-borne debris regions within 30 feet of grade to meet the large missile test of ASTM E1996, and openings higher than 30 feet to meet the small missile test.
Myth 7: A "hurricane-rated" label means impact-rated
Marketing words vary. TDI warns that a product rated for "Force 12" winds only meets the minimum of a Category 1 hurricane, which starts at 74 mph. A window can also carry a good design pressure rating, meaning it resists wind pressure, without being impact rated.
What you want to see on a quote and on the product:
- The impact standard (for example ASTM E1886 and E1996, or TAS 201, 202 and 203 in the HVHZ).
- The missile level (large missile for openings within 30 feet of grade in Florida).
- The design pressure, positive and negative, for that opening.
- The Florida product approval number or Miami-Dade NOA, or in Texas, the recognized product evaluation.
In Florida, labeling is required. The building code requires shutter manufacturers to put a permanent label on every impact-resistant covering showing the approval holder, the approval method, the test standards and the approval number where one exists. For a full checklist of what a quote should show, see how to compare impact window and shutter quotes.
Myth 8: With impact windows, I don't need to evacuate
Impact windows and shutters address wind and wind-borne debris. Evacuation orders are mostly about water. Ready.gov states: "Historically, storm surge is the leading cause of hurricane-related deaths in the United States." The Florida Climate Center at Florida State University notes that roughly 90% of hurricane deaths worldwide are caused by drowning in storm surge or in flooding from intense rain, and that surge in the strongest storms can reach 25 feet above normal water levels.
No window rating changes how high the water rises around your house. Florida's Division of Emergency Management says that if you are in an ordered evacuation zone, a low-lying flood area or a mobile home, you should follow all evacuation orders. Florida's evacuation zones run from A (first to evacuate) onward. Check yours at floridadisaster.org/knowyourzone. In Texas, check with your county or city emergency management office, as the National Weather Service advises.
Protection does help in another way: if you evacuate, a home with closed shutters or impact windows is more likely to stay sealed while you are gone. Close everything before you leave.
Myth 9: Shutters protect against storm surge
Shutters and impact windows are tested for impact and air pressure, not for standing or moving water. Surge water pushes on walls and doors from the outside, floods through doors, garages and vents, and can carry debris far heavier than any test missile. Ready.gov's advice when trapped by flooding is to go to the highest level of the building and never walk, swim or drive through flood water.
Flood protection is a separate subject: elevation, flood vents, flood-resistant materials and flood insurance. Standard homeowners and renters policies do not cover flood. Florida's landlord flood disclosure law (s. 83.512) puts it plainly in the required tenant notice: "Renters' insurance policies do not include coverage for damage resulting from floods."
Myth 10: Closing the blinds or curtains is enough
Blinds and curtains may catch some small glass if a window breaks, which is better than nothing. They do not stop debris, wind or rain. IBHS's advice for people without protection is to stay away from windows during high winds. The National Weather Service gives similar shelter advice for tornadoes: get to an interior room away from windows.
A practical plan for a home with no shutters: pick one interior room or hallway with no windows, put shoes, a flashlight and water there, and stay there during the worst of the storm.
More myths we hear about shutters and impact windows
"Impact windows never break."
They can crack. The test pass criteria allow cracking, as long as the missile does not penetrate and the cracks stay within limits after pressure cycling. After a storm, a cracked impact pane may still be holding, but it needs to be inspected and replaced. Florida's 2026 wind mitigation form marks damaged openings as Level Z, which knocks out opening protection credit until they are fixed. See after-the-storm repairs and claims.
"You need both impact windows and shutters."
TDI says installing both shutters and impact windows is not necessary. One properly tested and installed system is enough for code. See impact windows vs hurricane shutters.
"My house was built to code, so it's protected."
IBHS calls this a myth too. It says codes set minimum standards, vary by region and state, and may not include the latest wind research. Older Florida homes built before the statewide code, and many Texas homes outside the coastal catastrophe areas, may have no opening protection at all. See code rules for replacing windows in existing homes.
"The garage door doesn't matter."
IBHS calls the garage door "the largest opening in a home" and "one of its most vulnerable areas." See hurricane-rated garage doors.
"I can close shutters over every bedroom window."
You can during a storm threat. Florida's residential code allows shutters and panels on emergency escape openings during the threat of a storm, but at least one means of escape on the first floor must stay available, and everyone in the home must be able to reach it without passing through a lockable door they do not control. Do not leave escape windows shuttered for weeks. See rules on leaving shutters up.
"My insurance will pay for everything."
IBHS lists this as a myth as well. It notes that some policies do not cover full replacement cost and that wind or hurricane deductibles can be a percentage of the home's value. Check your deductible before the season.
How to choose a provider
- Throw out the tape plan; it gives no protection.
- Find your evacuation zone (floridadisaster.org/knowyourzone in Florida; your county or city emergency management office in Texas).
- Check every window and glass door for an impact label or etched mark, and match it to a product approval.
- Ask any seller of film, storm windows or "hurricane-rated" products for the test standard and the FL number, Miami-Dade NOA or Texas product evaluation, then look it up.
- If you rely on plywood, pre-cut and label panels and install permanent anchors now, not when a storm is forecast.
- Brace or replace a non-rated garage door.
- Keep at least one first-floor means of escape open when shutters are closed.
- Pick an interior, windowless room to shelter in during high winds.
- Review your wind or hurricane deductible and whether you have separate flood coverage.
Related hurricane shutters and impact windows guides
- Missile Impact Tests Explained: What Are the Large and Small Missile Tests, ASTM E1996/E1886 and TAS 201/202/203?
- What Are Impact Windows and How Do They Survive a Hurricane? Laminated Glass, Frames and Ratings Explained
- Can You Use Plywood for Hurricane Shutters? Code Rules, Thickness, Fasteners and Where Plywood Is Not Allowed
- Florida Product Approval (FL Number): How Do You Search floridabuilding.org and Verify Windows, Doors and Shutters?
- Impact Windows vs. Hurricane Shutters: Which Protection Is Right for Your Home or Business?
- What Is a Hurricane-Rated Garage Door? Wind Load vs. Impact Ratings, Bracing Kits and How to Read the Label
- What Are the Types of Hurricane Shutters? Accordion, Roll-Down, Panels, Fabric, Colonial and Bahama Compared
Hurricane shutters and impact windows by state and city
Questions people ask
Should I tape my windows before a hurricane?
No. IBHS says taping windows provides no protection and wastes valuable time, and FLASH tells homeowners not to tape their windows. Tape does not make glass stronger, and once debris breaks the glass the opening is open. Use tested shutters, impact windows or properly installed panels, and if you have none of those, shelter in an interior room away from windows.
Should I open a window to equalize pressure during a hurricane?
No. IBHS explains that when wind gets inside a home through a broken window or failed garage door, it creates internal pressure that pushes up on the roof and out on the walls, which can cause serious structural damage. An open window does the same thing. Keep every window, door and shutter closed and latched, and brace the garage door.
Does window film make my windows impact resistant?
Not by itself, based on what we could verify. Film can help hold broken glass together, but code-level protection requires a tested and approved product. Florida law bars marketing a product as wind-borne debris impact protection without state product approval. The Chronicle did not find a Florida approval or Miami-Dade NOA for film alone on residential windows; if a seller claims one, ask for the number and look it up.
Are double-pane windows hurricane-proof?
No. Double-pane glass is an energy feature. Two ordinary panes can both break from one piece of debris. Some impact windows are double-pane, but what makes them impact rated is laminated glass and a passed test, documented by a product approval. Check for a label or etched mark and match it to a Florida approval, Miami-Dade NOA or Texas product evaluation.
Is tempered glass impact-rated?
No. Tempered glass is safety glass that breaks into small pieces, but the pane usually falls out when it breaks. Impact glazing is normally laminated and must pass missile impact and cyclic pressure tests, such as ASTM E1886 and E1996. Only a tested assembly with a product approval counts as impact protection under the Florida Building Code or for TDI windstorm certification.
What does Force 12 mean on a window or shutter?
TDI warns that a product rated for Force 12 winds only meets the minimum of a Category 1 hurricane, which starts at 74 mph. It is not the same as an impact rating or a design pressure for your opening. Ask for the impact test standard, the missile level, the design pressure and the approval number.
If I have impact windows, can I ignore an evacuation order?
No. Impact windows address wind and debris, not water. Ready.gov says storm surge has historically been the leading cause of hurricane deaths in the United States, and Florida's Division of Emergency Management tells people in ordered evacuation zones, low-lying flood areas and mobile homes to follow all evacuation orders. Close your protection and leave when told to.
Do I need impact windows and shutters both?
No. TDI says installing both shutters and impact windows is not necessary. One properly tested, approved and installed system meets the code. Some owners add shutters over impact glass for extra security or to keep glass from cracking, but it is a choice, not a requirement.
Sources
- Understanding Wind Risks: Common Myths and How to Protect Your Home (FORTIFIED/IBHS)
- Before the Storm: A Homeowner's Guide to Hurricane Readiness (FORTIFIED/IBHS)
- FLASH: Hurricane
- TDI Windstorm: protecting openings FAQ
- TDI Windstorm: adopted codes
- Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 16 Structural Design
- Florida Building Code 2023, Chapter 17 Special Inspections and Tests
- Florida Building Code, Residential 2023, Chapter 3
- Florida Statutes s. 553.842, product evaluation and approval
- Form OIR-B1-1802, Rev. 04/26
- Citizens Property Insurance: your wind inspection
- Ready.gov: Hurricanes
- Florida Division of Emergency Management: Know Your Zone
- National Weather Service: Hurricane preparedness plan
- National Weather Service: Tornado safety, during
- Florida Climate Center (FSU): Hurricanes
- Florida Statutes s. 83.512, flood disclosure to tenants
This guide was written by our editorial team from the public sources listed above. It is general information, not legal advice; confirm licensing and terms directly with any provider.


